SPOILER ALERT If you haven't read the most recent chapter and are looking for a walkthrough, be aware that the page is full of spoilers.
This page contains the choices in The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story and their outcomes.
This mini-game revolves around the choices you make. However in this story, they only affect things in the short term. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the choice for the game that they want. Good luck and happy playing!
Most choices have no outcome and thus no outcomes are listed on the side. If there are any outcomes that do make a difference that are not listed, please add them. Thanks.
Setup Choices
Choice 1
Face 1
Face 2
Face 3
Face 4
Choice 2
Playing with Fire
The Classic
Blondes Have More Fun
Turn Up the Volume
Curl Power
Braid Runner
Choice 3
Stripe Right
Honey Dijon
Romp Around the Rosie
Choice 4
This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
Default is "Emily".
Chapter One: Stranger Than Fiction Choices
Choice 1
Don't be a jerk! (No effect)
You're gonna exorcise the ghosts, right? (No effect)
Choice 2
Take it easy. (No effect)
Go crazy! (No effect)
Choice 3
You're using me and my friends as characters. (No effect)
Everyone's behaving so strangely. (No effect)
Choice 4
Serial killer. (💎12) (Mass Word-Erer ) (Serial Killer Path)
Werewolf. (💎12) (Pup Fiction ) (Werewolf Path)
Swamp Monster, actually. (Speed Reeder ) (Swamp Monster Path)
Choice 5
Chris
Kaitlyn
James
Zig
Becca
Choice 6 (Chris)
It's actually weird. (No effect)
It's actually hilarious! (No effect)
Choice 7 (Chris)
I'd love to get the real Chris shirtless (💎30)
Reading that kind of killed the mood... (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1 (Chris)
Or should I call you Chad ? (No effect)
Please never reference that scene again...(No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Chris)
I want to take all your clothes off. (No effect)
Why don't we cuddle tonight? (No effect)
Choice 6 (Kaitlyn)
Pretty hilarious! (No effect)
Really weird... (No effect)
Choice 7 (Kaitlyn)
Let's get rapturous . (💎30)
That story kind of killed the mood... (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1 (Kaitlyn)
I know we'd survive together. (No effect)
We'd die by each other's side. (No effect)
You'd definitely be the monster! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Kaitlyn)
Why don't we take it all the way? (No effect)
Let's spend all night snuggling. (No effect)
Choice 6 (James)
A fun read. (No effect)
Pretty trashy. (No effect)
Hard to say. (No effect)
Choice 7 (James)
Get this sleepover started (💎30)
Save it for another time. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1 (James)
A jock. (No effect)
A loner. (No effect)
Yourself (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (James)
Get frisky (No effect)
Snuggle up (No effect)
Choice 6 (Zig)
Definitely weird. (No effect)
Kind of hilarious, actually. (No effect)
Choice 7 (Zig)
We should have a little fun (💎30)
I'm not in the mood after reading that.
Diamond Choice 1 (Zig)
Good girl. (No effect)
Bad girl. (No effect)
Evil mastermind. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Zig)
Get these clothes off? (No effect)
Just cuddle for a bit? (No effect)
Choice 6 (Becca)
I think it's a little weird. (No effect)
It is pretty funny so far. (No effect)
Choice 7 (Becca)
Why don't I cheer you up? (💎30)
I'll ask Twombly to add you to the book.
Diamond Choice 1 (Becca)
Trophy wife. (No effect)
Muse. (No effect)
Collaborator. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Becca)
Make your wildest dreams come true. (No effect)
Keep things tame tonight. (No effect)
Choice 8
It's just chili sauce. (No effect)
It's from an accident. (No effect)
Something bad happened here. (No effect)
Choice 9
The owner was paranoid. (No effect)
There are wild animals in the woods. (No effect)
He was trying to keep something in , not out. (No effect)
Choice 10
Can handle himself. (No effect)
Will distract all the hungry animals. (No effect)
Chapter Two: I Know What You Did Last Quarter... Choices
Choice 1
Pretty hilarious. (No effect)
Really weird. (No effect)
Exactly what you'd expect. (No effect)
Choice 2
Warrior Woman (💎25)
Super Lady (💎25)
Pumpkin Person (No effect)
Choice 3
This is a costume party, FYI. (No effect)
Since when are you into TC&TF? (No effect)
Choice 4
Definitely dead. (No effect)
Probably dead. (No effect)
Alive and kicking! (No effect)
Choice 5
Kind of sad. (No effect)
A good thing, trust me. (No effect)
Choice 6
We could all drive away together. (No effect)
Tyler could go alone. (No effect)
I think it's fine as is. (No effect)
Choice 7
Run away! (No effect)
Face whatever's waiting head on! (No effect)
Werewolf and Serial Killer route has an extra dialogue choice
Diamond Choice 1 (Serial Killer Path)
Newspaper Clippings (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Serial Killer Path)
Someone we know! (No effect)
Some random person! (No effect)
Twombly! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 3 (Serial Killer Path)
Go through first! (No effect)
Help you guys first, I guess. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 4 (Serial Killer Path)
Caitlin. (No effect)
Jim. (No effect)
Whoever you pick will be in the next scene with you.
Diamond Choice 5 (Serial Killer Path)
Think you should check it out. (No effect)
Want to check it myself. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 6 (Serial Killer Path)
Reach for the axe! (No effect)
Pull Rebekah's hair! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 7 (Serial Killer Path)
Survive! (💎17)
Die Majestically! (Skip Diamond Choices 8 and 9)
Diamond Choice 8 (Serial Killer Path)
Hide! (No effect)
Ambush Rebekah! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 9 (Serial Killer Path)
Dive in front of Skyler! (No effect)
Save myself! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1 (Werewolf Path)
Shredded Clothes (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Werewolf Path)
Someone we know. (No effect)
Someone we don't know. (No effect)
Jim. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 3 (Werewolf Path)
Go through first! (No effect)
Help you guys first, I guess. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 4 (Werewolf Path)
Caitlin. (No effect)
Jim. (No effect)
Whoever you pick will be in the next scene with you.
Diamond Choice 5 (Werewolf Path)
Dodge it! (No effect)
Block its strike! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 6 (Werewolf Path)
Hit the wolf with a branch! (No effect)
Hide behind the tree trunk! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 7 (Werewolf Path)
Survive! (💎17)
Die Majestically! (Skip Diamond Choices 8 and 9)
Diamond Choice 8 (Werewolf Path)
Make a final stand! (No effect)
Escape from the werewolf! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 9 (Werewolf Path)
Save her! (No effect)
Let her fall! (No effect)
Choice 8 (Swamp Monster Path)
Zag. (No effect)
A stranger. (No effect)
Someone we know. (No effect)
Choice 9 (Swamp Monster Path)
Go through first! (No effect)
Help you guys first, I guess. (No effect)
Choice 10 (Swamp Monster Path)
Caitlin. (No effect)
Jim. (No effect)
Whoever you pick will be in the next scene with you.
Choice 11 (Swamp Monster Path)
Dodge the vines! (No effect)
Throw a rock at its head! (No effect)
Choice 12 (Swamp Monster Path)
Survive! (💎17)
Die majestically! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1 (Swamp Monster Path)
Face the Becca monster! (No effect)
Trap the Becca monster! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2 (Swamp Monster Path)
Sneak upstairs. (No effect)
Push Rebekah into the furnace. (No effect)
You have reached the end of The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story .
Walkthroughs
Pilot Books
Boardroom Alpha Choices • Do No Harm, Book 1 Choices • Our Summer Crush Choices • The Spy I Married Choices • The Royal Wedding Planner Choices
Chat Books
Texts From HSS Choices • Knock Knock Choices • The Shadow Choices
The Freshman
The Freshman, Book 1 Choices • The Freshman, Book 2 Choices • The Freshman, Book 3 Choices • The Freshman, Book 4 Choices • The Freshman: Love Bites Choices • The Freshman: Game of Love Choices • The Freshman: Snowed In Choices • The Freshman: Luxury Getaway Choices • The Freshman: Masquerade Ball Choices • The Freshman: The Perfect Date Choices
The Crown & The Flame
The Crown & The Flame, Book 1 Choices • The Crown & The Flame, Book 2 Choices • The Crown & The Flame, Book 3 Choices
Most Wanted
Most Wanted Choices
Rules of Engagement
Rules of Engagement, Book 1 Choices • Rules of Engagement, Book 2 Choices • Rules of Engagement, Book 3 Choices • Rules of Engagement: Newlyweds Choices
Endless Summer
Endless Summer, Book 1 Choices • Endless Summer, Book 2 Choices • Endless Summer, Book 3 Choices
LoveHacks
LoveHacks, Book 1 Choices • LoveHacks, Book 2 Choices
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor Choices
The Royal Romance
The Royal Romance, Book 1 Choices • The Royal Romance, Book 2 Choices • The Royal Romance, Book 3 Choices • The Royal Holiday Choices
The Sophomore
The Sophomore, Book 1 Choices • The Sophomore, Book 2 Choices • The Sophomore: Hartfelt Horror Story Choices
Hero
Hero Choices
High School Story
High School Story, Book 1 Choices • Texts From HSS Choices • High School Story, Book 2 Choices • High School Story, Book 3 Choices • HSS: Class Act, Book 1 Choices • HSS: Class Act, Book 2 Choices • HSS: Class Act, Book 3 Choices
It Lives Anthology
It Lives in the Woods Choices • It Lives Beneath Choices
Home for the Holidays
Home for the Holidays Choices
Red Carpet Diaries
Red Carpet Diaries, Book 1 Choices • Red Carpet Diaries, Book 2 Choices • Red Carpet Diaries, Book 3 Choices
Perfect Match
Perfect Match, Book 1 Choices • Perfect Match, Book 2 Choices
Bloodbound
Bloodbound, Book 1 Choices • Bloodbound, Book 2 Choices • Bloodbound, Book 3 Choices • Bloodbound: Dark Solstice Choices • Bloodbound Origins Choices
The Junior
The Junior Choices
Veil of Secrets
Veil of Secrets Choices
America's Most Eligible
America's Most Eligible, Book 1 Choices • America's Most Eligible, Book 2 Choices • America's Most Eligible, Book 3 Choices
Desire & Decorum
Desire & Decorum, Book 1 Choices • Desire & Decorum, Book 2 Choices • Desire & Decorum, Book 3 Choices • Desire & Decorum: First Winter Choices
Across The Void
Across The Void Choices
The Senior
The Senior Choices
Big Sky Country
Big Sky Country, Book 1 Choices • Big Sky Country, Book 2 Choices
The Elementalists
The Elementalists, Book 1 Choices • The Elementalists, Book 2 Choices • The Elementalists: Winters Past Choices
A Courtesan of Rome
A Courtesan of Rome Choices
The Heist: Monaco
The Heist: Monaco Choices
Ride-or-Die: A Bad Boy Romance
Ride-or-Die: A Bad Boy Romance Choices
Open Heart
Open Heart Choices • Open Heart: Second Year Choices • Open Heart: Third Year Choices • Open Hearts on Fire Choices
Passport to Romance
Passport to Romance Choices
Wishful Thinking
Wishful Thinking Choices
Nightbound
Nightbound Choices
Platinum
Platinum Choices
The Royal Heir
The Royal Heir, Book 1 Choices • The Royal Heir, Book 2 Choices • The Royal Heir, Book 3 Choices • The Royal Finale Choices
Sunkissed
Sunkissed Choices
Bachelorette Party
Bachelorette Party Choices
Mother of the Year
Mother of the Year Choices
Save the Date
Save the Date Choices
The Royal Masquerade
The Royal Masquerade Choices
Baby Bump
Baby Bump, Book 1 Choices • Baby Bump, Book 2 Choices
Hot Couture
Hot Couture Choices
With Every Heartbeat
With Every Heartbeat Choices
Blades of Light & Shadow
Blades of Light & Shadow, Book 1 Choices • Blades of Light & Shadow, Book 2 Choices • Blades Official TTRPG Companion Choices • Blades of Light & Shadow, Book 3 Choices
A Very Scandalous Proposal
A Very Scandalous Proposal Choices
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Choices
Distant Shores
Distant Shores Choices
The Nanny Affair
The Nanny Affair, Book 1 Choices • The Nanny Affair, Book 2 Choices • The Nanny Affair, Book 3 Choices • The Dalton Affair Choices
The Unexpected Heiress
The Unexpected Heiress Choices
Queen B
Queen B, Book 1 Choices • Queen B, Book 2 Choices
My Two First Loves
My Two First Loves Choices
Ms. Match
Ms. Match Choices
Rising Tides
Rising Tides Choices
Wolf Bride
Wolf Bride Choices
Foreign Affairs
Foreign Affairs Choices
Slow Burn
Slow Burn Choices
Laws of Attraction
Laws of Attraction, Book 1 Choices • Laws of Attraction, Book 2 Choices
Shipwrecked
Shipwrecked Choices
Wake the Dead
Wake the Dead Choices
Surrender
Surrender, Book 1 Choices • Surrender, Book 2 Choices
Crimes of Passion
Crimes of Passion, Book 1 Choices • Crimes of Passion, Book 2 Choices • Crimes: The Proposal Choices • Crimes of Passion, Book 3 Choices
Untameable
Untameable Choices • Unbridled: An Untameable Story Choices
The Princess Swap
The Princess Swap Choices
The Cursed Heart
The Cursed Heart, Book 1 Choices • The Cursed Heart, Book 2 Choices
Immortal Desires
Immortal Desires, Book 1 Choices • Immortal Desires, Book 2 Choices • Immortal Desires Paths Not Taken Choices • Immortal Desires, Book 3 Choices
Murder at Homecoming
Murder at Homecoming Choices
The Phantom Agent
The Phantom Agent Choices
Guinevere
Guinevere Choices
Kiss of Death
Kiss of Death Choices
Getaway Girls
Getaway Girls Choices
Roommates with Benefits
Roommates With Benefits Choices • Rivals With Benefits Choices
First Comes Love
First Comes Love Choices
The Duchess Affair
The Duchess Affair Choices
Kindred
Kindred Choices
The Billionaire's Baby
The Billionaire's Baby Choices
Dirty Little Secrets
Dirty Little Secrets Choices
The Promise of Forever
The Promise of Forever, Book 1 Choices • The Promise of Forever, Book 2 Choices
Alpha
Alpha, Book 1 Choices • Alpha, Book 2 Choices
Ship of Dreams
Ship of Dreams Choices
Guarded
Guarded Choices
The Deadliest Game
The Deadliest Gambit Choices • The Deadliest Game Choices
Hot Shot
Hot Shot Choices • Face-Off: A Hot Shot Story Choices
Villainous Valentine
Villainous Valentine Choices
Along Came Treble
Along Came Treble Choices
The Ghost of Us
The Ghost of Us Choices
Filthy Rich
Filthy Rich Choices
Hearts on Fire
Open Hearts on Fire Choices • Hearts on Fire Choices
Terror Fest
Terror Fest Choices • Terror Fest Origins Choices
All of Us
All of Us: Her Story Choices • All of Us: His Story Choices
Plus One
Plus One Choices • Plus Two Choices
Tap That Date!
Tap That Date! Choices
Bitten
Bitten Choices
Years Apart
Years Apart Choices
Best Served Haute
Best Served Haute, Book 1 Choices • Best Served Haute, Book 2 Choices
The Holiday Bakeoff
The Holiday Bakeoff Choices
Boardroom Alpha
Boardroom Alpha Choices
Do No Harm
Do No Harm, Book 1 Choices
Inheritance
Inheritance Choices
Our Summer Crush
Our Summer Crush Choices
The Spy I Married
The Spy I Married Choices
Into the Woods
Into the Woods Choices
My Fake Valentine
My Fake Valentine Choices
Main Character Energy
Main Character Energy Choices
The Royal Wedding Planner
The Royal Wedding Planner Choices
The One
The One Choices
Better Off Wed
Better Off Wed Choices
Olympus Rising
Olympus Rising Choices
The Cursed Cloak
The Cursed Cloak Choices