The good, the bad, and the almost irrelevant. They are the miscellaneous characters that are there to answer that one question, explain away that one plot hole, assist in adding development to that actually relevant character, or give that good (or bad) advice. We usually never learn their names. They are there and they are gone as soon as they serve their purpose often never to be seen again. They may not be the most memorable but definitely have a role to play. If the "No Image" picture is used, it means that the particular character has only been mentioned and has never physically appeared.
Terror Fest
Chapter 1
Ann Baumgartner
She is your former high school English teacher. She's attacked by an unknown assailant two months prior to your return to Morilec Island, and she has two options for how to respond. In Chapter 4, Bex St. Regis tells you about the immediate aftermath of each choice.
If Mrs. Baumgartner pulls the fire alarm, the assailant attacks her in the hallway just before paramedics arrive to find her in a pool of blood. Detective Porter gives the scene a cursory glance before declining to write a report. If she runs away, the attacker kills her in the parking lot before apparently carrying her body back inside. Despite the bloody hallway and multiple stab wounds, the medical examiner rules her death to be a peaceful heart attack. Either outcome provides Bex with strong evidence pointing towards an official cover-up of the killer's murder spree.
Despite Bex heavily implying her death in both paths, you meet Mrs. Baumgartner in the hospital in Chapter 7 if she pulled the fire alarm. She has just completed her recovery and plans to leave Morilec to retire on the mainland. She's unable to recall the identity of her unmasked attacker due to trauma, but that she knew them and felt safe before they began their assault. All she remembers from the attack itself is a feeling of being manipulated and the smell of cherry blossoms, and she warns you to get away from the evil lurking on the island while you can.
Her character model resembles Edith from Save the Date.
Artie Atkins
You see him promoting his tourist trap prison tour and the history of Stabby Joe. When you confront him for trying to make a profit from real crimes, he claims you have no right to complain since Stabby Joe is your ancestor. He first appears as "Tour Guide." His character model resembles Luka from Laws of Attraction.
Bystander (1)
His character model resembles Sai from Sunkissed.
Bystander (2)
She says that maybe you should get the punishment that your ancestor should have gotten. Her character model resembles Davina Tierney from Roommates with Benefits.
Vendor
His character model resembles Javier from Rising Tides.
Bystander (3)
Her character model resembles a version of Reese from Surrender.
Stabby Joe Killer
At the party hosted by Destiny, they sneak up on Allen/Alana and slit his/her throat before chasing you. Depending on your choices, you can manage to evade them, and you can hurt them if you're armed with the knife. They eventually catch up to you and attempt to kill you, but only succeed in knocking you unconscious.
In Chapter 4, you can build a profile of the killer by examining their past victims that the Mayor has covered up. Based on the victims you examine, you determine that the killer is a young local who likes to get up close and personal with their victims. They stalk their victims because they saw something in them that inspires feelings of rage due to their victims having hope and optimism. Based on the fact that two different murders took place within 10 minutes of each other on opposite sides of the island, you theorize that there could be more than one killer.
In Chapter 6, you discover that their killing method is different from Stabby Joe's. While he tortured his victims by stabbing them repeatedly in the stomach before slitting their throat, this copycat gives their victims an almost peaceful death. In the same chapter, it is revealed that there were two copycat killers prior. One died in prison in the 1970s, while the other was active in the early 2000s and disappeared after 2003.
Chapter 2
Bystander (4)
After Allen/Alana's body is found, he accuses you of being the murderer. He appears first as "Guest," then as "Partygoer." His character model resembles Patryk Thorne from Crimes of Passion.
Officer (1)
His character model resembles Robert Gunderson from Open Heart.
Chapter 3
Officer (2)
Her character model resembles Minako from Perfect Match.
Chapter 4
Reporter
Her character model resembles Ellen Thompson from Wishful Thinking.
Samuel Brown
One of the Killer's earlier victims. He was the class valedictorian and had just been accepted to an Ivy League school on a full ride. He went to a party in the woods with his friends, got separated, and was never seen alive again. His suspected cause of death was drowning. His body was found by the northern shoreline. His character model resembles Garrett from Nightbound.
Grant Scott
One of the Killer's earlier victims. A husband and father of two, he was killed by a knife. Based on the wounds, you determine that his killer was experimenting and enjoying themself. His character model resembles a version of Alan Park from High School Story: Class Act.
Dr. Kavya Shanthakumar
She successfully led a push for free healthcare on the island. The police refused to believe she was murdered as she was unlikely to have enemies on the island.
If Lucky is still alive in Chapter 12, you learn that she "got into a screaming match" with Dr. Shanthakumar after learning her mother had been placed in the placebo group for the doctor's cancer drug trials.
Her character model resembles Medhani Kapoor from The Deadliest Game.
Angie Davis
An influencer who had a fight with Destiny. A few days after the argument, she turned up dead. Her character model resembles Emerald Phan from High School Story.
Annie Campbell
She was Stabby Joe's wife and regularly visited him in prison. She first appears as "Woman." Her character model resembles Constance Parsons from Desire & Decorum.
Chapter 5
Guy
He is attending the Terror Fest parade when the killer pulls him into a hug and stabs him in the back. In the chaos of the parade, his collapse is not noticed until later. His character model resembles Finn Wildfire from Red Carpet Diaries.
Crowd Member (1)
His character model resembles Bennet from Bloodbound.
Float Guy
His character model resembles the axe murderer from The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story.
Man in Crowd
His character model resembles Detective Foley from Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance.
Vampire Lady
Her character model resembles Elder Ferguson from Immortal Desires.
Coroner
She tells you Destiny's death is being ruled as an accident. She seems to non-verbally confirm your suspicion that Mayor Jackson is forcing her to not call Destiny's murder what it is. Her character model resembles Martha from Perfect Match.
Chapter 6
Prison Guard
His character model resembles a prison guard from The Heist: Monaco.
Young Woman
Her character model resembles a version of older Mary and her outfit is the same as that of Felicity Holloway, both of whom are from Desire & Decorum
Librarian
Her character model resembles Evelyn Swan from The Elementalists.
Chapter 7
Mr. Delfin
He is Mayor Jackson's political opponent. Zaire claims that they were following him and noting his schedule because they want to work with him to make sure their mother doesn't get re-elected. His character model resembles Luis Hernandez from Surrender.
Man (1)
His character model resembles a version of Stephen from The Freshman series.
Woman (1)
Her character model resembles Vivian Lopez from The Phantom Agent.
Man (2)
His character model resembles a version of Gavin Covington from Baby Bump.
Nurse
Her character model resembles Marlene from Open Heart.
Patient
His character model resembles Andrew Polowsky from Open Heart.
Mrs. Alvarez
Her character model resembles Brenda Silva from High School Story: Class Act.
Doctor
Her character model resembles Dr. Huang from Open Heart.
Chapter 8
Victim
His character model resembles a version of Beckham from Kiss of Death.
Chapter 10
Loud Reporter
Her character model resembles Stephani from Crimes of Passion.
Pushy Reporter
His character model resembles a reporter from Laws of Attraction.
Judge
His character model resembles a judge from Laws of Attraction.
Chapter 12
Crowd Member (2)
Her character model resembles Amelia Guidry from Hearts on Fire.
Girl
Her character model resembles a version of the young main character from Getaway Girls.
Momma
Her character model resembles Alison from Save the Date.
Crowd Member (3)
His character model resembles Stephen Liang from Hearts on Fire.
Man (3)
His character model resembles Otis Khouri from Most Wanted.
Drunk Guy
Although he has nearly the same appearance as the Vendor, the fact they both appear in one scene indicates they're not meant to be the same person. His character model resembles Arnold Northmun from Bloodbound.
Woman (2)
Although she is identical to your ancestor Annie Campbell, the fact she appears on the modern-day island makes it clear she's not meant to be the same person. Her character model resembles Constance Parsons from Desire & Decorum.
Hasan
His character model resembles a version of Hockey Star's father from Hot Shot.