FANDOM


MTFL Official Cover
SPOILER ALERT
If you haven't read the most recent chapter and are looking for a walkthrough, be aware that the page is full of spoilers.

This page contains the choices in My Two First Loves and their outcomes.

This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices

Choice 1

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3
  • Face 4

Choice 2

  • At First Blush (馃拵 10)
  • Kiss Me (馃拵 10)
  • Basically Brunette
  • Twirl of Fancy
  • A Little Twisted
  • Golden Hour
  • Sunkissed

Choice 3

  • Great! I love it!
  • Let's try something else. (Go Back to Choice 1)

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your character's first name:

Default is "Emma".

Chapter One: The Secret Choices

Choice 1

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 2

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your childhood crush's first name:

Default is "Mason".

Choice 3

  • Have you been working out?聽(No effect)
  • Is that a new cologne? (No effect)
  • How's your dad? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Why is this so hard? (No effect)
  • Seriously, what's wrong with me? (No effect)
  • Gaaaaaaaaaah! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Look inside. (馃拵 12)
  • Let's leave the past alone. (Case Closed)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Pick it up. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Take Mason's hand! (No effect)
  • Hold tight to him! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I can't! (No effect)
  • I just might.聽(No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • It's a joke.聽(No effect)
  • It's a riddle. (No effect)
  • It just sounds like an ocean!聽(No effect)

"Tiny but Infinite"

Choice 6

  • Awkward! (No effect)
  • Just fine. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • I'm definitely sleeping! (No effect)
  • Zzzzzz... (No effect)

Chapter Two: First Day of School Choices

Choice 1

  • Let me make my own choices! (No effect)
  • Whatever you say... (No effect)

Choice 2

  • In Pursuit of Cute (馃拵 20) (What Dad Doesn't Know)
  • No thanks (Daddy's Little Girl)

Choice 3

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your best friend's first name:

Default is "Ava".

Choice 5

  • The craziest summer party! (No effect)
  • Who everyone is dating! (No effect)

Chapter Three: The Dangerous One Choices

Choice 1

  • No problem. I know we got interrupted. (No effect)
  • There's such a thing as texting, you know. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Keep it together. (No effect)
  • Seriously, don't melt down right now. (No effect)
  • For the love of everything that's holy, bottle up your feelings! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Of course. I'm happy for you! (No effect)
  • You two are so cute I could die! (No effect)
  • I'll get used to it, I guess. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Find a different customer. (No effect)
  • Get the hell away from me! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter the handsome stranger's first name:

Default is "Noah".

Choice 7

  • Stupid. (No effect)
  • Heroic. (No effect)
  • Kind of hot. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Snacks! (No effect)
  • A cute tour guide. (No effect)

Choice 9

  • Promise. (馃拵 16)
  • I can't. (Misguided)

Diamond Choice 1

  • You're an athlete. (No effect)
  • You're single. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Where'd you go to school last year? (No effect)
  • Have you ever been in love? (No effect)

"Tour De Force"

Chapter Four: The Cheer Squad Choices

Choice 1

  • Completely ridiculous. (No effect)
  • Kind of believable. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Sweet. (No effect)
  • Scary. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • That was when my mom died. (No effect)
  • That's none of your goddamn business. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • He's totally not my type. (No effect)
  • Okay, he is kind of cute. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Let's put on a show. (馃拵 15)
  • Let's keep things G-rated. (Principal Approved)

Diamond Choice 1

  • High kick!聽(No effect)
  • Splits! (No effect)
  • Flip! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Sweet! (No effect)
  • Sexy! (No effect)
  • Dorky!聽(No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Playfully.聽(No effect)
  • Hard. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

"Sexy and Scandalous"

Chapter Five: Favors and Fights Choices

Choice 1

  • I was seriously worried! (No effect)
  • That defeats the purpose of the assignment! (No effect)
  • I... kind of admire your nerve. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Grab it. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Run after him. (馃拵 17)
  • Leave him be. (Lone Wolf)

Diamond Choice 1

  • I just wanted to see if you're okay. (No effect)
  • I do enjoy doing a little stalking. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Tackling is part of football. (No effect)
  • He seems biased. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Not afraid of you. (No effect)
  • Actually more intrigued now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Are there a lot of those people? (No effect)
  • So you're saying this is all an act. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • He is my best friend. (No effect)
  • We kinda drifted over the summer. (No effect)
  • You seem awfully curious. (No effect)

"Baby Steps"

Choice 5

  • Showing off for me. (No effect)
  • Killing it, as always. (No effect)
  • Gonna have to watch out for Noah. (No effect)

Chapter Six: Hurt/Comfort Choices

Choice 1

  • Be really careful! (No effect)
  • We can split it! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You really didn't have to. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You don't have to put on a brave face for me. (No effect)
  • Take a couple of deep breaths. (No effect)
  • I've got you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Keep talking to him. (馃拵 18)
  • Let him be. (Hands Off)

Diamond Choice 1

  • My dream life in the future. (No effect)
  • The great pineapple on pizza debate. (No effect)
  • My favorite things about you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Cared so much about me liking you. (No effect)
  • Were such a showoff. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Seeing how you're always getting hurt. (No effect)
  • I do care about you. (No effect)

"'Emma' Price, M.D."

Choice 5

  • You need to be careful. (No effect)
  • It wasn't your fault. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Need to see how he's doing. (No effect)
  • Hope we can talk more like this sometime. (No effect)

Chapter Seven: Red-Handed Choices

Choice 1

  • I call shotgun! (No effect)
  • Sorry! Let's switch. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I'm supposed to have that one! (No effect)
  • Shove it up your ass, Lauren! (No effect)
  • Someone get me OUT OF HERE! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Follow him to the pinball machine. (馃拵 15)
  • Stay behind. (Drop The Ball)

Diamond Choice 1

  • How are things with Ava? (No effect)
  • Lauren is totally going to crash and burn.

Diamond Choice 2

  • You're meant to be with me, not her! (No effect)
  • You shouldn't need to 'figure things out!' (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Take it slow.
  • Look for new opportunities... (No effect)
  • Dump her and don't look back.

"Full Tilt"

Choice 4

  • Throw my arms around him.聽(No effect)
  • Run my hand across his bike. (No effect)
  • Just play it cool. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Find a good place to eat out there?聽(No effect)
  • You're not supposed to leave campus. (No effect)
  • You look hot on that bike. (No effect)

Chapter Eight: The Knives Are Out Choices

Choice 1

  • I make my own decisions. (No effect)
  • It's not like I caught a disease from him! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Who cares what they think? (No effect)
  • You could change that. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Look. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • They can't keep it forever. (No effect)
  • Applegate is the actual worst. (No effect)
  • It's just a knife, right? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • I'll get your knife back. (馃拵 16)
  • There's nothing we can do. (Not Cut Out For It)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Scary good at lying. (No effect)
  • Even braver than I thought. (No effect)
  • So confident. It's hot. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Go now. Go fast. (No effect)
  • Wait for her to look again before moving. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Grab it! (Take A Stab At It)

Choice 6

  • I don't know if I'm free. (No effect)
  • I'll think about it. (No effect)

Chapter Nine: Trouble in Paradise Choices

Choice 1

  • Thanks for thinking of me. (No effect)
  • This just isn't how it used to be. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Perfectly nice.聽(No effect)
  • Nothing to me. (No effect)
  • Clearly making you jealous. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You should talk to her about it. (No effect)
  • She's not actually into you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I won't tell if you won't. (馃拵 18)
  • I don't think we should. (Cut And Run)

Diamond Choice 1

  • You should invite me over more. (No effect)
  • Does he like Ava this much? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Sneak a tiny look. (No effect)
  • Keep my eyes to myself. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Keep it together, Emma! (No effect)
  • Don't think about his muscles! (No effect)
  • You're just hanging out in the hot tub!

Diamond Choice 4

  • Splash him first! (No effect)
  • Let him get in a hit. (No effect)

"Hot and Bothered"

Chapter Ten: Choices

Walkthroughs
The Freshman The Freshman, Book 1 ChoicesThe Freshman, Book 2 ChoicesThe Freshman, Book 3 ChoicesThe Freshman, Book 4 ChoicesThe Freshman: Love Bites ChoicesThe Freshman: Game of Love ChoicesThe Freshman: Snowed In ChoicesChris: Luxury Getaway ChoicesJames: Masquerade Ball ChoicesKaitlyn: The Perfect Date Choices
The Crown & The Flame The Crown & The Flame, Book 1 ChoicesThe Crown & The Flame, Book 2 ChoicesThe Crown & The Flame, Book 3 Choices
Most Wanted Most Wanted, Book 1 Choices 路 Most Wanted, Book 2 Choices
Rules of Engagement Rules of Engagement, Book 1 ChoicesRules of Engagement, Book 2 ChoicesRules of Engagement, Book 3 ChoicesRules of Engagement: Newlyweds Choices
Endless Summer Endless Summer, Book 1 ChoicesEndless Summer, Book 2 ChoicesEndless Summer, Book 3 Choices
#LoveHacks #LoveHacks, Book 1 Choices#LoveHacks, Book 2 Choices
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor The Haunting of Braidwood Manor Choices
The Royal Romance The Royal Romance, Book 1 ChoicesThe Royal Romance, Book 2 ChoicesThe Royal Romance, Book 3 ChoicesThe Royal Holiday Choices
The Sophomore The Sophomore, Book 1 ChoicesThe Sophomore, Book 2 ChoicesThe Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story Choices
Hero Hero, Vol. 1 Choices 路 Hero Vol. 2 Choices
High School Story High School Story, Book 1 ChoicesHigh School Story, Book 2 ChoicesHigh School Story, Book 3 ChoicesHigh School Story: Class Act, Book 1 ChoicesHigh School Story: Class Act, Book 2 ChoicesHigh School Story: Class Act, Book 3 Choices
It Lives It Lives In The Woods ChoicesIt Lives Beneath Choices
Home for the Holidays Home for the Holidays Choices
Red Carpet Diaries Red Carpet Diaries, Book 1 ChoicesRed Carpet Diaries, Book 2 ChoicesRed Carpet Diaries, Book 3 Choices
Perfect Match Perfect Match, Book 1 ChoicesPerfect Match, Book 2 Choices
Bloodbound Bloodbound, Book 1 ChoicesBloodbound, Book 2 ChoicesBloodbound, Book 3 ChoicesBloodbound: Dark Solstice Choices
The Junior The Junior, Book 1 Choices
Veil of Secrets Veil of Secrets Choices
America's Most Eligible America's Most Eligible: Season 10 ChoicesAmerica's Most Eligible: All Stars ChoicesAmerica's Most Eligible: Wedding Edition Choices
Desire & Decorum Desire & Decorum, Book 1 ChoicesDesire & Decorum, Book 2 ChoicesDesire & Decorum, Book 3 ChoicesDesire & Decorum: First Winter Choices
Across the Void Across the Void Choices
The Senior The Senior Choices
Big Sky Country Big Sky Country, Book 1 ChoicesBig Sky Country, Book 2 Choices
The Elementalists The Elementalists, Book 1 ChoicesThe Elementalists, Book 2 ChoicesThe Elementalists: Winters Past Choices
A Courtesan of Rome A Courtesan of Rome Choices
The Heist: Monaco The Heist: Monaco Choices
Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 1 Choices 路 Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 2 Choices
Open Heart Open Heart, Book 1 ChoicesOpen Heart: Second Year Choices 路 Open Heart, Book 3 Choices
Passport to Romance Passport to Romance Choices
Wishful Thinking Wishful Thinking Choices
Nightbound Nightbound Choices
Platinum Platinum Choices
The Royal Heir The Royal Heir, Book 1 ChoicesThe Royal Heir, Book 2 Choices 路 The Royal Heir, Book 3
Sunkissed Sunkissed Choices
Bachelorette Party Bachelorette Party Choices
Mother of the Year Mother of the Year Choices
Save the Date Save the Date Choices
The Royal Masquerade The Royal Masquerade Choices
Baby Bump Baby Bump, Book 1 Choices 路 Baby Bump, Book 2 Choices
Blades of Light and Shadow Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 1 Choices 路 Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 2 Choices
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Choices
Distant Shores Distant Shores Choices
The Nanny Affair The Nanny Affair Choices
Queen B Queen B Choices
My Two First Loves My Two First Loves Choices
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.