MTFL Official Cover.png

SPOILER ALERT
If you haven't read the most recent chapter and are looking for a walkthrough, be aware that the page is full of spoilers.


This page contains the choices in My Two First Loves and their outcomes.

This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Contents

Setup Choices

Choice 1

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3
  • Face 4

Choice 2

  • At First Blush (πŸ’Ž 10)
  • Kiss Me (πŸ’Ž 10)
  • Basically Brunette
  • Twirl of Fancy
  • A Little Twisted
  • Golden Hour
  • Sunkissed

Choice 3

  • Great! I love it!
  • Let's try something else. (Go Back to Choice 1)

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your character's first name:

Default is "Emma".

Chapter One: The Secret Choices

Choice 1

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 2

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your childhood crush's first name:

Default is "Mason".

Choice 3

  • Have you been working out? (No effect)
  • Is that a new cologne? (No effect)
  • How's your dad? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Why is this so hard? (No effect)
  • Seriously, what's wrong with me? (No effect)
  • Gaaaaaaaaaah! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Look inside. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Let's leave the past alone. (Case Closed)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Pick it up. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Take Mason's hand! (No effect)
  • Hold tight to him! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I can't! (No effect)
  • I just might. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • It's a joke. (No effect)
  • It's a riddle. (No effect)
  • It just sounds like an ocean! (No effect)

"Tiny but Infinite"

Choice 6

  • Awkward! (No effect)
  • Just fine. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • I'm definitely sleeping! (No effect)
  • Zzzzzz... (No effect)

Chapter Two: First Day of School Choices

Choice 1

  • Let me make my own choices! (No effect)
  • Whatever you say... (No effect)

Choice 2

  • In Pursuit of Cute (πŸ’Ž 20) (What Dad Doesn't Know)
  • No thanks (Daddy's Little Girl)

Choice 3

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your best friend's first name:

Default is "Ava".

Choice 5

  • The craziest summer party! (No effect)
  • Who everyone is dating! (No effect)

Chapter Three: The Dangerous One Choices

Choice 1

  • No problem. I know we got interrupted. (No effect)
  • There's such a thing as texting, you know. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Keep it together. (No effect)
  • Seriously, don't melt down right now. (No effect)
  • For the love of everything that's holy, bottle up your feelings! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Of course. I'm happy for you! (No effect)
  • You two are so cute I could die! (No effect)
  • I'll get used to it, I guess. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Find a different customer. (No effect)
  • Get the hell away from me! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter the handsome stranger's first name:

Default is "Noah".

Choice 7

  • Stupid. (No effect)
  • Heroic. (No effect)
  • Kind of hot. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Snacks! (No effect)
  • A cute tour guide. (No effect)

Choice 9

  • Promise. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • I can't. (Misguided)

Diamond Choice 1

  • You're an athlete. (No effect)
  • You're single. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Where'd you go to school last year? (No effect)
  • Have you ever been in love? (No effect)

"Tour De Force"

Chapter Four: The Cheer Squad Choices

Choice 1

  • Completely ridiculous. (No effect)
  • Kind of believable. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Sweet. (No effect)
  • Scary. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • That was when my mom died. (No effect)
  • That's none of your goddamn business. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • He's totally not my type. (No effect)
  • Okay, he is kind of cute. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Let's put on a show. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Let's keep things G-rated. (Principal Approved)

Diamond Choice 1

  • High kick! (No effect)
  • Splits! (No effect)
  • Flip! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Sweet! (No effect)
  • Sexy! (No effect)
  • Dorky! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Playfully. (No effect)
  • Hard. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

"Sexy and Scandalous"

Chapter Five: Favors and Fights Choices

Choice 1

  • I was seriously worried! (No effect)
  • That defeats the purpose of the assignment! (No effect)
  • I... kind of admire your nerve. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Grab it. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Run after him. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Leave him be. (Lone Wolf)

Diamond Choice 1

  • I just wanted to see if you're okay. (No effect)
  • I do enjoy doing a little stalking. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Tackling is part of football. (No effect)
  • He seems biased. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Not afraid of you. (No effect)
  • Actually more intrigued now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Are there a lot of those people? (No effect)
  • So you're saying this is all an act. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • He is my best friend. (No effect)
  • We kinda drifted over the summer. (No effect)
  • You seem awfully curious. (No effect)

"Baby Steps"

Choice 5

  • Showing off for me. (No effect)
  • Killing it, as always. (No effect)
  • Gonna have to watch out for Noah. (No effect)

Chapter Six: Hurt/Comfort Choices

Choice 1

  • Be really careful! (No effect)
  • We can split it! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You really didn't have to. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You don't have to put on a brave face for me. (No effect)
  • Take a couple of deep breaths. (No effect)
  • I've got you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Keep talking to him. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Let him be. (Hands Off)

Diamond Choice 1

  • My dream life in the future. (No effect)
  • The great pineapple on pizza debate. (No effect)
  • My favorite things about you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Cared so much about me liking you. (No effect)
  • Were such a showoff. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Seeing how you're always getting hurt. (No effect)
  • I do care about you. (No effect)

"'Emma' Price, M.D."

Choice 5

  • You need to be careful. (No effect)
  • It wasn't your fault. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Need to see how he's doing. (No effect)
  • Hope we can talk more like this sometime. (No effect)

Chapter Seven: Red-Handed Choices

Choice 1

  • I call shotgun! (No effect)
  • Sorry! Let's switch. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I'm supposed to have that one! (No effect)
  • Shove it up your ass, Lauren! (No effect)
  • Someone get me OUT OF HERE! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Follow him to the pinball machine. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Stay behind. (Drop The Ball)

Diamond Choice 1

  • How are things with Ava? (No effect)
  • Lauren is totally going to crash and burn. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • You're meant to be with me, not her! (No effect)
  • You shouldn't need to 'figure things out!' (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Take it slow. (No effect)
  • Look for new opportunities... (No effect)
  • Dump her and don't look back. (No effect)

"Full Tilt"

Choice 4

  • Throw my arms around him. (No effect)
  • Run my hand across his bike. (No effect)
  • Just play it cool. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Find a good place to eat out there? (No effect)
  • You're not supposed to leave campus. (No effect)
  • You look hot on that bike. (No effect)

Chapter Eight: The Knives Are Out Choices

Choice 1

  • I make my own decisions. (No effect)
  • It's not like I caught a disease from him! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Who cares what they think? (No effect)
  • You could change that. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Look. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • They can't keep it forever. (No effect)
  • Applegate is the actual worst. (No effect)
  • It's just a knife, right? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • I'll get your knife back. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • There's nothing we can do. (Not Cut Out For It)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Scary good at lying. (No effect)
  • Even braver than I thought. (No effect)
  • So confident. It's hot. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Go now. Go fast. (No effect)
  • Wait for her to look again before moving. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Grab it! (Take A Stab At It)

Choice 6

  • I don't know if I'm free. (No effect)
  • I'll think about it. (No effect)

Chapter Nine: Trouble in Paradise Choices

Choice 1

  • Thanks for thinking of me. (No effect)
  • This just isn't how it used to be. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Perfectly nice. (No effect)
  • Nothing to me. (No effect)
  • Clearly making you jealous. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You should talk to her about it. (No effect)
  • She's not actually into you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I won't tell if you won't. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • I don't think we should. (Cut And Run)

Diamond Choice 1

  • You should invite me over more. (No effect)
  • Does he like Ava this much? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Sneak a tiny look. (No effect)
  • Keep my eyes to myself. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Keep it together, Emma! (No effect)
  • Don't think about his muscles! (No effect)
  • You're just hanging out in the hot tub! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Splash him first! (No effect)
  • Let him get in a hit. (No effect)

"Hot and Bothered"

Chapter Ten: Perfect Choices

Choice 1

  • I'd love to, but I can't (No effect)
  • Wanna come to a cheer exhibition instead? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Oh boy. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Needs an outlet. (No effect)
  • Is just a normal teenager. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Proud of you. (No effect)
  • Worried about the graffiti aspect. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Dad didn't say you couldn't have help! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • I know you can do it. (Sweep It Under The Rug)

Diamond Choice 1

  • I think I just stepped in glue. (No effect)
  • It smells like something died in here. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Wow... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • We can get him back. (No effect)
  • He's still mourning. (No effect)

"Clean Sweep"

Choice 6

  • I understand. (No effect)
  • But you promised! (No effect)
  • What would Mom say? (No effect)

Chapter Eleven: Good Girl, Bad Boy Choices

Choice 1

  • Dangerous Woman (πŸ’Ž 20) (Black Magic)
  • No thanks (Afraid of Her Own Shadow)

Choice 2

  • Get on. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Maybe a little... (No effect)
  • Not with you behind the wheel. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Applying for the bartender job. (No effect)
  • With the band. (No effect)
  • His girlfriend. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • What else do you like about me? (No effect)
  • It's what I like about you too. (No effect)

Chapter Twelve: The Cover Story Choices

Choice 1

  • I'm really sorry! (No effect)
  • It's just a stain. It'll wash out. (No effect)
  • Get out of my face or I'll mess yours up. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • A Shirley Temple. (No effect)
  • Some beer. (No effect)
  • Whatever you're having. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Cheers. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Love to dance. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Rather just watch the show. (#1 Fan)

Diamond Choice 1

  • I've just never danced like this before... (No effect)
  • You surprised me, that's all. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Grind my hips against his. (No effect)
  • Lay my head on his chest. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I have a wild side too. (No effect)
  • It's easy with you. (No effect)

"Dance Dance Revolution"

Choice 5

  • I forgot to tell you. (No effect)
  • It'll look great on my transcript! (No effect)
  • I don't need to fill you in on every little thing, do I? (No effect)

Choice 6

  • I will. (No effect)
  • He's not so bad. (No effect)

Chapter Thirteen: Polite Company Choices

Choice 1

  • Mackenzie, not Madeline. (No effect)
  • Great to see you too. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • There are lots of paths to success. (No effect)
  • Sometimes you learn more when you break the rules. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Mason deserves the best. (No effect)
  • I'm surprised more than anything. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Waiting for the right person. (No effect)
  • Happily single. (No effect)
  • Exploring my options. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Clearly don't know what to talk about. (No effect)
  • Are trying to embarrass me to death. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • That's the best thing I've heard all night. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • We should probably just get back to the table. (Pine Away)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Intimidating. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I can't tell you or it won't work! (No effect)
  • No wishes, just goals. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Oof. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • You were very convincing. (No effect)
  • At least I've got you. (No effect)
  • We could always try again. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Treasure all these memories. (No effect)
  • Wish things were still like that. (No effect)

"Evergreen"

Chapter Fourteen: Just Missed It Choices

Choice 1

  • I wonder if it was Mom's? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Make a silly face! (No effect)
  • Give my best smile! (No effect)
  • Kiss Mason's cheek! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Let's read our fortunes! (πŸ’Ž 14)
  • I'm fine not knowing. (Going In Blind)

Diamond Choice 1

  • But that sounds terrible! (No effect)
  • Maybe the cards are wrong? (No effect)
  • At least now I'll be prepared. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Learn to be more open and honest. (No effect)
  • Confront something you're avoiding. (No effect)
  • Change your mind about something important. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • What are we fighting about? (No effect)
  • How do we resolve it? (No effect)
  • What happens when it's over? (No effect)

"Fortune Favors the Brave"

Choice 4

  • A window to happy memories. (No effect)
  • My way of expressing love. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • What did you think I would have said? (No effect)
  • I feel like I messed up. (No effect)

Chapter Fifteen: Hidden Depths Choices

Choice 1

  • I'm just tutoring him. (No effect)
  • What do you have against Noah? (No effect)
  • Are you jealous? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Looks like you just can't get enough of me. (No effect)
  • Can't say no to a student in need. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Check Noah's answer. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Coffee sounds great! (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • We should try to focus. (Hit The Books)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Drink up. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Follow your dreams. (No effect)
  • Have faith in your family. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Do what makes me happy. (No effect)
  • Work even harder. (No effect)

"Damn Fine Cup of Coffee"

Choice 5

  • Not as scary as you seem. (No effect)
  • Complex. (No effect)
  • Kind of cute. (No effect)

Chapter Sixteen: Out On A Limb Choices

Choice 1

  • Can't Be Tamed (πŸ’Ž 20) (Of Corset You Can)
  • No thanks (Comfort Zone)

Choice 2

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

You get to choose both of them. This just determines the order.

Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Tell her to chill! (No effect)
  • Just leave her alone. (No effect)

Choice 4 (Noah)

  • You have me to keep you company (No effect)
  • there'll be alcohol! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Always bailing on us! (No effect)
  • Being a tyrant! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Impress Noah! (No effect)
  • Rescue Mason! (No effect)

Chapter Seventeen: The Slip Choices

Choice 1

  • I love you too. (No effect)
  • You're drunk. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Noah? (No effect) β¬… Correct
  • Mason? (No effect)
  • Jeff Goldblum? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You don't need an excuse. (No effect)
  • What exactly do you hope to do? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • How's Ava doing? (No effect)
  • How 'bout that jungle juice? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Truth or Dare sounds fun. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • I'm down for whatever. (Stranger To the Truth)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Drink the whole salsa dish. (No effect)
  • Post a selfie on the toilet with an embarrassing caption. (No effect)
  • Shower me in compliments. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Truth. (No effect)
  • Dare. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Do a shot off of me. (No effect)
  • Lift weights with my body. (No effect)

"Daredevil"

Chapter Eighteen: Kiss Goodbye Choices

Choice 1

  • Tell her it was an accident. (No effect)
  • Not say anything. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • If you haven't been happy, why date him? (No effect)
  • Maybe you're the one with issues. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Feel hurt that my best friend doesn't trust me. (No effect)
  • Still wish you hadn't seen that... (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Would really like that. (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • Kinda just want to go home. (Home Sweet Home)

Diamond Choice 1

  • It sounds like you're close with your siblings. (No effect)
  • I take it you learned a valuable lesson in safety. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Lean on his shoulder. (No effect)
  • Take his hand. (No effect)

"On Top of the World"

Chapter Nineteen: Double or Nothing Choices

Choice 1

  • It didn't mean anything. (No effect)
  • I can kiss whoever I want. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Are you okay? (No effect)
  • What if Dad had come home? (No effect)
  • If you joined a fight club, I want in. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You know you can talk to me. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • We don't have to get into it. (Burn With Curiosity)

Now playing as Mackenzie.


Diamond Choice 1

  • Pretty slick. (No effect)
  • Annoying. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Okay, that's pretty cool. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Are you trying to kill me?! (No effect)
  • That wasn't even a cool trick. (No effect)
  • This burn looks pretty bad... (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


"Burn Notice"

You are taken to the Closet here if you bought a premium outfit previously.

Chapter Twenty: Change of Pace Choices

Choice 1

  • Why you even care. (No effect)
  • I even know. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • It's time to switch things up! (πŸ’Ž 20) (Don't Sweat It)
  • Eh, you looked fine the way you were. (Better Letterman)

Choice 3

  • You should wear this all the time! (πŸ’Ž 20) (Bolt From the Blue)
  • I think you should go back to the leather. (Stick To Your Guns)

Choice 4

  • Had a difficult choice. (No effect)
  • Was living life her own way. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Are you going to ask anyone? (No effect)
  • I didn't think you cared about Homecoming. (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-One: Empty Handed Choices

Choice 1

  • One of those inflatable tube men in front of car dealerships. (No effect)
  • A really, really desperate pretzel. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • It was just a party game! (No effect)
  • I'd be mad too. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Talk to Noah in the locker room. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Leave him be. (Silence Is Golden)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Guilty as charged. (No effect)
  • Psh, you wish. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • From your bullfighting career! (No effect)
  • In a car accident. (No effect)
  • Because of a juvie shiv fight. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I'm glad you trust me. (No effect)
  • You can keep your secrets. (No effect)

"Forbidden Rendezvous"

Choice 4

  • I earned this spot, fair and square. (No effect)
  • Drop and give me twenty. (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Two: Trust Fall Choices

Choice 1

  • Thank you. (No effect)
  • Hold me tighter. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You can bet I've got something to say. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Are you done? (Merciful Ruler)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Terrible work ethic. (No effect)
  • Infamous attitude. (No effect)
  • Jealousy of me. (No effect)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.

"Take No Prisoners"

Choice 3

  • Noah was just helping! (No effect)
  • Stop being so overprotective! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Amazing doctors. (No effect)
  • A good team. (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Three: Aftermath Choices

Choice 1

  • I didn't know anything about this. (No effect)
  • I'm sorry. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You're so sweet. (No effect)
  • Funny, it's usually me taking care of you. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Hear every detail. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • Talk about something else. (The Dog Days Are Over)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Call for help! (No effect)
  • Save that dog! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Don't get hurt. (No effect)
  • You have to come with me! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • A hero! (No effect)
  • A total idiot. (No effect)

"Every Dog Has His Day"

Choice 4

  • Why didn't you tell me before? (No effect)
  • I'm glad it's all out in the open now. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • It's been a crazy day... (No effect)
  • Ava deserves better. (No effect)
  • I don't know what I want. (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Four: The Crown Jewel Choices

Choice 1

  • I really am flattered. (No effect)
  • I can't give you an answer right now. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Happy! (No effect)
  • Kind of sad. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You know I'm the only one who can do it. (No effect)
  • Let's not make this personal. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Nothing. (No effect)
  • Ava. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • I'm ready to RAGE! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • I should go home. (Bottle It Up)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Arm! (RAGE!)
  • Leg! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Graaugh! (RAGE!)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Like he cared about you a lot. (No effect)
  • A little intense. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Block! (Block!)
  • Dodge! (Dodge!)
  • Scream! (No effect)

RAGE!, "Hit It Off"

Chapter Twenty-Five: The Crew Choices

Choice 1

  • I just want to make sure everything is okay. (No effect)
  • I'd trust you if you weren't keeping secrets. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • That sounds... illegal. (No effect)
  • I'm into art of all sorts. (No effect)
  • Whatever. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I'd love to see your work. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Just be careful. (Color Me Gone)

Diamond Choice 1

  • See? This is why we shouldn't keep secrets from each other. (No effect)
  • I'm just starting out, so that's understandable. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Going against the grain. (No effect)
  • Growing into your best self. (No effect) β¬… Correct

Diamond Choice 3

  • You'll get there. (No effect)
  • I think you're doing great already. (No effect)

"Open Heart, Open Art"

Choice 4

  • What about unintentionally? (No effect)
  • Just remember that you're your own person. (No effect)
  • You can tell me if something bad happens. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • That doesn't make it right. (No effect)
  • How do you know Elijah's telling the truth? (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Six: Behind Bars Choices

Choice 1

  • I can't believe you got us into this mess! (No effect)
  • It'll be okay. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I know he's a good person. (No effect)
  • It gives him a sexy edge. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • We didn't do anything! (No effect)
  • He can't leave us here! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Mason. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Noah. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • But we shouldn't. (Throw Away The Key)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • It wasn't my fault. (No effect)
  • I do have a wild side. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • It sounds like you learned your lesson. (No effect)
  • Sometimes you are a dumb teenage boy. (No effect)
  • That won't stop me from liking you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • I have you to rescue me. (No effect)
  • I'm not a goody-two-shoes anymore. (No effect)

"Smooth Ride"

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • It wasn't my fault. (No effect)
  • I do have a wild side. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • For what it's worth, I respect you. (No effect)
  • I don't think Eastridge is big on forgiveness. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • I have you to rescue me. (No effect)
  • I've got some street cred now. (No effect)

"Partners In Crime"

Chapter Twenty-Seven: The Meeting Choices

Choice 1

  • Hold me. (No effect)
  • Let me crash on your couch if I get disowned. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Can never say no to milkshakes. (πŸ’Ž 25)
  • Would rather be alone. (Shaken Up)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Went exploring in the woods and almost died? (No effect)
  • Tried to fly to space in a cardboard box? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I wish he'd be more understanding. (No effect)
  • Only I know what's best for me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Follow my actual dreams. (No effect)
  • Party, explore, and just have fun. (No effect)
  • Have a vibrant love life. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Dig in! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Look into his eyes. (No effect)
  • Take his hand. (No effect)

"Shake It Out"

Choice 3

  • Didn't do anything wrong. (No effect)
  • Already got our punishment. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • You don't control our lives! (No effect)
  • All you care about is my 'success!' (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Eight: The Harris Boy Choices

Choice 1

  • Like I messed up. (No effect)
  • Angry that I'm being judged. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You can always talk to me. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • I'm so sorry. (Keep Your Secrets)

Now playing as Noah.


Diamond Choice 1

  • What did he ever do to you? (No effect)
  • You don't know who you're messing with! (No effect)
  • You must be a wimp if you have to pick on younger kids. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Wanted to help you. (No effect)
  • Don't like letting jerks off the hook. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • The bully started it! (No effect)
  • It was to save Albert! (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


"Slowly But Surely"

Diamond Choice 4

  • Got a good heart. (No effect)
  • Been through a lot. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I was worried about you. (No effect)
  • I need to know what I'm getting into. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • HIM!? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Lean into him. (No effect)
  • Brush my hand against his. (No effect)

Chapter Twenty-Nine: Study Session Choices

Choice 1

  • I won't let you fail. (No effect)
  • You're smarter than you think. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I wasn't staring at you! (No effect)
  • Just brushing up for anatomy class. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I don't know who I am anymore. (No effect)
  • Everything I used to take for granted has changed. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • You've been paying close attention, huh? (No effect)
  • Even if one of those things is a boyfriend? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Can you stay a little longer? (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • See you later. (By The Book)

Diamond Choice 1

  • It'll help you unwind before the test. (No effect)
  • Think of it as returning the favor. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Softly. (No effect)
  • Hard. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You make me feel so special. (No effect)
  • Then I guess we need to do this more. (No effect)

"Live and Learn"

Chapter Thirty: Consequences Choices

Choice 1

  • She's been slacking all season! (No effect)
  • You're just trying to get back at me! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • We'd at least discuss my replacement together. (No effect)
  • You'd do what was best for the squad. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • A walk with you might clear my head. (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • You've got a big game coming up... (Get Your Head In The Game)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Hold Mason's hand. (No effect)
  • Bump his shoulder. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Staged a hunger strike! (No effect)
  • Sucked it up and ate my lunch. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I deserve it! (No effect)
  • No one else can do it justice! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Ava's totally just screwing with me! (No effect)
  • Lauren's a human trash bag! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Make Mom proud. (No effect)
  • Understand her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • Let her look. (No effect)
  • Kiss Mason somewhere else! (No effect)
  • We shouldn't kiss right now. (No effect)

"Your Spotter In Secret"

Chapter Thirty-One: Best Laid Plans Choices

Choice 1

  • This is about me, isn't it? (No effect)
  • I'm sure the coach was bluffing about sidelining you. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Looks like the hard work is paying off. (No effect)
  • You look, um, like, all muscley. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • It's good to know what you want! (No effect)
  • What if deviating is good? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Be a professional cheerleader. (No effect)
  • Go to med school like my dad. (No effect)
  • Do something with photography. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • You're going down! (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • Actually, I'm pretty tired. (Know Your Limits)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Hard! (No effect)
  • Far! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Hit the target! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • To hit! (No effect)
  • Too high! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Fling it! (No effect)
  • Follow through! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Angle it! (No effect)
  • Aim it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • Kiss Mason. (No effect)
  • Snap out of it! (No effect)

"Crash Course"

Chapter Thirty-Two: Out of the Past Choices

Choice 1

  • Decide what I want out of life. (No effect)
  • With my boy drama. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • An invasion of privacy! (No effect)
  • Perfect timing. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You still monitor my outfits like I'm a child? (No effect)
  • You grounded me for being a good big sister? (No effect)
  • You're never around to talk to? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Marching at a protest! (No effect)
  • Backpacking through South America! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Tell me everything. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • I think we should stop here. (Closed Book)

Diamond Choice 1

  • In the dirndl? (No effect)
  • With the fish? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Unique! (No effect)
  • Corny! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Mack and I miss her too. (No effect)
  • I'm sorry. (No effect)

"Worth A Thousand Words"

Chapter Thirty-Three: Come Together, Fall Apart Choices

Choice 1

  • I've been missed. (No effect)
  • The squad's gone to shambles. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • About Mason. (No effect)
  • About us. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • It's coming straight at me! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Kiss Noah. (No effect)
  • Wrap him in my arms and never let go. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Give you a kiss for good luck? (No effect)
  • Help you study? (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

This choice will decide who will be the quarterback.

Choice 7

  • Cheer the boys on! (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Have a little faith. (Ever the Optimist)

Diamond Choice 1

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • I was thinking...

Default is "We Got Spirit".

Diamond Choice 2

  • Miss! That! Kick! (No effect)
  • You'll let your whole team down! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Run to Mason! (No effect)
  • Play it cool. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Mason)

  • I had to congratulate you in person. (No effect)
  • I thought you could wish me luck. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • That last play was amazing! (No effect)
  • Uh... You were... I mean, that was... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • To congratulate you in person. (No effect)
  • You to wish me good luck. (No effect)

"Handspring Into Action"

Choice 8

  • High kick! (No effect)
  • Split! (No effect)
  • Round off! (No effect)

Chapter Thirty-Four: The Choice Choices

Choice 1

  • Would it kill you to do your own homework? (No effect)
  • What were you gonna do if I hadn't quit? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Take a photo! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Snap! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Noah. (No effect)
  • Mason. (No effect)

This choice will decide who's your Homecoming date.

Choice 5 (Mason)

  • We made these all the time when we were kids! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Let's go. Pull out all the stops! (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • That's sweet, but... (No Surprises)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • Your family. (No effect)
  • Your usual order. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Kiss Noah. (No effect)
  • Feed him a bite. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • You're not as caught up as we thought... (No effect)
  • All of these answers are wrong! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Noah... (Make The Grade)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • The third act of a blockbuster love story! (No effect)
  • The beginning of a slasher film... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Kiss him. (No effect)
  • Show him the firefly. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Oh my god! (X Marks The Spot)

Chapter Thirty-Five: Bring On the Night Choices

Choice 1

  • Less trash talk, more assistance. (No effect)
  • That one's yours! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Where have you been hiding? (No effect)
  • Mason would love this! (No effect)
  • Noah won't know what hit him! (No effect)

You get either the second or third option depending on who you chose as your homecoming date.

Choice 3

  • Dripped In Diamonds (πŸ’Ž 25) (Hello, Beautiful)
  • Simple And Sweet (Better Safe Than Sorry)

Choice 4

  • You sure clean up well. (No effect)
  • Are you actually wearing a suit? (No effect)

Choice 5 (Mason)

  • I have no idea what you're talking about. (No effect)
  • That wedding was totally fake. (No effect)

Choice 6 (Mason)

  • Kiss Mason. (No effect)
  • Cuddle Mason. (No effect)

Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Please stop. I've reached maximum cringe. (No effect)
  • I am fun! (No effect)

Choice 6 (Noah)

  • Kiss Noah. (No effect)
  • Comfort Noah. (No effect)

Chapter Thirty-Six: The Other Boy Choices

Choice 1

  • It's just one dance... (No effect)
  • But I came with Mason/Noah... (No effect)

The second option depends on who's your Homecoming date.

Choice 2 (if Mason is your Homecoming date)

  • That truce of yours sure was short-lived. (No effect)
  • Next time, warn a girl when you're gonna go nuclear. (No effect)

Choice 2 (if Noah is your Homecoming date)

  • That's a little unfair, don't you think? (No effect)
  • It's about time! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Didn't mean for it to happen... (No effect)
  • Don't know what you're talking about. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • We look too good not to! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Sorry, too public for my taste. (Camera Shy)

Diamond Choice 1

  • A silly pose! (No effect)
  • A cheesy prom pose! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Top Hat. (No effect)
  • Silly Mustache. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Kiss me. (No effect)
  • Spin me as fast as you can! (No effect)

"Not Afraid To Show It"

Choice 5

  • Calm down. It's just a dance... (No effect)
  • Stop it! Now! (No effect)

Chapter Thirty-Seven: All of the Stars Choices

Choice 1 (Mason)

  • 'Asking Emma out was such a good idea!' (No effect)
  • About where we should eat after Homecoming. (No effect)

Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Rock out to this song with you. (No effect)
  • Stargaze with you. (No effect)

Choice 1 (Noah)

  • That this date is going pretty well. (No effect)
  • About how sexy the brooding makes you look. (No effect)

Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Warm up your singing voice, because I love this song. (No effect)
  • Lay down with me. I wanna show you something. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Make out with Mason/Noah! (πŸ’Ž 30)
  • Bail! (Slow And Steady)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • Slowly. (No effect)
  • Like you mean it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • I should show him the ropes. (No effect)
  • Let's see what he's got! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • I just haven't really done this before... (No effect)
  • But I think it's my turn. (No effect)

"On A High"

Diamond Choice 4 (Mason)

  • Got my braces off! (No effect)
  • Grew boobs! (No effect)
  • Had that terrible bowl cut. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • More. (No effect)
  • To take things slow. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Your mouth all over me. (No effect)
  • You to be gentle with me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Are you okay? (No effect)
  • Why would that scare me? (No effect)

"On A High"

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • I lost my mom freshman year. (No effect)
  • But now we're here to make things better for each other. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I need to hear this. (No effect)
  • We shouldn't be here. We need to escape! (No effect)

Chapter Thirty-Eight: Decisions, Decisions Choices

Choice 1 (Mason)

  • We definitely still have to make some memories. (No effect)
  • I dunno, I was having a lot of fun up there on the roof... (No effect)

Choice 1 (Noah)

  • What kind of dance? (No effect)
  • Being alone with you on the roof will be hard to top, though. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Noah's past has nothing to do with his future. (No effect)
  • Sounds like someone's biased. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Pick both of them? (No effect)
  • Give it some more time? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Try this one more time. (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Take it easy for a bit. (Sit It Out)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • It's so... country! (No effect)
  • Talk about a throwback! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Let's throw in a hip swivel! (No effect)
  • A thigh slap should do the trick! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Dance with Mason! (No effect)
  • Freestyle! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • I can't keep my hands off of you! (No effect)
  • We'll be 'making our exit' alright... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Drop it like it's hot! (No effect)
  • Take control! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Shake what my mama gave me! (No effect)
  • Have Noah carry me! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Slow things down. (No effect)
  • Keep the party going! (No effect)

"Dance To Your Own Tune"

Choice 5

  • Mason, your dad did say something... (No effect)
  • Noah, you don't know for sure why the scout didn't pick you... (No effect)
  • Arguing won't change anything. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Can't you see how much this is hurting me? (No effect)
  • I should never have let things get to this point. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Chad. (No effect)
  • Everything. (No effect)

Chapter Thirty-Nine: Everything's Changed Choices

Choice 1

  • Snuggle Season (πŸ’Ž 20) (Ice Cold)
  • No thanks (Put It On Ice, Go to Closet if you've purchased an outfit before)

Choice 2

  • We should definitely hang out more. (No effect)
  • But quitting cheer was the right choice for me. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • But that's how it has to be. (No effect)
  • I wish things were different. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Photography's just a hobby. (No effect)
  • What if I'm not good enough? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • But maybe I should have. (No effect)
  • You got caught because your 'crew' set off a car alarm. (No effect)

Chapter Forty: A New Perspective Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • i miss you (No effect)
  • i hate not talking (No effect)
  • can we please fix this? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Grab him! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Anyone ever tell you you're kinda nosy? (No effect)
  • I don't want you to worry about me. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Serve it. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Take the kid sledding. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Get her to school. (Misled)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Let's go! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Throw your hands in the air! (No effect)
  • Roar like a yeti! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Are a born natural. (No effect)
  • Were clearly terrified. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Don't let anyone wipe that smile off your face. (No effect)
  • I'm always going to be here for you. (No effect)

"Uphill From Here"

Choice 6

  • Nod with style. (No effect)
  • Wink. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • You oughta be sick of me by now, Jennings. (No effect)
  • I'm not really much of a talker. (No effect)

Chapter Forty-One: The Half of It Choices

Content Warning: This chapter contains depictions of violence and police brutality.

Now playing as Mason.


Choice 1

  • Think I can relax for one day? (No effect)
  • Get sick of tracking my carbs? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Can go at someone else's expense. (No effect)
  • Even want to play longterm. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You don't know the whole story. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Let's just leave it in the past. (Here And Now)

Diamond Choice 1

  • His pants look like they have a poop stain on them? (No effect)
  • He's compensating for something? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • The only thing 'less fortunate' is your face. (No effect)
  • I must have much better taste than you do. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • My gaming room! (No effect)
  • My dad's new electric car in the garage! (No effect)

"Friends To Foes"

Choice 4

  • A gunshot? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • I'm not gonna let you die. (No effect)
  • You don't get to make decisions now. (No effect)

Content Warning: The following scene may contain a realistic depiction of police brutality and asphyxiation. We included this scene because it was important to writers on our staff with personal experiences regarding this subject. If this subject is painful for you, you can skip ahead. Your choice will not affect the story.

Choice 6

  • Continue
  • Skip Ahead

Choice 7

  • Tell her I miss her! (No effect)
  • Admit I'm a huge idiot! (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Ever actually want to be friends? (No effect)
  • Hate me for throwing you to the wolves? (No effect)

Chapter Forty-Two: Budding Talent Choices

Choice 1

  • Scrutinize it. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • The composition has room for improvement. (No effect)
  • The mood of the photo is pretty striking. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I'm so new! (No effect)
  • I don't have any pictures! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Stay out of my way. (No effect)
  • Better have learned your lesson. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Do an impromptu photoshoot with the boys! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Reconsider and just wait here. (Camera Shy)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Mason. (No effect)
  • Noah. (No effect)

You get to choose both. This just determines the order.

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Blow me a kiss. (No effect)
  • Act like I'm not here. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Lean on your shovel? (No effect)
  • Take your shirt off? (Path B)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah) (Path B)

  • Take a photo. (No effect)

"When Life Gives You Lemons"

Chapter Forty-Three: Losing Control Choices

Choice 1

  • Who's that? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Fine. Watch and learn. (No effect)
  • That helps Winter Wonderland how, exactly? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Calm down, it's fine! (No effect)
  • This dumb igloo is way too small! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Grab it. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Say goodbye to your ride home, Lauren! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • I'd better hurry back with her drink... (Play Nice)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Pour water all over it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Write on the windshield.

Default is "Just Chill".

Diamond Choice 3

  • Act like I care. (No effect)
  • Discretely snap a commemorative photo! (No effect)

"Best Served Cold"

Chapter Forty-Four: The Whole Truth Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • Act tough. (No effect)
  • Stay quiet. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Thanks for stepping in. (No effect)
  • But I could have handled that myself. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • That's super solid of you. (No effect)
  • It's just how things go, though. People are always gonna act that way. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • What if we get caught? (No effect)
  • We're better than this. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Take it. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Ignore it. (Hold Your Peace)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Were they really that good? (No effect)
  • Everything's different now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • At least now we're talking. (No effect)
  • I'm not sure if I'm ready either. (No effect)
  • Some things in life are out of our control. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • It's up to her. (No effect)
  • I don't want to compete with you. (No effect)

"Bury the Hatchet"

Chapter Forty-Five: The Dinner Guest Choices

Choice 1

  • You could never lose me. (No effect)
  • You nearly did with how you handled this. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Thanks for having me over. (No effect)
  • Uh, need help with that? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Something like that. (No effect)
  • No comment. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Right up my alley. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • A little old school for me. (Gutterball)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Throw the ball HARD! (No effect)
  • Get some help from Noah! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Hazel, you got this! (No effect)
  • Looks like it might not be that hard to beat you... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • What are you waiting for? (No effect)
  • It's... too soon. (No effect)

"Bowled Over"

Chapter Forty-Six: New Tricks Choices

Choice 1

  • Wipe that smirk off your face, asshole! (No effect)
  • You owe me and Mack an apology. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I'll see you around? (No effect)
  • Don't do anything rash. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Getting into an elite college doesn't mean you're better than anyone. (No effect)
  • This smells fishy as hell. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I think you made the right call. (No effect)
  • Your dad must be pissed... (No effect)

Choice 5

  • What would I do without you? (No effect)
  • This is dangerous... (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Let's do it! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • No thanks... (Later Skaters)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Sounds like you and Noah agree for once. (No effect)
  • What do you think I should do? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • You should dip me! (No effect)
  • Let's skate as fast as we can! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I'd like a kiss, please! (No effect)
  • Sweep me off my feet! (No effect)

"Skate and Date"

Chapter Forty-Seven: Overexposed Choices

Choice 1

  • Does he think we're buying that? (No effect)
  • At least people will have someone new to talk about. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Call her out! (No effect)
  • Sit somewhere else. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Or should I say 'Picasso'? (No effect)
  • You okay? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • We'd love to pose for you. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • I'm more comfortable behind the camera. (No Photos, Please)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Lay across the desks!
  • Do a cheer pose! (No effect)
  • Have Ava sit in my lap! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • You liked him, didn't you? (No effect)
  • Want me to get rid of him? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Perfect. I've always wanted to be an eldritch horror. (No effect)
  • You're a genius! (No effect)

"Portrait of Two Ladies"

Choice 5

  • Hide behind the lockers. (No effect)
  • Pretend to drink from the fountain. (No effect)

Chapter Forty-Eight: The Person He Trusts Most Choices

Choice 1

  • He has enough sense on his own. (No effect)
  • This is so none of my business. (No effect)
  • I can try. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • It's called a snowman, not a snowmonster. (No effect)
  • It's creative, I'll give you that... (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Forgive him. (No effect)
  • Keep my guard up. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Not if we stay in it until the festival. (No effect)
  • Maybe we should bury the snowman in it. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Join Noah. (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • Stay in the snow angel. (Fallen Angel)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Throw it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Was my plan all along... (No effect)
  • Is just what I want you to think. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Reverse the situation! (No effect)
  • Let him pin me down. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Bite his lip! (No effect)
  • Go with the flow. (No effect)

"Your Angel... Or Your Devil"

Choice 6

  • I'd love to! (No effect)
  • I'll have to check if i'm free (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Call out to him! (No effect)
  • Go straight to the note. (No effect)

Chapter Forty-Nine: Up in the Air Choices

Choice 1

  • That's amazing! (No effect)
  • Show off. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Wow... (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Yeah, if you could just reach over here... (No effect)
  • I've buckled a seatbelt before, you know. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Move over, Captain. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Nah, this is your moment. (Stalling Out)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Follow instructions. (No effect)
  • Fake him out. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Whether the Air Force works out or not, I'm sure you'll find a way. (No effect)
  • Aren't you worried it's dangerous? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Gently. (No effect)
  • Like you mean it. (No effect)

"I'm The Captain Now"

Chapter Fifty: What's Not Earned Choices

Choice 1

  • Congratulate him! (No effect)
  • Throw my arms around him! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Don't sell yourself short. (No effect)
  • It'll be a relief not living under the same roof as him soon, huh? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I'M SO SORRY (No effect)
  • you should've reminded me! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Let's kill some time with a photoshoot. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Let's just wait here. (Mayday)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Classic, crisp salute. (No effect)
  • 'Top Gun' pose. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • We won't get to go to college together. (No effect)
  • We've never been apart more than a summer. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You should follow up with a kiss. (No effect)
  • But don't say that in your interview. (No effect)

"Change of Station"

Choice 5

  • You really impressed him. (No effect)
  • I'm so proud of you. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Are they really that bad? (No effect)
  • I know I can do better. (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-One: Option B Choices

Now playing as Ava.


Choice 1

  • Dance? (No effect)
  • Photography? (No effect)
  • Athletics? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • She flaked. (No effect)
  • I told her not to. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Just a close friend. (No effect)
  • Taken. Twice over. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I'm never dating a man again. (No effect)
  • You're the first person I've told. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • But I could tell you. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • I don't wanna think about it. (Don't Rewind)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Tell her how I feel. (No effect)
  • Never let her go... (No effect)
  • Kiss her... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Want to talk to Emma. (No effect)
  • Don't give a damn about me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Tearing down Emma won't make you vice-captain. (No effect)
  • You didn't do this because you're my friend. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Cry. (No effect)
  • Walk away. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • We're done. (No effect)

"Unsatisfied"

Choice 6

  • You're a really sweet person. (No effect)
  • You have a point. (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Two: Branching Out Choices

Choice 1

  • Take more risks. (No effect)
  • Hone what I'm good at. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • When did you get so wise? (No effect)
  • Because I really needed to hear that. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • That would be perfect. (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • I don't think I should. (Burned Out)

Diamond Choice 1

  • You can't expect me to climb that. (No effect)
  • Are we allowed to be here? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • You definitely made me work for it. (No effect)
  • Maybe if we get to make out up here. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • A flask? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • I've heard skin on skin helps. (No effect)
  • Your kisses usually get me hot and bothered. (No effect)

"Starstruck"

Choice 4

  • I still need time. (No effect)
  • I don't want to lose either of them. (No effect)

You are taken to the Closet here if you've bought a premium outfit previously.

Choice 5

  • No. (No effect)
  • Not good enough. (No effect)
  • Absolutely not. (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Three: Miss Movin' On Choices

Choice 1

  • Jealous. (No effect)
  • Sad. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Wanted you to wait for me. (No effect)
  • Wasn't sure if I liked girls too. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You're a real piece of work. (No effect)
  • Mrs. Larson would never believe you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Paint the set with Mason. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Build the castle with Noah. (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Work on my own. (No effect)

You get to choose as many as you have diamonds for.

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • Let me teach you how it's done. (No effect)
  • I think yours are charming in their own way. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • I thought you'd pick me as your subject. (No effect)
  • I've heard I have the same effect. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Swipe him with the paintbrush! (No effect)
  • Push him against the wall! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Mason)

  • Kiss Mason. (No Paint, No Gain)
  • Hug Mason. (No Paint, No Gain)

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • More than you know. (No effect)
  • But you could pick up the pace! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Noah)

  • Have my own toolbox at home! (No effect)
  • Don't know my Phillips head from my own head. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7 (Noah)

  • The kind that secretly cries at romantic movies. (No effect)
  • The typical meathead jock. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Noah)

  • Kiss Noah. (No effect)
  • Hug Noah. (No effect)

"Weapon of Mass Construction"

Choice 5

  • Mason! (No effect)
  • Noah! (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Four: Truth, Dare, or Consequences Choices

Choice 1

  • Call someone for help? (No effect)
  • Climb the Christmas tree to the windows? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Hand it over! (No effect)
  • I'll pass. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • About the most embarrassing thing you've ever walked in on! (No effect)
  • What non-human thing you used to practice kissing! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Dare! (No effect)
  • Truth! (No effect)
  • Consequences! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Make the most of tonight. (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • Get some sleep instead. (Let Sleeping Dogs Lie)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Mason! (No effect)
  • Noah! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Can run, but you can't hide. (No effect)
  • Didn't doubt me, did you? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Put on a show of our own. (No effect)
  • Keep things PG. (No effect)

"Night Owl"

Chapter Fifty-Five: Friends in Low Places Choices

Choice 1

  • My dad's gonna kill me! (No effect)
  • But we didn't even do anything! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • She was so busy flirting, she didn't notice she'd locked us in. (No effect)
  • I think she locked us in on purpose. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Look at that, you finally got out of working! (No effect)
  • I'm sure Scooter'll drop by detention to see you. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • It's a date! (πŸ’Ž 25)
  • Maybe next time. (Outfit Repeater)

Diamond Choice 1

  • And who am I to judge? (No effect)
  • But I'm not so sure. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Blankly. (No effect)
  • Happily! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Laugh! (No effect)
  • Stay still! (No effect)

"Ice, Ice, Baby"

Choice 5

  • It wasn't like that! I swear! (No effect)
  • What does it matter to you? You're seeing someone now. (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Six: Inside Man Choices

Choice 1

  • I'm not gonna help you commit any crimes. (No effect)
  • I didn't ask you to save us! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Should really hear this from you. (No effect)
  • Won't do anything he doesn't want to. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • We're madly in love. (No effect)
  • We're robbing a bank. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I'd follow you anywhere. (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • I can't. (Pump the Brakes)

Diamond Choice 1

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • (I should scream...)

Default is "YEAAAAAHHH".

Diamond Choice 2

  • I'm lucky to get a minute alone in my own house! (No effect)
  • I didn't know you were a fan of flowers. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Hit the brake! (No effect)
  • Twist the throttle! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • You'll always have me. (No effect)
  • You can keep an eye on him. (No effect)

"Run Away With Me"

Choice 5

  • Was a night in jail not enough for you? (No effect)
  • This better not be another tagging thing! (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Seven: Out in the Cold Choices

Choice 1

  • A shot that's stunning on a technical level. (No effect)
  • Something with an emotional impact. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You scared the crap outta me! (No effect)
  • Quiet, you'll wake Dad! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Barely knew how to swim! (No effect)
  • Discovered the joys of s'mores! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Go for it! (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Just get the shot set up. (Don't Make Waves)

Diamond Choice 1

  • A kiss should do the trick. (No effect)
  • Skin to skin contact is just what the doctor ordered. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Take the plunge! (No effect)
  • Jump the fire! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • But you're never grounded! (No effect)
  • Then why are we here?! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • You've been excited for it forever! (No effect)
  • You can't let your dad decide your whole life. (No effect)
  • Only you know the answer to that. (No effect)

"The Stage Is Set"

Choice 5

  • I captured it just in time! (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Eight: Building Bridges Choices

Choice 1

  • Isn't the worst crime in the world. (No effect)
  • Was for a good cause! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Can't be any worse than you! (No effect)
  • Haven't done a single thing to hurt him! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • It's incredible! (No effect)
  • How'd we get it done so fast? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • It's beautiful! (πŸ’Ž 12) (Hearts Aglow)
  • It's already fine the way it is. (Lights On, Lights Off)

Choice 5

  • I thought you two were mortal enemies. (No effect)
  • Are you guys besties now too? (No effect)

Chapter Fifty-Nine: Square One Choices

Choice 1

  • Does she like them or not...? (No effect)
  • Would it kill her to smile a little?! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Jennings made Lauren walk the plank! (No effect)
  • For Elijah, the best foreman at Eastridge! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I won't apologize to Lauren. (No effect)
  • I'm sorry. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Anything for you. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • That probably isn't a good idea. (F is for Friends)

Diamond Choice 1

  • The day you met me! (No effect)
  • The story of your first detention! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • But... why? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Follow my heart. (No effect)
  • Get my degree. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Say something, Emma! (No effect)
  • Don't think about how close you are together! (No effect)
  • Snap out of it, she has a girlfriend already! (No effect)

"Say Cheese"

Choice 5

  • Turn on the lights. (No effect)
  • TURN ON THE LIGHTS! (No effect)
  • TURN ON THE EFFING LIGHTS! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • That's my camera! (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Not on your life. (No effect)
  • ...Fine. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • No! (No effect)

Chapter Sixty: Slippery Slopes Choices

Choice 1

  • Fixed the camera? (No effect)
  • Retake my picture at Murphy's Beach? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Noah! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Mason! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Ava! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • No one. (Going At It Alone)

Choice 3

  • With caves like these, I barely need the waterfall! (No effect)
  • Never a dull date with me, huh? (No effect)
  • This looks dangerous... (No effect)

The second option appears instead of the first if you brought LI along.

Choice 4

  • Run to safety! (No effect)
  • Spread out my weight on the ice! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • You were under this blanket with me. (No effect)
  • You'd share the thermos! (No effect)

"Falling For You"

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • But a kiss should do the trick. (No effect)
  • I love hot cocoa. (No effect)

"Falling For You"

Diamond Choice 1 (Ava)

  • Know that we're... close? (No effect)
  • Take you on special trips like this? (No effect)

"Falling For You"

Choice 5

  • Hurry! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • How's that for Winter Wonderland? (No effect)

Chapter Sixty-One: Let It Snow Choices

Choice 1

  • im so glad you wanted to introduce us (No effect)
  • tbh I'm gonna miss when it was just the two of us (No effect)

Choice 2

  • We can always drop out and become circus clowns! (No effect)
  • There's always room in Elijah's crew! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Hot! (No effect)
  • Ready for Winter Wonderland already! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • It's not like I had a choice. (No effect)
  • I've been dying to meet you. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • A Kiss of Frost (πŸ’Ž 25) (Pretty as a Picture)
  • No thanks (Burned Out)

Choice 6

  • Hug Mack! (No effect)
  • Snuggle up to Ava! (No effect)
  • Give Bayla bunny ears! (No effect)

Chapter Sixty-Two: Cold Blooded Choices

Choice 1

  • Tone it down. (No effect)
  • Split up. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Noah! (No effect)
  • Mason! (No effect)

You'll eventually see both. The one you didn't choose will automatically be selected.

Choice 3 (Noah)

  • You're supposed to ask me to dance, not tell me. (No effect)
  • I can't say no to that. (No effect)

Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Let's get lost in the ice rink together! (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • You should see what he wants. (Honesty Is The Best Policy)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • Feet don't fail me now! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • We should make things even more interesting. (Path A)
  • Just this once, we can slow things down. (Path B)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah) (Path A)

  • Cut him off! (No effect)
  • Go under the girl and her mother! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah) (Path B)

  • Do you think I've been doing this whole time? (No effect)
  • Type of girl do you think I am? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah) (Path B)

  • Stand up! (No effect)
  • Squat! (No effect) β¬… Correct

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Dominate me. (No effect)
  • Caress me. (No effect)

"He Was A Skater Boy"

Choice 5 (Mason)

  • I wonder if they bid on any of my pieces... (No effect)
  • I care more that you're here, Mason. (No effect)

Choice 6 (Mason)

  • Let's hide and look at some photos together! (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • We should just confront him. (Don't Beat Around The Bush)

Diamond Choice 6 (Mason)

  • It's a boat! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7 (Mason)

  • Trying too hard. (No effect)
  • An instant classic. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Mason)

  • How romantic! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Mason)

  • Symbolic of nature's role in humanity. (No effect)
  • A commentary on love. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10 (Mason)

  • Kiss his neck! (No effect)
  • Bite his lip! (No effect)

"Picture Perfect"

Chapter Sixty-Three: Blank Check Choices

Choice 1

  • None of this is your fault. (No effect)
  • We won't let him get away with this! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • That's my photo! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Am I dreaming? (No effect)
  • Holy crap. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • But I really like you, too. (No effect)
  • Noah deserves to catch a break. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Return the handshake! (No effect)
  • Let it hang. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Ride home with Noah! (πŸ’Ž 30)
  • Ride home with Mason! (πŸ’Ž 30)
  • Turn them both down. (Girls' Night)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • You did have him pegged from the start. (No effect)
  • You loved him. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Pull him in for a kiss! (No effect)
  • Put my hand on his thigh! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • It's been a while. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Your hands... everywhere. (No effect)
  • To touch you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Like this? (No effect)
  • I'll take that as a compliment. (No effect)

"Bumper to Bumper"

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • Should've happened a long time ago. (No effect)
  • Was the least I could do. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Unbuckle his seatbelt! (No effect)
  • Climb onto his lap! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • What kind of girl do you think I am? (No effect)
  • Because I might be tempted... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Mason)

  • It's been a while. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Mason)

  • Your mouth all over me. (No effect)
  • You to touch me. (No effect)

"Bumper to Bumper"

Chapter Sixty-Four: I'll Be Home for Christmas Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • Doing anything fun for the break? (No effect)
  • I'm thinking of you (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Baseball Bat (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Dancing?! (No effect)
  • Not being murdered? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Who the hell is 'Secret Santa'? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Call the cops. (No effect)
  • Return the money. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Why don't we celebrate right now? (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • It's really important for me to stay. (Worth Waiting For)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Here it is! (No effect)
  • Found it! (No effect)
  • Gotcha! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Handmade chocolates! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You don't wanna leave Ma all alone, do you? (No effect)
  • It's Fairyland! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • There he is. (No effect)

"Better Early Than Never"

Chapter Sixty-Five: Full House Choices

Now playing as Emma.


Choice 1

  • You invited me... remember? (No effect)
  • Is now a bad time? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Photograph! (No effect)
  • Journal! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I could use a crash course. (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Maybe we shouldn't... (Can't Be Too Careful)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Tell me what you like. (No effect)
  • I've got some experimenting to do. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • That's something we have in common. (No effect)
  • I'm more of a slow and gentle kinda girl. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Tell him I'm falling in love with him... (Three Words, Eight Letters)
  • Keep my mouth shut! (Home Alone)

Choice 4

  • Your motorcycle? (No effect)
  • Football? (No effect)

Chapter Sixty-Six: Be My Guest Choices

Now playing as Mason.


Choice 1

  • I know my way around Emma's house, thanks. (No effect)
  • What're you, Emma's doorman now? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Of course it's okay. (No effect)
  • I wish you'd waited for me. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Has been dying to show off the cabin's new renovations. (No effect)
  • Wants to get to know you better. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Because I miss being friends with him? (No effect)
  • Why I even bothered asking. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • We take the scenic route. (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • You go back inside before you freeze. (Best Kept Secret)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Sweetly? (No effect)
  • Passionately? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Fight back! (No effect)
  • Retreat! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You're so amazing. (No effect)
  • You've got me. (No effect)

"Moonlit Stroll"

Chapter Sixty-Seven: Crowded Heart Choices

Choice 1

  • You kept trying to convince us to try the black diamond slope, remember? (No effect)
  • You were totally glued to Mom that trip. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Ski Bunny (πŸ’Ž 20) (Smitten in Mittens)
  • No thanks (Not Snow Fast, Go to Closet if you bought a premium outfit before)

Choice 3

  • Isn't this trip about rebuilding friendships? (No effect)
  • It'll be good practice for a week at the cabin! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • The Bayla situation? (No effect)
  • Things between us? (No effect)

Chapter Sixty-Eight: Steamed Up Choices

Choice 1

  • It's just a big change. (No effect)
  • We didn't mean to make you uncomfortable. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Hefty price tag? (No effect)
  • Eastridge isn't classy enough? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • If you think that, you don't know Ava at all. (No effect)
  • Mason's a person, not a pawn. (No effect)
  • You'd like that, wouldn't you? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • The fancy champagne? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Let's pop some bottles! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • We shouldn't. (Tapped Out)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Take my clothes off quickly! (No effect)
  • Give a little strip tease! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Cheers. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I didn't want you to think I was a nerd. (No effect)
  • I guess I didn't wanna ruin your fun. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Ava! (No effect)
  • Mason! (No effect)
  • Noah! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Ava)

  • We could find our way back to each other. (No effect)
  • I didn't realize what I had. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Mason)

  • Thank god for happy accidents. (No effect)
  • Great minds think alike. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Wish we could do more than just kiss. (No effect)
  • Don't ever want to get out of this tub. (No effect)

Chapter Sixty-Nine: Naughty and Nice Choices

Choice 1

  • Do you want the right side or the left? (No effect)
  • Guess it's a good thing I don't talk in my sleep, huh? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Mason! (No effect)
  • Noah! (No effect)

You'll eventually see both. The one you didn't choose will automatically be selected.

Choice 3 (Mason)

  • We'd be surrounded by junk food! (No effect)
  • I could only think about kissing you. (No effect)

Choice 4 (Mason)

  • I guess I can stay a little longer... (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • I'd better go. (Bed Check)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • What if I wanted to pick up the pace? (No effect)
  • That sounds perfect to me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • You to undress me. (No effect)
  • To do a little experimenting. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • See where he's going with this... (No effect)
  • Return the favor. (No effect)

"Play Date"

Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Make out to. (No effect)
  • Cuddle to. (No effect)

Choice 6 (Noah)

  • I guess I can stay a little longer... (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • I have to go. (Hit Pause)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Think sneaking around has its perks. (No effect)
  • Wish we were the ones sharing a room. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Undress me. (No effect)
  • Strip. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Noah)

  • Fight for control! (No effect)
  • Enjoy the ride! (No effect)

"Midnight Delight"

Chapter Seventy: All Downhill From Here Choices

Choice 1

  • Go skiing with Mason! (No effect)
  • Grab a board with Noah! (No effect)
  • Ride a snowmobile with Ava! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Grab Mason! (No effect)
  • Cover my eyes! (No effect)

Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Test them out! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Noah)

  • We all make mistakes. (No effect)
  • I bet it makes a great story! (No effect)

Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Thanks... I think. (No effect)

Choice 2 (Ava)

  • Being ladylike is overrated. (No effect)
  • A 'lady' can be anything you want! (No effect)

Choice 3 (Ava)

  • Let's ride! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Swerve! (+Race)
  • Cross the front of my skis! (-Race)
  • Flex my feet! (-Race)
  • Squeeze the brake! (-Race)

You get the second option if you went with Mason, the third if you went with Noah, and the fourth if you went with Ava.

Choice 5

  • Lose focus! (-Race)
  • Glide! (+Race)
  • Lean forward! (+Race)
  • Floor it! (+Race)

You get the second option if you went with Mason, the third if you went with Noah, and the fourth if you went with Ava.

Choice 6

  • Wanna talk about it? (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • I'm sure everything'll be okay. (That's Rough, Buddy)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Well, that's just crazy! (No effect)
  • ...Is there? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Tell her how you're feeling. (No effect)
  • Set some boundaries. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Steady her hand. (No effect)
  • Tilt her head up. (No effect)

"You Before Me"

Chapter Seventy-One: What's Done In the Dark... Choices

Choice 1

  • Grab Mason's hand. (No effect)
  • Hold Ava's hand. (No effect)
  • Take Noah's hand. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • If that's what you want, you should do it. (No effect)
  • If you have to ask, then you know the answer. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • With Mason! (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • With Noah! (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • With Ava! (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • But not alone. (Down to Earth)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • My butt's wet from the snow. (No effect)
  • I can feel... everything. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • She's your ex! (No effect)
  • We're... you know... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Show him how I feel! (No effect)
  • Tell him exactly what he does to me. (No effect)

"Bae's Eye View"

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • It's got nothing on you. (No effect)
  • I'm standing right here... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Initials! (No effect)
  • Dates! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Kiss his neck. (No effect)
  • Bite his lip! (No effect)

"Fire and Ice"

Diamond Choice 1 (Ava)

  • You may have a point there. (No effect)
  • Then catch me up! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Ava)

  • All I know is how I feel about you. (No effect)
  • If I could go back and not fall for them, I would. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Ava)

  • I'd realized I felt this way sooner. (No effect)
  • You happiness. Always. (No effect)

"At World's End"

Choice 4

  • Make this quick. (No effect)
  • Check a different room. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • A gun! (No effect)

Chapter Seventy-Two: ...Comes to the Light Choices

Choice 1

  • Some meal, huh? (No effect)
  • Anybody else getting family game night flashbacks? (No effect)
  • The candles were a great idea! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I think he's telling the truth... (No effect)
  • What else did you expect? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Stand up for him! (No effect)
  • Comfort him. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • He wants you to hit him? (No effect)
  • You're better than this? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Not that it's any of your business! (No effect)
  • What type of 'role model' are you? (No effect)

Choice 6

  • We're right behind you! (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • We'll wait for you here. (Cold Shoulder)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Wow, it's really in there... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Kiss Mason! (No effect)
  • Make him look at me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Had me pretty worried. (No effect)
  • Made me want to... refocus that energy. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Do this in my sleep. (No effect)
  • Use a little help... (No effect)

"Fire Starter"

Chapter Seventy-Three: Off the Beaten Path Choices

Choice 1

  • Get Mrs. Jennings out of here! (-Emergency)
  • Call 911! (+Emergency)
  • Grab the first aid kit! (-Emergency)
  • Get medicine from the car! (-Emergency)

Choice 2

  • He's gonna die! (-Emergency)
  • We need a plan B! (+Emergency)

Choice 3

  • I won't let you down, Dad. (+Emergency)
  • Can't do this! (-Emergency)

"Calm, Cool, and Collected" if you got 2 or more +Emergency.

Choice 4

  • Hit the brakes! (No effect)
  • Turn the wheel! (No effect)
  • Scream! (No effect)

"Panic Button" if you got 1 or less +Emergency.

Choice 5

  • Mason's! (No effect)
  • Noah's! (No effect)
  • Ava's! (No effect)

This choice decides who stays with you for the rest of this chapter and the next chapter.

Choice 6

  • Please don't go! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • I'm so tired... (Snooze Control)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Am I dead?! (No effect)
  • What're you doing here? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I'm going to art school in New York! (No effect)
  • Things with Dad and Mack are finally... good. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • This guy. (No effect)
  • This girl... (No effect)

"Mommy Magic"

Chapter Seventy-Four: Staying Alive Choices

Choice 1

  • Dad's gonna murder me. (No effect)
  • We're all doomed now. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Seduce me? (No effect)
  • Pinch my arm? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Beautiful Princess! (No effect)
  • Warrior Queen! (No effect)

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • What's our heroine's name?

Default is "Buttercup".

Choice 5

  • This darkness has taken something from us all... (No effect)
  • Your happiness is my responsibility... (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Admit it's been a long while. (No effect)
  • Never tire of beautiful scenery. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Unity for my people! (No effect)
  • True love! (No effect)
  • Knowledge beyond what is commonly known! (No effect)

Choice 8

  • An ambulance! (No effect)

Choice 9

  • We have to finish the story! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Promise me we'll finish it later? (All's Well That Ends Well)

The knight is a banished prince if you're with Mason, a pickpocket if you're with Noah, and a witch if you're with Ava.

Diamond Choice 1

  • It's time the world changed. (No effect)
  • I can make my own choices. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • It's ours! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Lived happily ever after. (No effect)
  • Still had a lot of problems to fix. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Don't fairytales always end with a kiss? (No effect)
  • Do you really think so? (No effect)

"Like A Dream"

Chapter Seventy-Five: Santa Baby Choices

Choice 1

  • Please take care of Mason for me. (No effect)
  • That's... actually really nice of you. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You can always spend Christmas with us. (No effect)
  • Isn't that a good thing? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You and Bayla broke up! (No effect)
  • Jennings had a heart attack! (No effect)
  • We only hit the slopes once! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Lemme see! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • It's perfect! (πŸ’Ž 12) (No effect)
  • We'd better keep looking. (Smoke and Mirrors)

Choice 6

  • A captain's hat? (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Get the hat for Mason! (πŸ’Ž 12) (No effect)
  • Put it back. (Not Cleared for Takeoff)

Choice 8

  • Wow... it's beautiful! (No effect)

Choice 9

  • Make them for Noah! (πŸ’Ž 12) (No effect)
  • Leave well enough alone. (Bird in the Hand)

Choice 10

  • Joke book (No effect)
  • Caduceus (No effect)

Chapter Seventy-Six: Good Tidings We Bring Choices

Choice 1

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Emma Price:

Default is "From My POV".

Choice 2

  • Here I come! (Application Submitted)

Choice 3

  • My camera! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • But I think I'll keep using mom's old one. (No effect)
  • I won't go anywhere without it! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Love him from a distance. (No effect)
  • Surround yourself with people who love you properly. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (if you bought the gift for Mason)

  • Wow... (Aye, Aye, Captain)

Choice 6

  • Tag, you're 'it'! (No effect)
  • We are entirely too old to play tag! (No effect)

"Reduce, Reuse, Romance" if you bought the gift for Noah.

Diamond Choice 2 (if you bought the gift for Noah)

  • To represent New York! (No effect)

"Mirror, Mirror" if you bought the gift for Ava.

Choice 7

  • You didn't have to... (No effect)

Choice 8

  • I love it! (πŸ’Ž 25) (Countdown Cutie)
  • I'm not sure it's really me... (New Year, Same You)

Chapter Seventy-Seven: Old Acquaintance Be Forgot Choices

Choice 1

  • Some jungle juice! (No effect)
  • A glass of champagne! (No effect)
  • Your finest Avatini! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I'm right behind you! (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Maybe some other time... (For All to See)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Slowly. (No effect)
  • Rough. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • We'll make it fast. (No effect)
  • Who cares? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Let it out! (No effect)
  • Keep quiet. (No effect)

"Occupied"

Choice 3

  • Time flies when you're having fun... (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • We'd better not chance it. (On the Clock)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Consider your wish granted. (No effect)
  • What'd you have in mind? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • I love it when you take control. (No effect)
  • Don't think for a second that I'm not in charge here. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • You to pull my hair. (No effect)
  • To take care of you. (No effect)

"Work From Home"

Choice 4

  • Raise your glass (No effect)

Choice 5

  • You should just go. (No effect)
  • Was that really necessary? (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Ignoring how I feel about you. (No effect)
  • Not being honest with myself. (No effect)

Chapter Seventy-Eight: Gut Check Choices

Now playing as Ava.


Choice 1

  • Relive the 'after party' with Emma! (πŸ’Ž 25)
  • Focus on the present. (One Track Mind)

Diamond Choice 1

  • It's only fair that you're mine too. (No effect)
  • Prove it. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Give a sexy strip tease! (No effect)
  • Kiss her from head to toe! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Practice, practice, practice! (No effect)
  • Watch and learn. (No effect)

"With a Bang"

Choice 2

  • The party wasn't that bad... (No effect)
  • Whatever it is, I didn't do it! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Open It! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Crippling debt? (No effect)
  • Bone chilling homesickness? (No effect)
  • The fear that I'm inadequate? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Strike it! (+Dance)

Choice 6

  • Hit it! (+Dance)

Choice 7

  • Shimmy! (-Dance)
  • Wave! (+Dance)

Choice 8

  • High kick! (+Dance)
  • Power pose! (-Dance)

Chapter Seventy-Nine: All That Glitters Choices

Now playing as Mason.


Choice 1

  • the lack of evidence (+Clue)
  • the character witness (-Clue)

Choice 2

  • Look behind it! (No effect)

Choice 3

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • I'll search...

The correct answer is "Jerome Stein". +Clue if you get it right, -Clue if you don't.

Choice 4

  • Wow, Mom... (No effect)

Choice 5

  • It's beautiful. When'd you get it? (+Clue)
  • It looks really expensive... (-Clue)

Choice 6

  • Why's it in the middle of the driveway? (No effect)

Choice 7

  • I think you're blocking me in. (-Clue)
  • Mr. Jennings is my dad. (+Clue)

Choice 8

  • The crowd went crazy! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • But now she wouldn't talk to me... (Let It Go)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Show off! (No effect)
  • Wave to Emma! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I was just having some fun! (No effect)
  • It was one play! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Catch it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Run for the endzone! (No effect)
  • Make a tight pass! (No effect)

"What Are You, Chicken?"

Chapter Eighty: Enemy of My Enemy Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • It won't happen again. (No effect)
  • It's just been a crazy day... (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Start her up! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Spruce up the old parts! (No effect)
  • Install new parts! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Uh, Hazel... (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Drip that on the interior! (No effect)
  • Fall and hurt yourself! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Give Noah advice as Hazel! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Focus on work. (Mr. Know It All)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Take her to a carnival! (No effect)
  • Get her a cookie! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • And miss all the fireworks! (No effect)
  • Until you made it home. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Say you're sorry. (No effect)
  • Talk to Emma. (No effect)

"Pint-Sized Professor"

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 7

  • So he's your problem. (No effect)
  • If you wanna know what he's up to, ask him! (No effect)

Chapter Eighty-One: Girls' Night Choices

Choice 1

  • Nail polish! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Comfy pillows! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Spicy salsa! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Don't want Ava to be uncomfortable! (No effect)
  • Want everything to be perfect! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Just gals being pals! (No effect)
  • ...Is that really all this is? (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Broken bones. (No effect)
  • Car crash. (No effect)
  • Secret account. (No effect) β¬… Correct

Choice 7

  • A girl. (No effect)
  • Someone cute on New Year's. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Time to meet the new me! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • I think I'll keep my color. (Au Naturale)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Confident. (No effect)
  • Lighter. (No effect)
  • Hot. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I'd have your back. (No effect)
  • Only you can know. (No effect)
  • It doesn't have to be permanent. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Trust you. (No effect)
  • Am terrified. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • It's perfect! (No effect)
  • I look... good. (No effect)

"New Wave"

Choice 9

  • I can't stop thinking about it. (No effect)
  • I'm a little scared, to be honest. (No effect)

Chapter Eighty-Two: Nothing but the Truth Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • My charges have nothing to do with Eastridge! (No effect)
  • Where am I supposed to go to school then? (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


Choice 2

  • Drugs. (No effect)
  • Guns. (No effect)

Now playing as Mason.


Choice 3

  • Why even bother? (No effect)
  • I hate you. (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


Now playing as Ava.


Choice 4

  • Hide! (No effect)
  • Scold her for being late! (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


Choice 5

  • He's your dad. (No effect)
  • We need evidence! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Check in with Mason! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Decompress with Noah! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Process with Ava! (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • Spend some time alone. (Overstimulated)

You get to choose as many as you have diamonds for.

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • The father, questioning whether to make the sacrifice? (No effect)
  • The son, pissed about being yeeted for personal gain? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • I tell you a better story? (No effect)
  • We make up one of our own? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • For something more. (No effect)
  • To check on you. (No effect)

"Seeing Stars"

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • But what about college? (No effect)
  • So you're gonna take it, right? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Noah)

  • Angry. (No effect)
  • Afraid... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Noah)

  • Kiss Noah! (No effect)
  • Comfort Noah. (No effect)

"Snuggle Buddy"

Diamond Choice 7 (Ava)

  • Mack! (No effect)
  • Ava! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Ava)

  • Wanna take Jennings down too? (No effect)
  • Think this whole thing is stupid? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Ava)

  • Kiss me. (No effect)
  • Tell me how much you want me. (No effect)

"Kiss the Chef"

Chapter Eighty-Three: Whatever It Takes Choices

Choice 1

  • Did you rob a thirsty clown? (No effect)
  • How'd you sneak all that past security? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Lauren! (No effect)
  • Chad? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Use the tables as cover! (No effect)
  • Launch a sneak attack! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Show Jennings who's boss! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • Stick to the water balloons. (Wet Blanket)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Paint! (No effect)
  • Soda! (No effect)
  • Syrup! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Dodge this! (No effect)
  • This one's for Mason! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I could use a spotter. (No effect)
  • You might've. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • That's how you make me feel. (No effect)
  • Feel free to keep saying nice things about me. (No effect)

"Rain on Me"

Choice 5

  • Kiss Ava! (No effect)
  • Hand her my last water balloon! (No effect)

Chapter Eighty-Four: Unlikely Allies Choices

Now playing as Noah.


Choice 1

  • Behind the desk! (No effect)
  • Under the chairs! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You? (No effect)
  • Money? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • It's like this... (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • We don't have time for this. (Mysterious Upbringing)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Isn't that wrong? (No effect)
  • Why? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Tell Ma! (No effect)
  • Hide! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Mask? (No effect)
  • Bat? (No effect)
  • Weird phone? (No effect)

"The Kids Are Not All Right"

Choice 4

  • Fumbled a bill payment? (No effect)
  • Wanted his quarterback? (No effect) β¬… Correct
  • Had to kick his gambling habit? (No effect)

You will repeat this choice once if you didn't get it right. If you still don't choose the correct answer on the second try, Mason will solve it.

Choice 5

  • Your jersey number! (No effect) β¬… Correct
  • His stats from college! (No effect)
  • The number of games he's won! (No effect)

If you don't get it right, Mason will solve it.

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • What's the code?

The correct answer is "88". If you don't remember, Mason will type it in.

Choice 7

  • What now? (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Where else do we look? (No effect)
  • Run. Now. (No effect)

Chapter Eighty-Five: Out of the Pan, Into the Fire Choices

Choice 1

  • Try to throw him off! (No effect)
  • Play hard ball! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Is a better person than you'll ever be! (No effect)
  • Had a reason to do what he did. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • We're willing to make the same deal. (No effect)
  • The school board would be interested to hear it too. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • My charm. (No effect)
  • A certain je ne sais quoi. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Give Principal Jennings a piece of my mind! (πŸ’Ž 17)
  • Bite my tongue. (Goody Two Shoes)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Start with 'thank you...' (No effect)
  • Shut my mouth. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Noah? (No effect)
  • Mason? (No effect)
  • Ava? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • To get a taste of your own medicine? (No effect)
  • To get owned by a pack of 'losers?' (No effect)

"Screw the System"

Chapter Eighty-Six: Blood, Sweat, and Tears Choices

Choice 1

  • Isn't that a bit much? (No effect)
  • I wanna see you try. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Can't be this heartless. (No effect)
  • Are such a coward! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • We can't go to prom?! (No effect)
  • No photography club? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Worry over Mack. (No effect)
  • Sit next to Noah. (No effect)
  • Give Ava a hug. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • It's the least I can do. (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Maybe it's more of a family matter. (In House)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Kiss him passionately! (No effect)
  • Kiss him sweetly. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Give him a sexy strip tease! (No effect)
  • Let my hands wander! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • We'll figure this out together. (No effect)
  • Jennings is gonna pay for this! (No effect)

"I Got You Babe"

Chapter Eighty-Seven: The A Team Choices

Choice 1

  • Fake an emergency! (No effect)
  • Go with your streaking plan! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You shouldn't sell yourself short. (No effect)
  • Weren't you kicked off at one point? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I did say anything... (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • We should stay on task. (Cut To The Chase)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Start with a kiss? (No effect)
  • Gave you a massage? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I've been there. (No effect)
  • You don't have to put on a brave face. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • People like Lauren can rot! (No effect)
  • I get to see you happy. (No effect)

"Small Comforts"

Choice 4

  • And voila! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • You're here! (No effect)
  • I'm so sorry. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Then kiss me. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • We don't have time. (Pressing Priorities)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Pull him on top of me. (No effect)
  • Press him against the wall. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Give me more. (No effect)
  • Let's slow down. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • You're allowed to be sad. (No effect)
  • We're going to make things right. (No effect)

"Stolen Time"


"Gang's All Here"

Chapter Eighty-Eight: Whatever You Need Choices

Choice 1

  • Call 911! (No effect)
  • Stop the bleeding! (No effect) β¬… Correct

Choice 2

  • Someone else is (No effect)
  • Promise you wont get mad (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Can you stay home today? (No effect)
  • I need you. (No effect)
  • I'm not okay. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Text a friend. (No effect)
  • Do your homework. (No effect)
  • Look at some pictures. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • I didn't mean to worry you... (No effect)
  • I'm fine. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Wait for me. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • Take all the time you need. (Love Hurts)

Diamond Choice 1

  • How you're feeling about Elijah? (No effect)
  • Why you really wanted to come on this walk? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • He won't die. (No effect)
  • We'll get you through anything. (No effect)
  • It's okay to be scared. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Kiss him. (No effect)
  • Wipe away his tears. (No effect)

"Air It Out"

Chapter Eighty-Nine: State's Witness Choices

Content Warning: This chapter deals with issues of police brutality.

Choice 1

  • I don't know whether to slap you or hug you. (No effect)
  • I'm glad you're okay. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Doing the right thing for once? (No effect)
  • Taking down Jennings? (No effect)
  • You consider it payment for saving your life! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Deal 'em! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • I'm not here to play games. (All Bets Are Off)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Repeat that? (No effect)
  • Just get on with it? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Seven of hearts. (No effect)
  • Seven of spades. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Got him. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • We finally have it. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Why'd you steal the Winter Wonderland money? (No effect)
  • Do you even actually love Noah? (No effect)

"Truth Be Told" if you played Elijah's game.

Choice 5

  • Give Elijah another chance. (No effect)
  • Turn Elijah in. (No effect)

Chapter Ninety: Proving the Exception Choices

Choice 1

  • You'd really trust me with something so important? (No effect)
  • But I don't know anything about trying a case! (No effect)

Choice 2 (if you didn't get Noah's knife back in Chapter 8)

  • Crap... (-Case)

Choice 3

  • Bide my time. (-Case)
  • Interrupt! (+Case)

Choice 4

  • What were you thinking breaking into the office? (+Case)
  • Did you break into Principal Jennings' house? (-Case)

Choice 5

  • Do you think your dad is making money illegally? (-Case)
  • Did your father buy your college acceptance? (+Case)

Choice 6

  • Lauren is the case! (πŸ’Ž 15)
  • If I could just have more time... (Plead the Fifth)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Your GPA. (No effect)
  • Your extracurriculars. (No effect)
  • Your personal statement. (No effect)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.

Diamond Choice 2

  • Thanks for making this so easy. (No effect)
  • You brought this on yourself. (No effect)

"Objection!", +Case

Choice 7

  • Recognize this? (No effect)

Chapter Ninety-One: The Defense Rests Choices

Choice 1

  • Done and done. (No effect)
  • What would I even say? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • You are the lowest of the low! (No effect)
  • You would put your own son in jail for nothing? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Stand up for your crew! (πŸ’Ž 20)
  • Get to the point. (Hold Your Peace)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Noah (Heart of Gold)
  • Mason (The Perfect Son)
  • Ava (Captain on Deck)
  • Mackenzie (Soul Sisters)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.

Diamond Choice 2

  • We're good kids. (No effect)
  • Principal Jennings has targeted all of us. (No effect)

"All Aboard"

Choice 4

  • Describe a typical day for you. (+Case)
  • Where is this influx of cash coming from? (+Case)
  • What is your relationship to the families on this ledger? (+Case)

Choice 5

  • Place! (+Case)
  • Time! (-Case)
  • Date! (-Case)

Choice 6

  • Ava, you're the best! (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Show the photo! (No effect)

Chapter Ninety-Two: Pleased to Inform You Choices

Choice 1

  • Me! (No effect)
  • Mack! (No effect)
  • Dad! (No effect)

"One Degree Hotter"

Choice 2

  • Excited for the next steps! (No effect)
  • Overwhelmed by the possibilities... (No effect)

You are taken to the Closet here if you've purchased "In Pursuit of Cute", "All Cozied Up", "Snuggle Season", or "Warm and Fuzzy".

Choice 3

  • The football field? (No effect)
  • Home? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Work up an appetite? (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • Grab some food and catch up? (Paperweight)

Diamond Choice 1

  • How far we can take this before your boss gets back. (No effect)
  • Me as one of those bikini car models. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Passionately! (No effect)
  • Softly! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You're important to me too. (No effect)
  • You don't know what you're saying. (No effect)

"Zero to Sixty"

Chapter Ninety-Three: Ex Scientia Tridens Choices

Choice 1

  • An art class project! (No effect)
  • My big news. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • We'll be neighbors again! (No effect)
  • You'll get some one-on-one time with your mom! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Your 'new' car? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I like your new car. (No effect)
  • Let's get you home. (No effect)

Now playing as Mason.


Choice 5

  • I didn't need you after all. (No effect)
  • Noah sends his best. (No effect)

Now playing as Emma.


Choice 6

  • Not even close. (πŸ’Ž 19)
  • I guess so... (Turn the Page)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Show me? (No effect)
  • Tell me more? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • On the stairs! (No effect)
  • In the living room! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • I think you're a little biased. (No effect)
  • Do you think that'll change? (No effect)

"When One Door Closes"

Chapter Ninety-Four: Dancing On Her Own Choices

Choice 1

  • You joined a new dance company? (No effect)
  • You signed us up for a private class? (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Moving into the loft upstairs? (No effect)
  • Starting a business? (No effect) β¬… Correct
  • Pranking me? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • That it doesn't matter what I think. (No effect)
  • You're incredible! (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I'm so proud of you. (No effect)
  • It's perfect for you. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Bring it on. (πŸ’Ž 18)
  • I can't. (Save The Last Dance)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Press her against the mirror! (No effect)
  • Take her to the dance floor! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Take control back. (No effect)
  • Encourage her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • That doesn't mean you shouldn't try. (No effect)
  • People will always have something negative to say. (No effect)

"Lap Dance"

Chapter Ninety-Five: The Heart Decides Choices

Choice 1

  • You knew Mom was 'the one'. (No effect)
  • I choose who I love most. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Noah. (No effect)
  • Ava. (No effect)
  • Mason. (No effect)

This choice determines your final LI.

You are taken to the Closet here if you've purchased "In Pursuit of Cute", "All Cozied Up", "Snuggle Season", or "Warm and Fuzzy".

Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Takes long walks on the beach? (No effect)
  • Obsesses just like me? (No effect)

Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Romantic and a little dangerous... (No effect)

Choice 3 (Ava)

  • We knew where we'd end up. (No effect)
  • We could take a trip like that again. Just us. (No effect)

Choice 3 (Mason)

  • This'll never get old. (No effect)
  • I'm not sure which view I enjoy more. (No effect)

Choice 4 (Mason)

  • Mason, this is incredible! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Let's celebrate! (πŸ’Ž 20) πŸ“Œ
  • I should get back home. (Out of Date / Speed Date / Grounded)*

* The achievement depends on who you chose, Noah, Ava, or Mason, respectively.

Diamond Choice 1

  • Happy to be with the right person for me. (No effect)
  • Worried about how the others are doing. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • You showed me I could be different. (No effect)
  • You're a fighter. You fought for me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Ava)

  • Of your passion and confidence. (No effect)
  • We understand each other on a level they never could. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • You're my best friend! (No effect)
  • You've become your own man. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Slide onto his/her lap. (No effect)
  • Make more room. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Hide! (No effect)
  • I thought I said don't stop? (No effect)

"Rated L For Love"

Choice 6

  • Noah (No effect)
  • Ava (No effect)
  • Mason (No effect)

The LI you chose won't appear here.

Chapter Ninety-Six: Bittersweet Choices

You will meet both people you didn't choose as your final LI. The first set of choices are for the one you chose at the of Chapter 95, the second set is the second LI you have to reject.

Choice 1 (Noah)

  • I never meant for this to be so hard on you. (No effect)
  • But this doesn't have to be the end of everything! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Noah)

  • I gave my heart away long before we ever met. (No effect)
  • I thought you were the one. (No effect)

Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Help make this better. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Move on. (Heartbreak Hotel)

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • I don't want us to part on bad terms. (No effect)
  • Do you think you can forgive me? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • For stargazing. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • Take things one step at a time. (No effect)
  • Start fresh. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Noah)

  • Practice our dance moves? (No effect)
  • Raise a little hell? (No effect)

"Starry Eyed"

Choice 1 (Ava)

  • This wasn't your fault. (No effect)
  • You are anything but weak. (No effect)

Choice 2 (Ava)

  • That's a lot to live up to... (No effect)
  • I just think we were better as friends. (No effect)

Choice 3 (Ava)

  • Try to fix this. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Move on. (Clean Break)

Diamond Choice 1 (Ava)

  • You deserve nothing but happiness. (No effect)
  • I'm sorry. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Ava)

  • For the studio. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Ava)

  • You'll find someone new. (No effect)
  • It did matter. Never question that. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Ava)

  • All I can do is try to be better. (No effect)
  • Sometimes feelings are confusing. (No effect)

"Brunch Buddies"

Choice 1 (Mason)

  • I can't stand thinking that I ruined us! (No effect)
  • Thank you. (No effect)

Choice 2 (Mason)

  • That's a lot of pressure. (No effect)
  • I thought so too. (No effect)

Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Soften the blow. (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Move on. (Turbulence)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • Let's not leave it like this. (No effect)
  • I want to make things right. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • So you always know the way back. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • Found someone else. (No effect)
  • Became my own person. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Mason)

  • We'd only drift apart if we let it happen. (No effect)
  • We can grow as people and still support each other. (No effect)

"Chart the Course"

Chapter Ninety-Seven: One Last Night Choices

Choice 1

  • Just want everything to be perfect. (No effect)
  • Am just so nervous about this date. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • But I'm not sure I want something to happen after Prom. (No effect)
  • You said something right. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • 'A lady never kisses and tells.' (No effect)
  • 'Two can keep a secret if one is dead.' (No effect)

You are taken to the Closet here.

Choice 4

  • So let's go all out! (πŸ’Ž 25) (Ring the Alarm)
  • So I'd better stick to what I know. (No Frills)

Chapter Ninety-Eight: Our Carriage Awaits Choices

Choice 1

  • You... I... Wow. (No effect)
  • Hey, handsome. (No effect)
  • Hey, gorgeous. (No effect)

You get the second option if your LI is Noah or Mason, the third if it's Ava.

Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Noah, they're beautiful! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Ava)

  • Ava, it's beautiful! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Mason, it's beautiful! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Are you serious? (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Show me every detail. (πŸ’Ž 16)
  • On second thought, surprise me. (Just A Little Longer)

Diamond Choice 1

  • No promises. (No effect)
  • It's a limo. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I'm a better tease. (No effect)
  • I have other ideas in mind. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You already make me feel that way. (No effect)
  • I was thinking the same about you. (No effect)

"Sneak Preview"

Choice 5

  • Young love! (No effect)
  • The best night of our lives! (No effect)
  • This wild, unbelievable year! (No effect)

Chapter Ninety-Nine: Prom Night Choices

Choice 1

  • Take our Prom photo! (No effect)
  • Grab some punch! (No effect)
  • Hit the dance floor! (No effect)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.

Choice 2 (Prom Photo)

  • Traditional (No effect)
  • Romantic (No effect)
  • Fierce (No effect)

Choice 3 (Punch)

  • Mason (No effect)
  • Noah (No effect)
  • Ava (No effect)

Your LI won't appear here.

Choice 4 (Dance Floor)

  • Kiss me! (No effect)
  • Spin me! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Hack the vote! (πŸ’Ž 12)
  • Just let it go. (Long May She Rein)

Diamond Choice 1

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • I was thinking...

Default is "Swamp Queen".

Diamond Choice 2

  • Myself! (No effect)
  • Ava! (No effect)
  • Iris! (No effect)
  • Toni! (No effect)

Who you vote for here will win Prom Queen.

"New Notification"

Diamond Choice 3

  • It's gonna be the funniest prank ever! (No effect)
  • Now you have options. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Is an art hater! (No effect)
  • Doesn't deserve to represent Eastridge. (No effect)

"Democratic Monarchy"

Chapter One Hundred: Back to the Future Choices

Choice 1

  • Ooooh. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I love you too. (No effect)
  • I feel like the most special girl in the world. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I want you. (πŸ’Ž 30)
  • I'm not ready. (Innocence is Bliss)

Choice 4

  • A lot of video chats. (No effect)
  • Growing together. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Give in. (No effect)
  • Tease him/her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (Mason)

  • I'm gonna explode. (No effect)
  • You're stealing the show. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Mason)

  • Surprise me. (No effect)
  • Lay back and relax. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Mason)

  • The wait was worth it. (No effect)
  • I'm so glad it was you. (No effect)

"Friends To Lovers"

Diamond Choice 1 (Noah)

  • Find the next one. (No effect)
  • Let me touch one of yours. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Noah)

  • Take control. (No effect)
  • Lie on your back. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Noah)

  • I can't believe how sexy I feel. (No effect)
  • I'm so glad it was you. (No effect)

"A Little Naughty"

Diamond Choice 1 (Ava)

  • Don't stop. (No effect)
  • Let me show you how it feels. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Ava)

  • Let you have me. (No effect)
  • Take care of you first. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Ava)

  • I can't believe how sexy that was. (No effect)
  • I'm so glad it was you. (No effect)

"Three Cheers"

Diamond Choice 4 (if Mason isn't your LI and you have him the gift)

  • You kept it! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Maybe she thinks he'll change. (No effect)
  • That must be so hard for your mom. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (if Noah isn't your LI and you have him the gift)

  • You're letting them mess with it? (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Should be proud. (No effect)
  • Finally seem at ease. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (if Ava isn't your LI and you have her the gift)

  • They're still here! (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Your students are gonna kill it! (No effect)
  • No one does it better than you. (No effect)

You have reached the end of My Two First Loves.

Walkthroughs
The Freshman The Freshman, Book 1 Choices Β· The Freshman, Book 2 Choices Β· The Freshman, Book 3 Choices Β· The Freshman, Book 4 Choices Β· The Freshman: Love Bites Choices Β· The Freshman: Game of Love Choices Β· The Freshman: Snowed In Choices Β· Chris: Luxury Getaway Choices Β· James: Masquerade Ball Choices Β· Kaitlyn: The Perfect Date Choices
The Crown & The Flame The Crown & The Flame, Book 1 Choices Β· The Crown & The Flame, Book 2 Choices Β· The Crown & The Flame, Book 3 Choices
Most Wanted Most Wanted, Book 1 Choices
Rules of Engagement Rules of Engagement, Book 1 Choices Β· Rules of Engagement, Book 2 Choices Β· Rules of Engagement, Book 3 Choices Β· Rules of Engagement: Newlyweds Choices
Endless Summer Endless Summer, Book 1 Choices Β· Endless Summer, Book 2 Choices Β· Endless Summer, Book 3 Choices
#LoveHacks #LoveHacks, Book 1 Choices Β· #LoveHacks, Book 2 Choices
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor The Haunting of Braidwood Manor Choices
The Royal Romance The Royal Romance, Book 1 Choices Β· The Royal Romance, Book 2 Choices Β· The Royal Romance, Book 3 Choices Β· The Royal Holiday Choices
The Sophomore The Sophomore, Book 1 Choices Β· The Sophomore, Book 2 Choices Β· The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story Choices
Hero Hero, Vol. 1 Choices
High School Story High School Story, Book 1 Choices Β· High School Story, Book 2 Choices Β· High School Story, Book 3 Choices Β· High School Story: Class Act, Book 1 Choices Β· High School Story: Class Act, Book 2 Choices Β· High School Story: Class Act, Book 3 Choices
It Lives It Lives In The Woods Choices Β· It Lives Beneath Choices
Home for the Holidays Home for the Holidays Choices
Red Carpet Diaries Red Carpet Diaries, Book 1 Choices Β· Red Carpet Diaries, Book 2 Choices Β· Red Carpet Diaries, Book 3 Choices
Perfect Match Perfect Match, Book 1 Choices Β· Perfect Match, Book 2 Choices
Bloodbound Bloodbound, Book 1 Choices Β· Bloodbound, Book 2 Choices Β· Bloodbound, Book 3 Choices Β· Bloodbound: Dark Solstice Choices
The Junior The Junior, Book 1 Choices
Veil of Secrets Veil of Secrets Choices
America's Most Eligible America's Most Eligible: Season 10 Choices Β· America's Most Eligible: All Stars Choices Β· America's Most Eligible: Wedding Edition Choices
Desire & Decorum Desire & Decorum, Book 1 Choices Β· Desire & Decorum, Book 2 Choices Β· Desire & Decorum, Book 3 Choices Β· Desire & Decorum: First Winter Choices
Across the Void Across the Void Choices
The Senior The Senior Choices
Big Sky Country Big Sky Country, Book 1 Choices Β· Big Sky Country, Book 2 Choices
The Elementalists The Elementalists, Book 1 Choices Β· The Elementalists, Book 2 Choices Β· The Elementalists: Winters Past Choices
A Courtesan of Rome A Courtesan of Rome Choices
The Heist: Monaco The Heist: Monaco Choices
Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 1 Choices
Open Heart Open Heart, Book 1 Choices Β· Open Heart: Second Year Choices Β· Open Heart: Third Year Choices
Passport to Romance Passport to Romance Choices
Wishful Thinking Wishful Thinking Choices
Nightbound Nightbound Choices
Platinum Platinum Choices
The Royal Heir The Royal Heir, Book 1 Choices Β· The Royal Heir, Book 2 Choices Β· The Royal Heir, Book 3 Choices
Sunkissed Sunkissed Choices
Bachelorette Party Bachelorette Party Choices
Mother of the Year Mother of the Year Choices
Save the Date Save the Date Choices
The Royal Masquerade The Royal Masquerade Choices
Baby Bump Baby Bump, Book 1 Choices Β· Baby Bump, Book 2 Choices
Blades of Light and Shadow Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 1 Choices Β· Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 2 Choices
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Choices
Distant Shores Distant Shores Choices
The Nanny Affair The Nanny Affair, Book 1 Choices Β· The Nanny Affair, Book 2 Choices
Queen B Queen B, Book 1 Choices Β· Queen B, Book 2 Choices
My Two First Loves My Two First Loves Choices
Rising Tides Rising Tides Choices
Hot Couture Hot Couture Choices
Foreign Affairs Foreign Affairs Choices
With Every Heartbeat With Every Heartbeat Choices
A Very Scandalous Proposal A Very Scandalous Proposal Choices
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.