If you haven't read the most recent chapter and are looking for a walkthrough, be aware that the page is full of spoilers. |
This page contains the choices in My Fake Valentine and their outcomes.
This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!
Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!
Setup Choices
Choice 1
- Yes! That's me. (Go to Choice 5)
- I'd like to customize my look. (Go to Choices 2-4)
Choice 2
- Face 1
- Face 2
- Face 3
- Face 4
Choice 3
- Fiery Cascade
- Sunkissed Shimmer
- Chestnut Twirl
- Onyx Pixie
- Fun Bun
- Raven Coils
Choice 4
- Great! I love it!
- Let's try something else. (Go Back to Choice 1)
Choice 5
This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
- What is your name?
Default is "Emily".
Choice 6
This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
- And your family name?
Default is "Thompson".
Chapter One: Will You Be My 'Fake' Valentine? Choices
Choice 1
- Wish! I love this time of year! (No effect)
- Honestly can't wait until it's over. (No effect)
Choice 2 (Elijah/Eden)
- A man.
- A woman.
Choice 3 (Elijah/Eden)
- Face 1
- Face 2
- Face 3
- Show me female/male options
Choice 4
- Give a friendly wave. (No effect)
- Look away! Look away! (No effect)
Choice 5
- Bet he/she could use a pick me up. (No effect)
- Should go check on him/her. (No effect)
Choice 6
- Well, I'm off to a great start. (No effect)
- Oh my god, I'm so sorry! (No effect)
Choice 7
- You really want me, a stranger, to go out with you? (No effect)
- That's quite a proposition after I ruined your outfit. (No effect)
Choice 8
This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
- What's his/her name?
Default is "Elijah" for male LI, "Eden" for female LI.
Choice 9
This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
- And last name?
Default is "Carter".
Choice 10
- Yes! Let's make some sweet treats! (💎 15) (
+VALENTINE) - On second thought, I'll pass. (Path Less Taken)
Diamond Choice 1
- Something bold with a kick of spice. (No effect)
- A zesty twist with orange. (No effect)
- Classic milk chocolate, your favorite. ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 2
- Reach out and wipe it away. (
+VALENTINE) - Point it out to him/her. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 3
- What's your secret to a successful relationship? ( +VALENTINE)
- How do you keep the chemistry alive? ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 4
- We make a pretty good team, don't you think? (No effect)
- Chocolate-making might be your true calling. (No effect)
"Chocolate Maestra"
Choice 11
- Love that movie! (No effect)
- Didn't know you were into rom-coms. (No effect)
Choice 12
- Guess there was this one time... (No effect)
- Was way too shy. (No effect)
Choice 13
- You were made for journalism. (No effect)
- You really take this job seriously, huh? (No effect)
Choice 14
- The relationships are the plot! (No effect)
- The tropes are the best part! (No effect)
Choice 15
- Yes! Let's explore the lover's spot together. (💎 15)
- Not tonight. (Direct Route)
Diamond Choice 5
- I've never done that either. (No effect)
- So you've never wanted to pull over for a scenic makeout? (No effect)
Diamond Choice 6
- I think that's admirable. (No effect)
- Maybe it's pushing you in a good direction. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 7
- I can be creative with my food. (No effect)
- My grandma's cooking always inspired me. (No effect)
- It lets me express what I can't with words. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 8
- You did buy my movie ticket, so I guess I owe you a meal. ( +VALENTINE)
- If you want me to cook for you, you're gonna have to see me again. ( +VALENTINE)
"Secret Detour"
Choice 16
- Last time I checked it was! (No effect)
- Yep, why do you ask? (No effect)
Chapter Two: The Second Date Choices
Choice 1
- You're more fun to wake up to than my alarm clock. (No effect)
- I was up anyway. (No effect)
Choice 2
- What's in it for me? (No effect)
- But I'm not a romance expert. (No effect)
- Then let's get started! (No effect)
+VALENTINE
Choice 3
- I Love L.A. (💎 18) (Turning Heads)
- No thanks (No effect)
Choice 4
- Santa Monica Pier. ( +VALENTINE) ⬅ Correct
- Venice Beach. (No effect)
- The Hollywood Sign. (No effect)
Choice 5
- Back in high school with friends. (No effect)
- Not since I was young and my grandma would make a day of it. (No effect)
- Recently with my coworkers! (No effect)
Choice 6
- How long have you been together? (No effect)
- What do you do for Valentine's Day? (No effect)
- What makes your relationship work? (No effect)
Choice 7
This is a timed choice. The option order is random.
- Fumble and miss. (No effect)
- Throw the ring to the left. ( +VALENTINE)
- Throw the ring at the center. ( +VALENTINE)
If the timer ends, the first option is selected?
Choice 8
- Here. I can feed it to you. ( +VALENTINE)
- I guess you'll have to wait until one of your hands becomes free. (No effect)
Choice 9
- Echo Park. (No effect) ⬅ Correct
- MacArthur Park. (No effect)
- Lake Hollywood. (No effect)
Choice 10
- Yes! The perfect excuse to be alone with him/her! (💎 25) ( +VALENTINE)
- No, let's skip it. (Smooth Sailing Awaits, Go to Choice 11)
Diamond Choice 1
- Am I really being helpful with this article? (No effect)
- How do you usually celebrate Valentine's Day? (No effect)
Diamond Choice 2
- I guess I just see beauty in small things. (No effect)
- It's easy with great company. ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 3
- Lean into his/her touch a little. (No effect)
- Scoot back. (No effect)
+VALENTINE, "Echoes of Us"
Choice 11 (Non-diamond)
- How my ex ruined Valentine's Day for me. ( +VALENTINE)
- How I want to start enjoying this time of year again. ( +VALENTINE)
Choice 12
- It was super romantic. ( +VALENTINE)
- It was kind of goofy. ( +VALENTINE)
- It depends on who you go with. ( +VALENTINE)
Choice 13
- Yes! Let's guarantee our win! (💎 18)
- We should just wing it instead. (Go With the Flow)
Diamond Choice 4
- Reading with a cup of tea. (No effect)
- Binge-watching TV. (No effect)
- Getting outdoors! (No effect)
Diamond Choice 5
- Make the perfect model, you know. (No effect)
- Would love to see your work sometime. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 6
- So basically someone like me? ( +VALENTINE)
- Those are great values. (No effect)
"Perfect Pair Potential"
Choice 14
The option order is random.
- Pursue photography. ( +POINT) ⬅ Correct
- Play sports. ( -POINT)
- Watch TV. ( -POINT)
Choice 15
The option order is random.
- College. ( -POINT)
- My work. ( +POINT) ⬅ Correct
- A birthday party. ( -POINT)
Choice 16
This is a timed choice. The option order is random.
- Honesty and loyalty. ( -POINT)
- Humor and kindness. ( +POINT) ⬅ Correct
- My physical appearance. ( -POINT)
If the timer ends, the third option is selected.
"A Match Made in Heaven", +VALENTINE if you got 2 or more 
+POINT.
"Better Luck Next Time" if you got 1 or less +POINT.
Choice 17
- Back off. He/She's taken. (No effect)
- He/She's more focused on his/her interpretive dance classes right now. (No effect)
Choice 18
- Not feeling well. (No effect)
- Getting tired. (No effect)
Chapter Three: Wined and Dined Choices
Choice 1
- I can't wait to see you! (No effect)
- I still don't know how you got a reservation. (No effect)
Choice 2
- But I could totally be deluding myself. (No effect)
- And I'm ninety-nine percent sure he/she's into me. (No effect)
Choice 3
- Little Pink Dress (💎 18) (All Dressed Up, Stunning Surprise, +VALENTINE)
- No thanks (No effect)
Choice 4
- Is it legal to look that good? ( +VALENTINE)
- You look, um, really nice tonight. ( +VALENTINE)
+VALENTINE if you're wearing "Little Pink Dress".
Choice 5
- Excited to see the menu! (No effect)
- Excited to be here... together. ( +VALENTINE)
Choice 6
- That was just a strategic move to get your attention. ( +VALENTINE)
- You and I both know it was an accident! (No effect)
- Don't tempt me, I might just do it again. (No effect)
Choice 7
- A memorable date. (No effect)
- Journalistic research. (No effect)
Choice 8
- Makes me laugh. (No effect)
- Is passionate about their work. (No effect)
- Challenges me to grow. (No effect)
Choice 9
- Time to dig in! (No effect)
Choice 10
- Maybe I wanted them to be right. ( +VALENTINE)
- It's for your article, right? (No effect)
Choice 11
- All right, I trust you. ( +VALENTINE)
- What kind of surprises? (No effect)
- Are we not going to talk about... this? (No effect)
Choice 12
- What are we doing in the kitchen? (No effect)
- Isn't this a safety hazard? (No effect)
Choice 13
- Have been dreaming of attending Le Cordon Bleu for forever! (No effect)
- Am such a fan. I've followed your work for ages! (No effect)
Choice 14
- Think that was incredibly thoughtful. (No effect)
- Am wondering why you went through all that trouble. (No effect)
Choice 15
- Are you trying to break in right now? (No effect)
- Maybe we should find another spot? (No effect)
+VALENTINE
Choice 16
- Hold up a sprig of herbs for him/her to smell. (No effect)
- Ask him/her how he/she found this place. (No effect)
Choice 17
- You're still holding my hand. (No effect)
- This is the most romantic spot you've found yet. (No effect)
Choice 18
- What have you done with the real Elijah/Eden? (No effect)
- Why are we here? (No effect)
+VALENTINE
Choice 19
- Yes! I want more! (💎 25) ( +VALENTINE)
- Keep it short and sweet. (Taking it Slow)
Diamond Choice 1
- Bite his/her lip. ( +VALENTINE)
- Trail my hands down his/her chest. ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 2
- Should we worried about someone catching us? (No effect)
- I've never felt this way before. (No effect)
- So where does this fit in your article? (No effect)
Diamond Choice 3
- Wrap my legs around his/her waist. (No effect)
- Push him/her onto the bench and straddle him/her. (No effect)
"Rooftop Romance"
Choice 20
- Give him/her a sweet peck. (No effect)
- Tell him/her I can't wait to see him/her tomorrow. (No effect)
Choice 21
- Text him/her again. (No effect)
- Wait a bit longer. (No effect)
Chapter Four: The Real Deal Choices
Choice 1
- I hope those flowers come with a good story. (No effect)
- If you're looking for a date, that window just closed... (No effect)
Choice 2
- Get in here already! (No effect)
- You can come in, but the jury's still out. (No effect)
Choice 3
- Take them. (No effect)
Choice 4
- Three months is a long time. (No effect)
- So what does this mean for us? (No effect)
Choice 5
- Pull him/her into a hug. (No effect)
- Kiss him/her softly. (No effect)
- Let him/her sweat it out a bit longer. (No effect)
+VALENTINE
Choice 6
- Heart's Desire (💎 18) (Perfect Match)
- No thanks (No effect)
Diamond Choice 1
- Do a little spin for him/her. ( +VALENTINE)
- Pull him/her closer. ( +VALENTINE)
"Two of a Kind"
Choice 7
- You hold my hand? For good luck. ( +VALENTINE)
- You're okay with me winning them over. (No effect)
- You promise they don't bite. (No effect)
Choice 8
- He/She did all the hard work himself/herself. (No effect)
- Someone had to show him/her the light. (No effect)
Choice 9
- You never tried to win me over with cookies! (No effect)
- So you're kind of a suck-up, huh? (No effect)
Choice 10
- We should've turned Valentine's Day into a competition. (No effect)
- Please say there are photos! (No effect)
Choice 11
- Perfect excuse to get closer to you. (No effect)
- Watch me become the champion of Suck and Blow. (No effect)
Choice 12
- Drop the card and kiss Elijah/Eden. ( +VALENTINE)
- Pass the card. (No effect)
Choice 13
- Yes! Let's save dessert together! (💎 18)
- We shouldn't get involved. (Not My Circus)
Diamond Choice 2
- Looks like we're a dream team in the kitchen. (No effect)
- Glad you're here to help fetch ingredients. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 3
- No unapproved taste tests! (No effect)
- What about me? (No effect)
Diamond Choice 4
- Lean into his/her touch. ( +VALENTINE)
- Turn around and give him/her a kiss. ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 5
- Hope they like it! (No effect)
"Dessert Hero"
Choice 14
- Of course! I thought you'd never ask. (No effect)
- As long as you promise not to step on my toes. (No effect)
Choice 15
- Pull him/her closer. (No effect)
- Spin into his/her arms. (No effect)
Choice 16
- Am too. Tonight has been perfect. (No effect)
- Am still sad you're leaving tomorrow. (No effect)
Choice 17
- You've really captured something beautiful here. (No effect)
- I didn't realize our time meant that much to you. (No effect)
Choice 18
- Yes! (💎 30) ( +VALENTINE)
- Let's take it slow. (Taking It Slow)
Diamond Choice 6
- Then undress me. (No effect)
- I'd rather let you watch. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 7
- So hot. (No effect)
- Like something straight out of a magazine. (No effect)
Diamond Choice 8 (Eden)
- Your mouth on me. ( +VALENTINE)
- You to use your hands. ( +VALENTINE)
Diamond Choice 8 (Elijah)
- Straddle him. ( +VALENTINE)
- Let him remain on top. (No effect)
"A Night to Remember"
Choice 19
- Feel the same way. (No effect)
- Could be up for one more date. (No effect)
Choice 20
- Kiss him/her goodbye. ( +VALENTINE)
- Pull him/her in for one last embrace. ( +VALENTINE)
Choice 21
- Ready for this new chapter. (No effect)
- Bittersweet about leaving. (No effect)
+VALENTINE
Choice 22
- I'm in. (No effect)
- Hard to say no when you've come all this way... (No effect)
You have reached the end of My Fake Valentine.