Dog
People aren't the only ones to make a lot of appearances. The adorable little homeless dog that Dave can adopt after the trouble in Tull's stolen RV has made a lot of appearances in the Choices universe.
- Most Wanted: Dog
- Rules of Engagement: Dog
- LoveHacks: Puppy
- High School Story: Puppy, the puppy
- Perfect Match: Puppy
- The Junior: Wordsworth Puppington I
- A Very Scandalous Proposal: Mutt
The Hawk
- The Crown & The Flame: The Hawk
- The Royal Romance: Tiberius
- High School Story: Utah, the Hawk
- Mother of the Year: Hawk
- The Royal Masquerade: Princess Astralla
- Save the Date: William T. Riker
- Wolf Bride: Hawk
- The Princess Swap: Yasmin
- Guinevere: Aella
- First Comes Love: Hawk
- Years Apart: Hawk
The Bear
- The Crown & The Flame: The Bear
- It Lives in the Woods: Bear
- Big Sky Country: Bear
- The Elementalists: Bear
- Nightbound: Grizzly Bear
- The Royal Heir: Bear
- Mother of the Year: Bear
- The Royal Masquerade: Bear
- Bloodbound: Bear
- Immortal Desires: Bear
- The Nanny Affair: Bear
- Kindred: Saffron (Bear)
Mechataur
- The Crown & The Flame: Mechataur
- The Elementalists: Security Guard
- The Royal Heir: Nevrakis Steward
Bubbles
- The Crown & The Flame: Bubbles, the baby kraken
- Across the Void: Kraken
- The Royal Heir: Squid
- The Royal Heir: Octopus
- The Cursed Heart: Baby Kraken
- First Comes Love: Octopus
- All of Us: Octopus
- Blades of Light and Shadow: Octopus
Kraken
- The Crown & The Flame: Kraken
- Nightbound: Kraken
- Red Carpet Diaries: Alien Monster
- Blades of Light and Shadow: Bloodsquid
Bat
- The Freshman: Bat
- LoveHacks: Bat
- Bachelorette Party: Vampire Bat
- Bitten: Cletus
- Bitten: Bats