FANDOM


THIS ARTICLE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION!

Please refrain from editing until this notice is removed.


DS01ThumbCover 1
SPOILER ALERT
If you haven't read the most recent chapter and are looking for a walkthrough, be aware that the page is full of spoilers.

This page contains the choices in Distant Shores and their outcomes.

This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices

Choice 1

  • Man.
  • Woman.

Choice 2

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3
  • Face 4

Choice 3 (Hair - Male)

  • Man Bun (💎 15)
  • Windswept Wonder (💎 15)
  • Black Fade
  • Short Blond
  • Tousled Brown

Choice 3 (Hair - Female)

  • Golden Locks (💎 15)
  • Elegant Updo (💎 15)
  • Red Waves
  • High Bun
  • Long Blonde

Choice 4 (Outfit)

  • A Pirate's Life (💎 20)
  • Landlubber

Choice 5

  • Aye, 'tis perfect!
  • Avast! Let's start again. (Go back to Choice 1)

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your character's first name:

Default is "Peyton".

Choice 7

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter your character's last name:

Default is "Bellamy".

Chapter One: Swept Away Choices

Choice 1

  • Parry! (No effect)
  • Dodge! (No effect)

Choice 2 (Edward)

  • Face 1
  • Face 2
  • Face 3
  • Face 4

Choice 3

  • It's calling to you... (No effect)

Choice 4

  • What did I do?! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • ♡ But not as fine as you. (No effect)
  • But you should probably worry about them! (No effect)

Choice 6

This is a timed choice.

  • Fight! (No effect)
  • Hide! (No effect)

If the timer ends, you hide.

Choice 7

  • Now Edward has it? (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Take his hand. (No effect)
  • Hesitate. (No effect)

Choice 9

  • I would be acting less suspiciously. (No effect)
  • ♡ I would've just slept with Edward to get his secrets. (No effect)

Choice 10

  • A little worse for wear... (No effect)

Choice 11

  • I'm a nobody. (No effect)
  • I'm really far from home. (No effect)
  • ♡ I have a weakness for attractive quartermasters. (No effect)

Choice 12

  • Catch! (First Bounty)

Choice 13

  • Then swab the barrel clean. (No effect)

Choice 14

  • Oil the outside. (No effect)
  • Oil the inside. (No effect)
  • Oil it everywhere. (+Crew x2)

Choice 15

  • Fetch rum with Charlie. (💎 15)
  • Stay above deck. (But Why is the Rum Gone?)

Diamond Choice 1

  • ♡ Keep holding her hand. (No effect)
  • Let go and thank her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • How did you become a pirate? (No effect)
  • What's it like being a woman on a ship? (No effect)
  • ♡ Do you always bring prisoners to secluded places like this? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Cheers! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

This is a timed choice.

  • Jump out of the way! (No effect)
  • Pull Charlie to safety! (No effect)
  • Freeze! (No effect)

If the timer ends, you freeze and Charlie saves you

"Cheers" and +Crew

If you didn't help Charlie with the rum, Choice 16 will happen after Choice 18.

Choice 16

  • To kill the germs. (+Crew)
  • To help with the pain. (+Crew)

Choice 17

  • With what I hope is jam. (No effect)

Choice 18

  • That's nasty. (+Crew)
  • It's like nothing I've ever tasted before. (+Crew)

+Crew x4 if you helped Charlie look for rum.

Diamond Choice 5

  • Not being executed tomorrow! (No effect)
  • Finding my way home! (+Crew)
  • Never running out of rum! (+Crew)

This choice is only available if you helped Charlie look for rum.

Choice 19

  • Keep watch with Edward. (💎 18)
  • Go with Robert. (One Quiet Night)

Diamond Choice 6

  • Then why'd you bother inviting me along? (No effect)
  • ♡ And here I thought you wanted some alone time with me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7

  • Are you always this rude to your guests? (No effect)
  • Why aren't you drinking with the crew? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8

  • Subtly ask about the compass. (No effect)
  • Change the subject. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9

  • Did you find what you were looking for? (No effect)
  • How much 'harm' did you cause? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10

  • ♡ Lean closer. (No effect)
  • Pull back. (No effect)

"Star Light, Star Bright"

Chapter Two: A Pirate's Life Choices

Choice 1

  • Don't fall off! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Human life is hardly a trifle. (No effect)
  • Keep it up, and I'll curse you next! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Appeal to Edward's emotional side. (No effect)
  • Redirect everyone's attention back to Robert. (No effect)
  • ♡ Flirt with Edward. (No effect)

"One of the Crew" if you got 7 +Crew or more (impossible without diamonds).

"Close Call" if you got 6 +Crew or less.

Choice 4

This is a timed choice.

  • Panic and flail! (-Pirate)
  • Catch the rope! (+Pirate)

If the timer ends, you panic and flail (-Pirate)

Choice 5

This is a timed choice.

  • Following Edward? (No effect)
  • Checking out the town. (No effect) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you say nothing and Charlie catches you staring at Edward

Choice 6

  • But I didn't do anything. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Play along! (No effect)
  • Admonish the boy. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Bonnie Lad/Lass (💎 25) (Bonnie Lad/Lass)
  • No thanks (No effect)

Choice 9

  • Did you get all your business done this afternoon? (No effect)
  • ♡ Did you miss me today? (No effect)

Choice 10

  • What happened? (No effect)
  • I'm so sorry. (No effect)

Choice 11

  • Who is he to you? (No effect)
  • Is it because he's in charge of the navy? (No effect)

Choice 12

  • Close enough to touch... (No effect)

Choice 13

  • Play a drinking game with the crew! (💎 15)
  • Call it a night. (Dry Run)

Diamond Choice 1

  • The fire. (No effect) ⬅ Correct
  • The shark.
  • The wives. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • The prince thing. (No effect)
  • The Poseidon thing. (No effect)
  • The rum thing. (No effect)

All of them are lies.

Diamond Choice 3

  • You're the son of a duke.
  • You've met the Queen. (No effect) ⬅ Correct
  • You kissed a mermaid. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • I've lived in parts of the New World that aren't on the map. (No effect)
  • I've flown thousands of miles through the air. (No effect)
  • I've read stories where I control the ending. (No effect)

"Another!"

Choice 14

  • Flashlight... on! (No effect)

Chapter Three: Live By the Sword Choices

Choice 1

  • Bribe him. (No effect)
  • Punch him. (No effect)
  • Make a run for it! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Samuel (No effect)
  • Maggie (No effect)
  • Kendrick (No effect)

Choice 3

  • ♡ Flirt with Edward. (No effect)
  • Spill rum on Robert. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Take a walk with Edward. (💎 17)
  • Try to find a better time later. (Secrets Left Unsaid)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Why do you give a share of the spoils to the village? (No effect)
  • What do you want most in life? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • I haven't found the right person yet. (No effect)
  • I'm not looking for romance. (No effect)
  • I'd rather have a wife. (No effect)

You only get the third option if you're a woman.

Diamond Choice 3

  • Tell him the truth. (Path A)
  • Avoid answering. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Path A)

  • Turn it back on. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Path A)

  • Lots and lots of selfies. (No effect)
  • Pictures of our family dog. (No effect)
  • Pictures of my last trip to Vegas. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Path A)

  • Keep scrolling. (No effect)

"Warning Shot"

Diamond Choice 7 (Path A) (if you have enough romance points with Edward)

  • ♡ Lean in to kiss him. (No effect)
  • Step back. (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Boatswain (No effect)
  • Gunner (No effect)
  • Sailor (No effect)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.

Choice 6 (Boatswain)

  • Looped at the end. (No effect)

Choice 7 (Boatswain)

  • Kinda looks like a square... (No effect)

Choice 8 (Boatswain)

  • Wrapped around a railing. (No effect)

Choice 9 (Boatswain)

  • With the bowline knot. (-Boatswain)
  • With the clove hitch knot. (-Boatswain)
  • With the reef knot. (+Boatswain) ⬅ Correct

Choice 10 (Boatswain)

  • With the bowline knot. (-Boatswain)
  • With the clove hitch knot. (+Boatswain) ⬅ Correct
  • With the reef knot. (-Boatswain)

Choice 11 (Boatswain)

  • The bowline knot. (+Boatswain) ⬅ Correct
  • The clove hitch knot. (-Boatswain)
  • The reef knot. (-Boatswain)

Choice 12 (Gunner)

  • The cannon ball (-Gunner)
  • The wad (-Gunner)
  • The gun powder (+Gunner) ⬅ Correct

Choice 13 (Gunner)

  • The gun powder (-Gunner)
  • The wad (+Gunner) ⬅ Correct
  • The cannon ball (-Gunner)

Choice 14 (Gunner)

  • The gun powder (-Gunner)
  • The cannon ball (+Gunner) ⬅ Correct
  • The wad (-Gunner)

Choice 15-19 (Sailor)

This is a timed choice.

  • Forward!
  • Left!
  • Right!
  • Back!

Match your movements to the prompts as they pop up on-screen. If the timer runs out you do nothing.

+Sailor if you got 3 or more correct.
-Sailor if you got 2 or less correct.

Choice 20 (Passed at least one job)

  • Sailor (Sail Ho)
  • Gunner (Big Shot)
  • Boatswain (Tie The Knot)

Sailor only appears if you got +Sailor.
Gunner only appears if you got 2 or more +Gunner.
Boatswain only appears if you got 2 or more +Boatswain.

Choice 20 (Failed at every job)

  • Practice makes perfect. (Tie The Knot)

If you didn't get enough +Sailor, +Gunner, and +Boatswain you will get this choice and be assigned boatswain.

Choice 21

  • Edward (No effect)
  • Charlie (No effect)

Choice 22

  • Catch! (No effect)

Choice 23

  • Learn sword fighting from Edward! (💎 18)
  • Learn sword fighting from Charlie! (💎 18)
  • Watch with the rest of the crew. (Not A Fighter)

Diamond Choice 8 (Charlie)

  • High! (No effect)
  • Low! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Edward)

  • Counterattack! (No effect)
  • Evade! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9

  • Fighting on the streets. (No effect)
  • A master in a distant country. (No effect)
  • Your mom! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10

  • ♡ Lean in for a kiss. (No effect)
  • Finish the fight. (No effect)

"En Garde"

Choice 24

  • Wait a second... (No effect)

Choice 25

  • Okay, that makes more sense. (No effect)

Choice 26

  • I won't hold you back. (No effect)
  • That's suicide! (No effect)

Chapter Four: Mutiny on the Revenge Choices

Choice 1

  • Pointing right at Edward! (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Ridiculous! (No effect)
  • Terrifying! (No effect)
  • All my fault! (No effect)

Choice 3

This is a timed choice.

  • Trip Edward! (No effect)
  • Trip Robert! (No effect)
  • Dodge! (No effect)

If the timer ends, Charlie pulls you out of the way.

Choice 4

  • Drawn and ready. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 (if you practiced sword fighting with Edward/Charlie)

  • Parry! (No effect)
  • Feint! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Take Robert's sword! (💎 20)
  • Try to stand your ground. (Out of Measure)

Diamond Choice 2

  • You're the problem here. (No effect)
  • You talk too much. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Block the blow! (No effect)
  • Dodge his attack! (No effect)
  • Distract him! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • Catch it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • And that's how it's done. (No effect)
  • That was just like the movies! (No effect)
  • That was for Edward. (No effect)

"A Cutlass Above the Rest"

Choice 6

  • Jonas, are you seriously doing this? (No effect)
  • Ginny, calm down. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Convince Jonas to stay for Ginny. (💎 18)
  • Let him go. (Pushin' Him Away)

Diamond Choice 6

  • They mean everything to him too. (No effect)
  • Robert's just trying to manipulate you. (No effect)
  • You've come this far together. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7

  • He has an agenda. (No effect)
  • He's a back-stabbing sneak. (No effect)
  • There's something off about that guy. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8

  • You're the only family she has left. (No effect)
  • What would you teach her by leaving? (No effect)

"Family Loyalty"

Diamond Choice 9 (if you warned Edward about the mutiny)

  • Gotcha! (It's a Trap!)

Diamond Choice 10 (if you warned Edward about the mutiny)

  • It was my pleasure. (No effect)
  • I'm just glad it's over. (No effect)

"Too Little, Too Late" if you didn't warn him.

Choice 8 (if you didn't warn Edward)

This is a timed choice

  • Robert! (No effect)
  • Octavia! (No effect)
  • Edward!

If the timer runs out, ?

Choice 9

  • My first mate didn't just betray me. (No effect)
  • I'm fine. (No effect)

Choice 10

  • He must be tending to others. (No effect)
  • Why bother with a surgeon if he's not around when you need him? (No effect)

Choice 11

  • Take care of Charlie yourself. (💎 17)
  • Let Henry handle it. (Sew No Mercy)

Diamond Choice 11

  • Those surgeons were idiots. (No effect)
  • You're delusional from the pain. (No effect)
  • Just... trust me, okay? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12

  • Tell her a story about my past. (No effect)
  • Offer her some rum. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 13

  • ♡ Kiss her. (No effect)
  • Pull back. (No effect)

"The Doctor Is In"

Diamond Choice 14

  • Tell the truth. (Path A)
  • Say nothing. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15 (Path A)

  • My phone! (No effect)
  • My outfit! (No effect)

Choice 12

  • They're escaping! (No effect)

Chapter Five: Changing Course Choices

Choice 1

  • Edward's still got it. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Are you alright? (No effect)
  • Are you just going to let them get away with that? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I'm feeling surprisingly calm. (No effect)
  • I'm freaking out. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Help Charlie with her quartermaster duties. (💎 16)
  • Stick to your day job. (On Your Own) (Go to Choices 5-8)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Oooo, shinies! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Hell yeah. (No effect)
  • ♡ Around you? Always. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Robert's Sword)

  • Strike that, my sword. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • That's on-brand. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Edward (No effect)
  • Charlie (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • A shiny ring. (No effect)
  • A shiny goblet. (No effect)
  • A shiny necklace. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7

  • Tease her. (No effect)
  • ♡ Kiss her. (No effect)

"Tight Quarters"

If you helped Charlie with her quartermaster duties, you skip Choices 5-8.

Choice 5 (Sailor)

This is a timed choice​.​

  • Let go! (-Sailor)
  • Hold on! (+Sailor)

If the timer ends, you let go. (-Sailor)

Choice 6 (Sailor)

  • Help me. (-Sailor)
  • Unfurl the jib. (+Sailor)

Choice 5 (Boatswain)

This is a timed choice​.​

  • The bowsprit! (+Boatswain)
  • The rope! (+Boatswain)

If the timer ends, you miss and are thrown from the bowsprit. (-Boatswain)

Choice 6 (Boatswain)

  • Clean of the barnacles. (+Boatswain)
  • Tie the splintered wood together. (-Boatswain)

Choice 7 (Boatswain)

  • Perfect for bundling. (No effect)

Choice 5 (Gunner)

  • Move the barrel. (No effect)

Choice 6 (Gunner)

  • Pick it up... carefully! (No effect)

Choice 7 (Gunner)

This is a timed choice.

  • Drop! (-Gunner)
  • Steady! (+Gunner)

If the timer ends, you drop it. (-Gunner)

Choice 8 (Gunner)

This is a timed choice.

  • Step over! (+Gunner)
  • Trip over! (-Gunner)

If the timer ends, you trip. (-Gunner)

Choice 9

  • A ship? (No effect)

Choice 10

  • Is it wise to chase them when we're short-handed? (No effect)
  • This is so exciting! (No effect)

Choice 11

This is a timed choice.

  • Toward the ship (+Navigate)
  • Away from the ship (-Navigate)

If the timer ends, you steer her away from the ship. (-Navigate)

Choice 12

This is a timed choice.

  • Take a deep breath. (+Navigate)
  • Get your head out of your ass. (-Navigate)

If the timer ends, you hesitate and say nothing. (-Navigate)

Choice 13

  • There it goes! (No effect)

Choice 14

  • Revenge. (No effect)
  • Justice. (No effect)

Choice 15

  • Talk to Edward. (💎 20)
  • Give him time to cool off. (Steer Clear)

Diamond Choice 8

  • What's the deal with you and the Admiral? (No effect)
  • You don't have to talk about it, if you don't want to. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9

  • You have to do what you feel is right. (No effect)
  • You're on a dangerous path. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10

  • Someone's got to watch your back. (No effect)
  • I'm up to the challenge. (No effect)

"Storm Along"

Choice 16

  • It's finally yours! (No effect)

Choice 17

This is a timed choice.

  • West. (-Navigate)
  • East. (+Navigate)

If the timer ends, you steer west. (-Navigate)

Choice 18

  • That dastardly cargo ship! (No effect)

Choice 19

This is a timed choice.

  • Give the command! (+Navigate)
  • Watch the fireworks. (No effect)

If the timer ends, you watch the fireworks. (No effect)

Choice 20

  • Board the cargo ship! (💎 17)
  • Let them go without you. (Board to Death)

Diamond Choice 11

  • Make a proper pirate entrance! (+Pirate)
  • Knock down an enemy on my way! (+Pirate)

Diamond Choice 12

  • Shoot their powder keg. (No effect)
  • Attack the gunners! (+Pirate)

Diamond Choice 13 (Shoot)

  • Fire! (+Pirate)

Diamond Choice 14

  • Then pull with all your might! (+Pirate)

Diamond Choice 15

  • Strangely sad. (No effect)
  • Exhilarated. (No effect)
  • Looking forward to the treasure. (No effect)

"No Prey, No Pay"

Diamond Choice 15

  • Get a better look. (No effect)

Chapter Six: Without a Net Choices

Choice 1

This is a timed choice.

  • Wait for the wind to die down. (-Pirate)
  • Catch and tie! (+Pirate) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you wait for the wind to die down. (-Pirate)

Choice 2

  • Ouch, that's gonna sting. (No effect)

Choice 3

  • You're the sniveling fool! (No effect)
  • If you don't want the dagger, I'll take it. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • I thought we were looking for recruits. (No effect)
  • Do we have time to watch a show? (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Volunteer for the trapeze with Edward! (💎 15)
  • Volunteer for the trapeze with Charlie! (💎 15)
  • Stay in your seat next to Tripp. (Feet On The Ground)

Diamond Choice 1

  • Focus on climbing. (No effect)
  • Play to the crowd. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

This is a timed choice.

  • Miss the bar! (-Trapeze)
  • Grab the bar! (+Trapeze) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you miss the bar. (-Trapeze)

Diamond Choice 3

  • Jump into Charlie's/Edward's arms! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Charlie)

  • ♡ Kiss Charlie! (No effect)
  • Take a bow with her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Edward)

  • We should take a bow. (No effect)
  • ♡ I'm not ready to let go just yet. (No effect)

"Flyin' High"

Choice 6

  • Huh? (No effect)
  • Full sentences might help. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • I don't know about this... (No effect)
  • Oh, I'm so down. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • Thief in the Night (💎 25) (Thief in the Night)
  • No thanks (No effect)

Choice 9

This is a timed choice.

  • Pick the lock! (+Thief) ⬅ Correct
  • Smash a window instead. (-Thief)

If the timer ends, you smash a window. (-Thief)

+Thief if you're wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 10

  • A gold necklace. (No effect)
  • Jade cufflinks. (No effect)
  • A giant ruby. (No effect)

Choice 11

  • A passport? (No effect)

+Thief if you're wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 12

This is a timed choice.

  • Under the bed! (+Thief) ⬅ Correct
  • Behind the curtain! (+Thief) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you freeze. (-Thief)

+Thief if you're wearing the premium outfit.

"Thick as Thieves" if you got 2 or more +Thief.

Choice 13

This is a timed choice.

  • Stay silent! (+Thief) ⬅ Correct
  • Sneeze! (-Thief)

If the timer ends, you stay silent. (+Thief) ⬅ Correct

Choice 14

  • Getting caught yourself won't help. (No effect)
  • I'm sure you'll be together again someday. (No effect)

Choice 15

  • Help Axton save Ada and recruit them both! (💎 20)
  • Let him go alone. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Sneak up behind them. (No effect)
  • Distract them. (No effect)

+Thief if you're wearing the premium outfit.

Diamond Choice 6 (Robert's Sword)

  • Threaten him. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7

  • Careful! It's still sharp. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8

  • Fate brought me here. (No effect)
  • I chose this life. (No effect)

Choice 16

  • Losing focus. (No effect)
  • Not as eager to get home as I thought. (No effect)

"Better Together" if you helped Axton save Ada.
"Dynamic Uno" if you let Axton go alone.

Chapter Seven: Stranger Tides Choices

Choice 1

This is a timed choice.

  • Turn left! (-Pirate)
  • Turn right! (+Pirate) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you turn left. (-Pirate)

Choice 2

  • Catch! (No effect)

Choice 3

  • I'd kill for some coffee. (No effect)
  • I'm going to look for some clothes. (No effect)
  • I'll just be happy to be on dry land again. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Fierceness. (Path A)
  • Legacy. (No effect)
  • Generosity. (No effect)

Choice 5 (Path A)

  • Brandish! (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Spend the day with Edward. (💎 17)
  • Spend the day with Charlie. (💎 17)
  • Buy supplies with Henry. (Tough Market*)

You get to choose as many as you have diamonds for.

*Only if you don't spend the day with Charlie or Edward.

Diamond Choice 1 (Edward)

  • What makes him so evil? (No effect)
  • Why do you have to stop him? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Edward)

  • And it will be enough. (No effect)
  • ...For now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Edward)

  • That sounds like an excellent idea. (No effect)
  • That's not good enough. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Edward)

  • That's not funny. (No effect)
  • You should stick to your strengths. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Edward)

  • ♡ Don't stop now. (No effect)
  • You're right. (Skip Diamond Choice 6)

Diamond Choice 6 (Edward)

  • That's bullshit. (No effect)
  • I understand. (No effect)

"Captain's Orders"

Diamond Choice 7 (Charlie)

  • But I still wish you had a happier life. (No effect)
  • If I see a charming lad/lass, I'll let you know. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Charlie)

  • The crew? (No effect)
  • Your family? (No effect)
  • Love? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Charlie)

  • Pretty flower (No effect)
  • Mystery liquid (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10 (Charlie)

  • To keep me warm? (Path A)
  • To take me home? (Path B)
  • To make someone fall in love? (Path C)

Diamond Choice 11 (Charlie) (Path A & C)

  • Not exactly what you had in mind...

Diamond Choice 11 (Charlie) (Path B)

  • Works in a pinch. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12 (Charlie)

  • ♡ Kiss her. (No effect)
  • Pull away. (No effect)

You skip this choice if you don't have enough romance points with her.

Diamond Choice 13 (Charlie)

  • Jump back! (No effect)

"Close Quartermasters"

Choice 7

  • Yo Ho Ho (💎 25) (Yo Ho Ho)
  • No thanks (No effect)

Choice 8

This is a timed choice.

  • Bounce! (-Pirate)
  • Balance! (+Pirate) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you bounce. (-Pirate)

Choice 9

This is a timed choice.

  • Jump over the stall! (+Pirate) ⬅ Correct
  • Slide under the stall! (-Pirate)

If the timer ends, you hesitate. (-Pirate)

Choice 10

This is a timed choice.

  • This guy? (-Pirate)
  • There! (+Pirate) ⬅ Correct
  • This girl? (-Pirate)

If the timer ends, you hesitate. (-Pirate)

Choice 11

  • Rescued! (No effect)

"To Catch A Thief" if you got 2 or more +Pirate, or bought the premium outfit.
"The One That Got Away" if you got 1 or less +Pirate.

Choice 12

  • It was more than a bit of help. (No effect)
  • ♡ I'd help you any day of the week. (No effect)

Choice 13

  • You both need to calm down. (No effect)
  • You're making a scene, stranger. (No effect)
  • ♡ Is there anything I can do for you? (No effect)

Choice 14

  • What good is a pirate without a crew? (No effect)
  • And your plan is to just ask to join one? (No effect)

Choice 15

  • Go to the tavern with Oliver. (💎 18)
  • Head back to the ship. (Take Your Leave)

Diamond Choice 14

  • Rum. (No effect)
  • A pint of beer. (No effect)
  • Just water. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15

  • You're no more than a mysterious stranger. (No effect)
  • 'Friend' sounds about right. (No effect)
  • ♡ You'll be more than a friend by the end of the night. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 16

  • To getting to know each other. (No effect)
  • To getting answers. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 17

  • Tiburon. (No effect)
  • London. (No effect)
  • Somewhere you've never heard of. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 18

  • Tell him the truth. (No effect)
  • Make up a ship name. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 19

  • Why are you so interested in me? (No effect)
  • ♡ Will you kiss me? (No effect)

"Pint for Your Thoughts"

Diamond Choice 20

  • ♡ Grab Oliver's hand. (No effect)
  • Lead the way. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 21

  • ♡ Lean in for a kiss. (No effect)
  • Push him away. (No effect)

Chapter Eight: Enemy Mine Choices

Choice 1 (if you didn't get drinks with Oliver)

  • I knew it! (No effect)
  • I did not see that coming.

Diamond Choice 1 (if you got drinks with Oliver)

  • I don't understand. (No effect)
  • How could you? (No effect)
  • ♡ It doesn't matter. You owe me a kiss. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (if you got drinks with Oliver)

  • Duty calls. (No effect)
  • ♡ Then stay with me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Adelia and Axton)

  • Shout at them. (No effect)
  • Steal the show. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • I ran into him at the market. (No effect)
  • Does that really matter right now? (No effect)
  • I kissed him, that's how! (No effect)

The third option only appears if you've kissed Oliver.

Choice 3

  • We had a clearer plan. (No effect)
  • You and I had a moment to talk. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Sail ho! (No effect)

Choice 5

  • Look through. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (if you kissed Oliver and told Edward)

  • How can you even say that? (No effect)
  • I promise. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Stormy seas ahead. (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Our only option. (No effect)
  • Way too dangerous. (No effect)
  • Part of the adventure. (No effect)

Choice 8

This is a timed choice.

  • Hold steady! (+Storm) ⬅ Correct
  • Stumble! (-Storm)

If the timer ends, you stumble. (-Storm)

Choice 9

This is a timed choice.

  • Stumble! (-Storm)
  • Dodge! (-Storm)
  • Stand firm! (+Storm) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you try to jump out of the way. (-Storm)

Choice 10

This is a timed choice.

  • Hold fast! (+Storm) ⬅ Correct
  • Duck and cover! (-Storm)
  • Freeze up! (-Storm)

If the timer ends, you're taken by surprise. (-Storm)

"Port In Storm" if you got 2 or more +Storm.
"Stormy Weather" if you got 1 or less +Storm.

Choice 11

  • Save Ginny! (💎 20)
  • Focus on evading the navy. (Taken By Storm)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Grab it! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • Swim up! (+Rescue)
  • Swim down. (+Rescue)

Diamond Choice 7

  • Punch him in the nose like a shark! (+Rescue)
  • Scare him away like a barracuda! (+Rescue)

Diamond Choice 8

  • I got you! (+Rescue)
  • Hold on tight, for real this time. (+Rescue)

"Right as Rain"

Diamond Choice 9 (Edward)

  • It's fine. (No effect)
  • ♡ I like when you shout my name... (No effect)

Choice 12

  • We finally lost the navy. (No effect)
  • We're on dry land right now. (No effect)

Choice 13

  • Help gather food. (No effect)
  • Help gather firewood. (No effect)
  • Help gather flint. (No effect)

You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order. The third option only appears if Jonas and/or Ginny is with the crew.

Choice 14

  • Explore the island with Edward. (💎 18)
  • Explore the island with Charlie. (💎 18)
  • Stay by the fire. (Playing With Fire if you didn't go with at least one of them)

You get to choose as many as you have diamonds for.

Diamond Choice 10 (Edward)

  • They'll be fine. (No effect)
  • You deserve a break. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11 (Edward)

  • It'll cheer you up. (No effect)
  • It's an adventure! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12 (Edward)

  • Trip him. (No effect)
  • Distract him. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 13 (Edward)

  • ♡ Draw nearer. (No effect)
  • Swim to the surface. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 14 (Edward)

  • Hold up my hand. (No effect)
  • Touch the dolphin's nose. (No effect)

"Cove Story"

Diamond Choice 15 (Edward) (if you haven't told him you're from the future)

  • There's something I need to confess to you... (No effect)
  • It doesn't have to be like this. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 16 (Charlie)

  • You go first. (No effect)
  • I'm going first. (No effect)
  • We're jumping together. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 17 (Charlie) (if you haven't told her you're from the future)

  • I'm from the future. (No effect)
  • I could imagine staying with the crew.

Diamond Choice 18 (Charlie)

  • ♡ Kiss Charlie. (No effect)
  • Tell her we should head back. (No effect)

"Chasing Waterfalls"

Choice 15 (if you haven't told Edward you're from the future)

  • I'm from the future. (No effect)
  • I don't know what's going on. (No effect)

Chapter Nine: Battle Lines Choices

Choice 1

  • That explains why it's so heavy. (No effect)

Choice 2

  • Did you always want to be a pirate? (No effect)
  • Where are you from? (No effect)

Choice 3

  • Isn't that just legal piracy? (No effect)
  • You must've been adorable. (No effect)

Choice 4

  • Ask Edward about his history with the Admiral. (💎 20)
  • Change the subject. (Piracy Privacy)

Diamond Choice 1

  • I know he hurt you. (No effect)
  • If you don't... I'll have to assume the worst. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

  • Demand answers. (No effect)
  • Wait him out. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

  • You made your own family. (No effect)
  • You found your calling. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

  • But you were so young! (No effect)
  • Just 'Francis'? He wasn't an admiral yet? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

  • Lead the way so he can focus on the story. (No effect)
  • ♡ Take his hand. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6

  • You couldn't have known the Admiral was lying. (Ye Have His Trust)
  • How could you have done something so evil? (Between you and me)

Choice 5

  • In plain sight, near the entrance. (No effect)
  • As far away as possible, in the back. (No effect)
  • Separately from the treasure chest. (No effect)

Choice 6

  • Dig! (No effect)

Choice 7

  • Hide it away. (No effect)

Choice 8

  • I knew how to get home already. (No effect)
  • I could share the awesome parts of the future with everyone here. (No effect)

Choice 9

  • Being able to keep in touch with people with the push of a button. (No effect)
  • Online shopping and delivery. (No effect)
  • Indoor plumbing. (No effect)

Choice 10 (if you haven't showed your phone to Edward before)

  • Show Edward.

Choice 11

  • It's been an adjustment. (No effect)
  • It's not so bad. (No effect)

Choice 12

  • You don't mean to kill him, do you? (No effect)
  • He deserves worse. (No effect)

Choice 13

  • Offer my arm as a perch. (No effect)
  • Squawk back. (No effect)

Choice 14

  • Adopt the parrot! (💎 25)
  • Leave her behind (Fly the Coop)

Diamond Choice 7

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • What do you name your parrot?

Default is "Polly".

Diamond Choice 8

  • Some leaves and seeds. (No effect)
  • Crackers, of course. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9

  • How to fly a loop-the-loop. (No effect)
  • How to nosedive. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.

  • Enter her catchphrase:

Default is "Surrender your booty".

"Birds of a Feather"

Choice 15

  • I was ever afraid to be up here. (No effect)
  • I'm sailing a freakin' pirate ship. (No effect)

Choice 16

  • Untie! (No effect)

Choice 17

  • Get a closer look. (No effect)

Choice 18

  • Learn how to shoot the pistol. (💎 15)
  • Reject it. (Jump the Gun)

Diamond Choice 11

  • Let's do this. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12

  • Shoot! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 13

  • Hit the target. (No effect)
  • ♡ Miss on purpose, so she shows me again. (Skip Diamond Choice 14)

Diamond Choice 14

  • Shoot! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15

This is a timed choice.

  • Shoot! (+Pistol)
  • Shoot! (+Pistol)
  • Shoot! (+Pistol)

If the timer ends, you miss (-Pistol) and repeat this choice.
If the timer ends again, you miss (-Pistol) and repeat without a timer. (Skip Diamond Choices 16 and 17)

Diamond Choice 16

This is a timed choice.*

  • Shoot! (+Pistol)
  • Shoot! (+Pistol)

If the timer ends, you miss (-Pistol) and repeat the choice without a timer. (Skip Diamond Choice 17)

*If you let the timer run out once on Diamond Choice 15 there is no timer and you skip Diamond Choice 17.

Diamond Choice 17

  • Shoot! (+Pistol)

Diamond Choice 18

  • A bottle of rum. (No effect)
  • ♡ A kiss. (No effect)

"Secret Weapon"

Choice 19

  • That's Oliver's ship, alright. (No effect)

Choice 20

  • Are we ready for this? (No effect)
  • Are you ready for this? (No effect)

Choice 21 (Boatswain)

This is a timed choice.

  • Steer clockwise. (+Boatswain)
  • Steer counter clockwise. (-Boatswain)

If the timer ends, ?

Choice 21 (Gunner)

  • Fire! (No effect)

Choice 21 (Sailor)

This is a timed choice.

  • Drop the sail and grab a rope! (+Sailor)
  • Hang onto the sail!

If the timer ends, ?

Choice 22

  • You're not giving us enough credit. (No effect)
  • It was too easy. (No effect)

Choice 23

  • Shout for Henry! (No effect)
  • Start looking for him. (No effect)

+Fight if you have 'Polly'.

Choice 24

This is a timed choice.

  • Strike first! (+Fight, go to Diamond Choice 19) ⬅ Correct
  • Parry! (+Fight) ⬅ Correct
  • Duck! (-Fight)

If the timer ends, you duck. (-Fight)

The first option is only available if you have Robert's sword.

Diamond Choice 19 (Robert's Sword)

  • Attack!

Choice 25

  • This feels familiar. (No effect)

Choice 26

This is a timed choice.

  • Shoot at him! (Go to Diamond Choice 20) ⬅ Correct
  • Rush him! (-Fight)
  • Hide! (+Fight) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you freeze in fear. (-Fight)

You only get the first option if you have Charlie's pistol.

Diamond Choice 20 (Charlie's Pistol)

  • Fire! (+Fight)

Choice 27

This is a timed choice.

  • Struggle against him! (-Fight)
  • Spit in his face! (+Fight) ⬅ Correct

If the timer ends, you struggle against him. (-Fight)

Choice 28

  • They're escaping! (No effect)

Chapter Ten: Choices

Walkthroughs
The Freshman The Freshman, Book 1 Choices · The Freshman, Book 2 Choices · The Freshman, Book 3 Choices · The Freshman, Book 4 Choices · The Freshman: Love Bites Choices · The Freshman: Game of Love Choices · The Freshman: Snowed In Choices · Chris: Luxury Getaway Choices · James: Masquerade Ball Choices · Kaitlyn: The Perfect Date Choices
The Crown & The Flame The Crown & The Flame, Book 1 Choices · The Crown & The Flame, Book 2 Choices · The Crown & The Flame, Book 3 Choices
Most Wanted Most Wanted, Book 1 Choices · Most Wanted, Book 2 Choices
Rules of Engagement Rules of Engagement, Book 1 Choices · Rules of Engagement, Book 2 Choices · Rules of Engagement, Book 3 Choices · Rules of Engagement: Newlyweds Choices
Endless Summer Endless Summer, Book 1 Choices · Endless Summer, Book 2 Choices · Endless Summer, Book 3 Choices
#LoveHacks #LoveHacks, Book 1 Choices · #LoveHacks, Book 2 Choices
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor The Haunting of Braidwood Manor Choices
The Royal Romance The Royal Romance, Book 1 Choices · The Royal Romance, Book 2 Choices · The Royal Romance, Book 3 Choices · The Royal Holiday Choices
The Sophomore The Sophomore, Book 1 Choices · The Sophomore, Book 2 Choices · The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story Choices
Hero Hero, Vol. 1 Choices · Hero Vol. 2 Choices
High School Story High School Story, Book 1 Choices · High School Story, Book 2 Choices · High School Story, Book 3 Choices · High School Story: Class Act, Book 1 Choices · High School Story: Class Act, Book 2 Choices · High School Story: Class Act, Book 3 Choices
It Lives It Lives In The Woods Choices · It Lives Beneath Choices
Home for the Holidays Home for the Holidays Choices
Red Carpet Diaries Red Carpet Diaries, Book 1 Choices · Red Carpet Diaries, Book 2 Choices · Red Carpet Diaries, Book 3 Choices
Perfect Match Perfect Match, Book 1 Choices · Perfect Match, Book 2 Choices
Bloodbound Bloodbound, Book 1 Choices · Bloodbound, Book 2 Choices · Bloodbound, Book 3 Choices · Bloodbound: Dark Solstice Choices
The Junior The Junior, Book 1 Choices
Veil of Secrets Veil of Secrets Choices
America's Most Eligible America's Most Eligible: Season 10 Choices · America's Most Eligible: All Stars Choices · America's Most Eligible: Wedding Edition Choices
Desire & Decorum Desire & Decorum, Book 1 Choices · Desire & Decorum, Book 2 Choices · Desire & Decorum, Book 3 Choices · Desire & Decorum: First Winter Choices
Across the Void Across the Void Choices
The Senior The Senior Choices
Big Sky Country Big Sky Country, Book 1 Choices · Big Sky Country, Book 2 Choices
The Elementalists The Elementalists, Book 1 Choices · The Elementalists, Book 2 Choices · The Elementalists: Winters Past Choices
A Courtesan of Rome A Courtesan of Rome Choices
The Heist: Monaco The Heist: Monaco Choices
Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 1 Choices · Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 2 Choices
Open Heart Open Heart, Book 1 Choices · Open Heart: Second Year Choices
Passport to Romance Passport to Romance Choices
Wishful Thinking Wishful Thinking Choices
Nightbound Nightbound Choices
Platinum Platinum Choices
The Royal Heir The Royal Heir, Book 1 Choices · The Royal Heir, Book 2 Choices
Sunkissed Sunkissed Choices
Bachelorette Party Bachelorette Party Choices
Mother of the Year Mother of the Year Choices
Save the Date Save the Date Choices
The Royal Masquerade The Royal Masquerade Choices
Baby Bump Baby Bump, Book 1 Choices · Baby Bump, Book 2 Choices
Blades of Light and Shadow Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 1 Choices
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Choices
Distant Shores Distant Shores Choices
The Nanny Affair The Nanny Affair Choices
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.