Choices: Stories You Play Wiki
Choices: Stories You Play Wiki

America's Most Eligible: All Stars is the second book of the America's Most Eligible series. It is alternatively known as either America's Most Eligible, Book 2 or America's Most Eligible, Season 11. It succeeds its first book, America's Most Eligible: Season 10, and is followed by America's Most Eligible: Wedding Edition.


New season, new showrunner... And plenty of chances for drama! Find fame and win hearts in the next season of America's Most Eligible. Head back to Miami for America's Most Eligible: All Stars! Will you return be triumphant, or will old enemies drag you down?


Chapter 1: Baby, You're a Star

You're back in Miami for America's Most Eligible: All-Stars! Will your return be triumphant, or will old enemies drag you down?

Chapter 2: Guess Who's Back

Season 11 starts off with a twist when you meet the competition! Can you keep your cool as old contestants and new collide?

Chapter 3: Back in the Saddle

When you head for the first double Date of the season, will drama knock you into the dust?

Chapter 4: Sand, Sun, and Strife

A day at the beach promises to be all fun and games... But when tempers flare, your team spirit is put to the test.

Chapter 5: Under The Sea

When you embark on an underseas adventure, will you fight against the current or go with the flow?

Chapter 6: A Shot in the Dark

Carson's latest twist might get you closer to the Grand Prize, but the next Challenge will put all your reflexes to the test...

Chapter 7: Save the Last Dance

On this week's Date, you'll be attending a prom for charity! But will your worries keep you from dancing the night away?

Chapter 8: Enemy of My Enemy

One of your rivals has an unexpected proposal... but are they trying to help your game, or throw you off track?

Chapter 9: The Art of the Deal

With unexpected offers on the table, this week's Elimination Ceremony has higher stakes than ever. Who will come out on top?

Chapter 10: Up In Smoke

With tensions rising between Carson and the producers, can you find a way to steer clear of the crossfire?

Chapter 11: The Real World

During a sudden break in filming, you and your friends look for adventure to push your worries aside.

Chapter 12: Playing with Fire

As AME takes on an icy new locale, tensions on-set threaten to boil over. Can you withstand the heat?

Chapter 13: On Thin Ice

Someone on set has a shocking secret! Will behind-the-scenes drama upstage your romantic Date?

Chapter 14: Behind Closed Doors

The mansion's jam-packed with secrets. Whose will work to your advantage, and which will come back to bite?

Chapter 15: Moment of Truth

In the live finale of AME All-Stars, you have one last chance to prove yourself. Are you ready to be put to the test?

Chapter 16: That's a Wrap!

It's the second half of the live finale! How will you react to Season 11's most shocking twist yet?

Gameplay Features

Friendship Indicator

The book follows the same relationship system as the Endless Summer series. Certain choices can make the contestants like, dislike, or stay neutral about you and can affect the story in the future. Over time, their behavior toward you will change.

Your relationships with other characters are improved or damaged, contestants in America's Most Eligible have a friendship emoji right next to their name whenever they speak. The color and face on the emoji indicates the nature of that character's relationship to Your Character. The emoji range from an angry blue face for enemies to a laughing reddish face for best friends and a cherry-red heart for lovers. Build alliances, make enemies, and even find romance.

Characters with friendship indicators are Your Character's opponents such as Handsome Stranger, Beautiful Contestant, Derek, Bianca, Slater, Eden, Heath, Vince, Ivy, Ronan, Yvette, and Kiana.

Here are the different statuses that the emojis can indicate, all of which represent how they feel about you, from lowest to highest:

  • Enemy
  • Hate
  • Neutral
  • Like
  • Close
  • Ally
  • In Love


  • Duos: In Chapter 3, it is revealed that the contestants for this season will compete in pairs until further notice.
  • Elimination Freeze: Derek was given the power to cancel an elimination ceremony, he uses this power in Chapter 7 to save Ivy, Vince, Handsome Stranger and Beautiful Contestant.
  • One Final Partner Swap: With the power of the audience vote, you can save Derek or Beautiful Contestant from the bottom 4, but at the cost of Handsome Stranger replacing them.

Game History

Week Number Bottom Two/Four Description Challenge Winner Challenge Boost Status
Week 1
Heath vs Eden.png
Heath and Eden
Week 1 had a challenge where each contestant is randomly assigned a partner for a dance challenge, Eden and Heath display the worst connection and are placed in the bottom 2. Vince and You The winners of the challenge get to invite 2 contestants on a double date, Vince decides to invite Handsome Stranger and Beautiful Contestant.

As winner of the season's first audience vote, your character is given a sole vote, you must choose who between Eden and Heath will be the first person sent to the jury house.

Week 2
Week 2 Bianca vs Yvette and Ronan vs Kiana.jpg
Kiana, Ronan, Yvette and Bianca
The challenge consists of building the best sandcastle, as well as showing your team spirit with your partner. You can play nice with Vince and win or leave him alone and hand the victory to Ivy and Derek. Vince and You/Ivy and Derek For the next date, all safe contestants are sent on a snorkeling date. (You, Vince, Ivy, Derek, Handsome Stranger, Beautiful Contestant, Eden/Heath and Slater)

After the date, you are sent to place your vote (if you win, Slater will ask who you recommend to eliminate). Depending on your choice, Bianca or Yvette are sent to the jury house.

Regardless of choice Ronan is also sent to the jury house.

Week 3 Handsome Stranger, Ivy, Beautiful Contestant, Vince The team who play the best game of Laser Tag, scoring the most points wins. Slater and You/Derek and Kiana Every single contestant is invited to the AME prom!

Derek reveals to you that he won audience vote, giving him a power that causes a none elimination.

No one is sent home.

Week 4


Your Character, Slater, Eden, Yvette

Your Character, Slater, Heath, Yvette

Your Character, Slater, Eden, Bianca

Your Character, Slater, Heath, Bianca

Handsome Stranger, Ivy, Eden, Yvette

Handsome Stranger, Ivy, Heath, Yvette

Handsome Stranger, Ivy, Eden, Bianca

Handsome Stranger, Ivy, Heath, Bianca

Ivy comes to you with a plan, throw the bike challenge so she can use her audience power to eliminate Slater, depending on your choices, the bottom 4 has 8 different possibilities. Derek and Kiana or You and Slater The winners get invited to a romantic dinner at a fancy restaurant.

With Ivy's audience power she is given the option to give two characters immunity if she is safe from elimination.

Depending on which bottom 4 you got, Ivy will choose to eliminate Slater and Yvette/Bianca or Yvette/Bianca and Ivy are voted out.

Week 5 Due to events of the chapter, there is no bottom 4. In a test of teamwork, the new teams must compete to complete a go-kart race simultaneously. In a shock twist, Eden/Heath's brakes fail to trigger, causing them to crash head on with Kiana. Both karts explode, luckily, both victims survived. You and Handsome Stranger With the help of the audience vote, you and a Love Interest of your choice (Handsome Stranger, Beautiful Contestant or Derek) are invited to private karting lesson with Crash Yamaguchi.

Due to the crash, both Kiana and Eden are forced to forfeit and spend the rest of the season in the jury house.

Due to received controversy, the show is put on indefinite hiatus and eventually moved to Iceland.

Week 6


Handsome Stranger, Beautiful Contestant, Vince and Slater/Ivy

Handsome Stranger, Derek, Vince and Slater/Ivy

Derek, Beautiful Contestant, Vince and Slater/Ivy

You and your partner must make a dish to please the jury, you can choose to spend between 10-30 diamonds to sabotage Vince, but regardless, Beautiful Contestant, Derek, Slater/Ivy and Vince fall into the bottom 4.

During the date you learn you won audience vote yet again, this gives you the option to swap your partner and secure your love interest.

This also means Handsome Stranger is placed into the bottom 4 if you choose to swap.

You and Handsome Stranger You, your partner and two others (automatically selected as Beautiful Contestant and Derek) get to visit the ice caves of Iceland.

Carson reveals that everyone from the Jury and the top six will be voting out a pair to eliminate.

Depending on which bottom 4 you got, you can choose to eliminate Slater/Ivy and Vince or Handsome Stranger and Derek or Handsome Stranger and Beautiful Contestant or Derek and Beautiful Contestant.

Regardless of choice Vince and Slater/Ivy is sent to the jury house.

Finale As this is finale, there is no bottom 4.

You and your partner face a quiz, that will determine how well you know them, this will also allow you to bring your persona to the ultimate head. Slater, Ivy and Vince ask you a question each and you can choose your persona. 

You and You Partner None

You receive one final chance to appeal to the jury, which is the only way to get the person you eliminated in week 1 as an Ally.

Depending on your total number of allies, you or your partner will be crowned the All Star and both of you take home checks for $500,000.


Sneak Peeks

Pre-Book Sneak Peeks & Information


Promotional Videos


Visit the soundtrack page for more soundtracks from Choices


  • On November 7, 2018, in response to a player, PB confirmed that this book, along with Desire & Decorum, Book 2, was in the works. [1]
  • On November 8, 2018, Pixelberry urged players to send them their picks through their official Instagram, Twitter, Tumblr, and Facebook accounts for who should return to play in the All-Stars Season and even hinted at us possibly being able to pick who we get to "love" in this season. [2] [3]
    • They also revealed on November 9, 2018 that the poll was going to close on Tuesday, November 13, 2018. [4]
  • On November 26, 2018, PB continued to say that this is one of the books that they are currently working on. [5]
  • On November 30, 2018, PB confirmed that the book would premiere sometime in Winter 2019. [6]
  • On December 6, 2018, the book was promoted in PB's at the time latest blogpost. [7]
  • On December 28, 2018, PB released the first sneak peek for the All-Stars season. [8]
    • In addition, they also confirmed that Bianca was one of the contestants that will return.[9] [10]
  • On January 1, 2019, PB confirmed that Book 2 would come out on Wednesday, January 16, 2019.
    • They also unveiled the book cover on the same day, which revealed that also back for the All Stars season are: Handsome Stranger and Beautiful Contestant who appear on the cover with a version of Your Character and Jen Espinoza.[11]
    • In addition, it is the first Choices book to be referred to by different names, seen as how on the Book cover, it's labeled Book 2, but on the app, it's AME 2 and it has also been referred to as AME: All Stars at the end of Book 1 and by the writers as well.
  • On January 3, 2019, PB released a second sneak peek where they confirmed that the player will once again get to pick if they want to play as a villain, a sweetheart, or a flirt in Book 2.
    • In addition, they also confirmed that Derek would also be one of the contestants from Season 10 that is participating in the All Stars season. [12]
  • On January 8, 2019, a summary for the Book was released on the Choices App as part of the then-new update alongside Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 1.
  • On January 9, 2019, a third sneak peek was released, this time featuring a new character named Eden who competed in Season 7 of America's Most Eligible and previously held the title of the Heiress. [13]
    • The description for Chapter One was released on the same day.
  • As of January 12, 2019, the book appears on the Choices App.
  • On January 15, 2019, a sneak peek for Chapter 1 was released. [14]
  • On the same day, a blog post featuring an interview with the writers for this book was released ahead of the Wednesday premiere. [15]
    • The writers for this book are: Cat, Kelsie, Bre'Anna, Olivia and Elizabeth
    • New Characters were to be introduced... including the devious antagonists you'll be competing against!
      • Since this is the All-Star season, you'll be meeting people from very different seasons and different walks of life. This includes one of the veteran contestants being labeled as a ... truly unique experience according to Olivia, one of the writers for this book.
      • Some of the new Characters teased in the blogpost are: Kiana who is described by Cat as, cute, fun, and super down-to-earth! Then there's Ronan, who Kelsie says that the Most Interesting Man in the World has nothing on him. Lastly there's Eden who Bre'Anna describes as the cool, older sister type who'll make your parents proud, but still let you borrow stuff from her closet.
    • The stakes were also raised and the players can expect bigger rewards.
      • The writers tried to keep everything players loved from Book 1 but improved on things that didn't work for the All Stars season.
    • In addition to the villain, the flirt and the sweetheart persona introduced for the confessionals in Book 1, a brand-new Confessional persona was to debut in this book.
      • Players will also have the opportunity to play into your Confessional persona more often, both on and off-camera.
    • There was to be some new art that will take our breath away.
    • Book 2 also dived into who the characters are when they're affected by factors outside of the show.
      • For example, players can expect to see uber-tough Mack get in touch with her sensitive side, buttoned-up Adam lose his cool, and you'll even get some backstory on a certain producer extraordinaire.
  • On Wednesday, January 16, 2019, it was hinted at Bianca being officially a love interest for some players when she reached the "in love" status. [16]
  • On Thursday, January 17, 2019, Bianca used her Twitter account to discuss how some players voted her off, and others kept her around for as long as they could.[17]
  • On January 22, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for the second chapter where they revealed Yvette, another contestant that is participating on this All Stars season. [18]
  • On February 4, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for the fourth chapter of this book.[19]
  • On February 19, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for Chapter 6. [20]
  • On March 11, 2019, sneak peek for Chapter 9 was released.[21]
  • On April 1, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for Chapter 12.[22]
  • On April 15, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for Chapter 14.[23]
  • On April 22, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for Chapter 15.[24]
  • On April 29, 2019, PB released a sneak peek for Chapter 16 and confirmed it would be this book's finale.[25]
  • On September 4, 2019, PB released the official soundtrack for this series.[26]
  • On September 13, 2019 PB shared a behind-the-scene playlist of America's Most Eligible.[27]


  • A sequel was confirmed at the end of the 20th chapter of America's Most Eligible Season 10.
  • Through a premium scene in Chapter 2, it is revealed that you went on a trip with your LI to Paris, France, if you won Season 10 or to New York City, New York, USA, if Ivy won Season 10.
  • In contrast to the bottom two of Season 10, All-Stars had a bottom four, meaning that two contestants will be sent to the Jury House each week instead of one.
  • In Chapter 7, if you choose to dance with Slater and ask him to do a lift, Your Character will make a reference to Dirty Dancing.
  • Chapter 8 shares the same title as Distant Shores, Chapter 12, "Enemy of My Enemy". 
  • As of Chapter 9 in All-Stars, Your Character is able to reach in love status with Slater.
  • In Chapter 9, if you and Handsome Stranger pose as spies, he will make a reference to fictional spy James Bond by saying "I'm Eligible. Most Eligible".
  • Chapter 14 shares the same title as The Haunting of Braidwood Manor, Chapter 4, "Behind Closed Doors".
  • Chapter 15 shares the same title as Rules of Engagement, Book 2, Chapter 18: "Moment of Truth".
  • Chapter 16 shares the same title as Red Carpet Diaries, Book 2, Chapter 15: That's a Wrap!

Click here for the walkthrough of this book: America's Most Eligible: All Stars Choices.


The Freshman The Freshman, Book 1 · The Freshman, Book 2 · The Freshman, Book 3 · The Freshman, Book 4 · The Freshman: Love Bites · The Freshman: Game of Love · The Freshman: Snowed In · Chris: Luxury Getaway · James: Masquerade Ball · Kaitlyn: The Perfect Date
The Crown & The Flame The Crown & The Flame, Book 1 · The Crown & The Flame, Book 2 · The Crown & The Flame, Book 3
Most Wanted Most Wanted, Book 1 · Most Wanted, Book 2
Rules of Engagement Rules of Engagement, Book 1 · Rules of Engagement, Book 2 · Rules of Engagement, Book 3 · Rules of Engagement: Newlyweds
Endless Summer Endless Summer, Book 1 · Endless Summer, Book 2 · Endless Summer, Book 3
#LoveHacks #LoveHacks, Book 1 · #LoveHacks, Book 2
The Haunting of Braidwood Manor The Haunting of Braidwood Manor
The Royal Romance The Royal Romance, Book 1 · The Royal Romance, Book 2 · The Royal Romance, Book 3 · The Royal Holiday
The Sophomore The Sophomore, Book 1 · The Sophomore, Book 2 · The Sophomore: Hartfeld Horror Story
Hero Hero, Vol. 1 · Hero, Vol. 2
High School Story High School Story, Book 1 · High School Story, Book 2 · High School Story, Book 3 · High School Story: Class Act, Book 1 · High School Story: Class Act, Book 2 · High School Story: Class Act, Book 3
It Lives It Lives In The Woods . It Lives Beneath
Home for the Holidays Home for the Holidays
Red Carpet Diaries Red Carpet Diaries, Book 1 · Red Carpet Diaries, Book 2 . Red Carpet Diaries, Book 3
Perfect Match Perfect Match, Book 1 · Perfect Match, Book 2
Bloodbound Bloodbound, Book 1 · Bloodbound, Book 2 · Bloodbound, Book 3 · Bloodbound: Dark Solstice
The Junior The Junior, Book 1
Veil of Secrets Veil of Secrets
America's Most Eligible America's Most Eligible: Season 10 · America's Most Eligible: All Stars · America's Most Eligible: Wedding Edition
Desire & Decorum Desire & Decorum, Book 1 · Desire & Decorum, Book 2 · Desire & Decorum, Book 3 · Desire & Decorum: First Winter
Across the Void Across the Void
The Senior The Senior
Big Sky Country Big Sky Country, Book 1 · Big Sky Country, Book 2
The Elementalists The Elementalists, Book 1 · The Elementalists, Book 2 · The Elementalists: Winters Past
A Courtesan of Rome A Courtesan of Rome
The Heist: Monaco The Heist: Monaco
Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 1 · Ride or Die: A Bad Boy Romance, Book 2
Open Heart Open Heart, Book 1 · Open Heart: Second Year · Open Heart: Third Year
Passport to Romance Passport to Romance
Wishful Thinking Wishful Thinking
Nightbound Nightbound
Platinum Platinum
Sunkissed Sunkissed
The Royal Heir The Royal Heir, Book 1 · The Royal Heir, Book 2 · The Royal Heir, Book 3 · The Royal Finale
Bachelorette Party Bachelorette Party
Mother of the Year Mother of the Year
Save the Date Save the Date
The Royal Masquerade The Royal Masquerade
Baby Bump Baby Bump, Book 1 · Baby Bump, Book 2
Blades of Light and Shadow Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 1 · Blades of Light and Shadow, Book 2
Witness: A Bodyguard Romance Witness: A Bodyguard Romance
Distant Shores Distant Shores
The Nanny Affair The Nanny Affair, Book 1 · The Nanny Affair, Book 2
Queen B Queen B, Book 1 · Queen B, Book 2
My Two First Loves My Two First Loves
Rising Tides Rising Tides
Hot Couture Hot Couture
Foreign Affairs Foreign Affairs
With Every Heartbeat With Every Heartbeat
Laws of Attraction Laws of Attraction, Book 1 · Laws of Attraction, Book 2
A Very Scandalous Proposal A Very Scandalous Proposal
The Unexpected Heiress The Unexpected Heiress
Wake the Dead Wake the Dead
Surrender Surrender
Crimes of Passion Crimes of Passion