The Unexpected Heiress Choices



This page contains the choices in The Unexpected Heiress and their outcomes.

''This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!''

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices
Choice 1
 * We could leave earlier. (No effect)
 * We could travel for longer than planned. (No effect)

Now playing as Amelia's younger sister.

Choice 2
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 3
 * Regal Waves (💎 15)
 * Shimmering Debutante (💎 15)
 * Modern Bob
 * Fiery Tresses
 * White Blonde
 * Curly Bun

Choice 4
 * Lasting Impression (💎 20)
 * Day Attire

Choice 5
 * Perfect! Let's away!
 * Not quite right. Let's try this again. (Go Back to Choice 2)

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Lillian".
 * What is your name?

Chapter One: Windcroft Manor Choices
Choice 1
 * Would do anything for our family. (No effect)
 * Despise being traded away like cattle at a market. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Hopeful. (No effect)
 * Pragmatic. (No effect)
 * Angry. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 4
 * Shake his hand. (No effect)
 * Curtsy politely.
 * Kiss him on both cheeks. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * ❤ He appears very intriguing, indeed... (John ❤ +Romance)
 * That remains to be seen. I'm not easily impressed... (No effect)

Choice 6
 * I'm not my sister. (No effect)
 * We aren't only American. (No effect)
 * ❤ I would've sent a photograph of both of you right away... (John ❤ +Romance)

"" if you're wearing "Lasting Impression".

Choice 7
 * Beautiful. (No effect)
 * Perhaps a little excessive... (No effect)

Choice 8
 * I understand. I'm also grieving for her... (No effect)
 * Can't you at least try?! (No effect)

Choice 9
 * When were you taken in by the family? (No effect)
 * ❤ I much prefer you as my guide. (John ❤ +Romance)

Choice 10
 * TUHIconEtiquette.png Get the full tour with John! (💎 12)
 * Wrap up the tour quickly. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Looks... Classical? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Where is it from? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * A little homesick, to be honest... (No effect)
 * Enjoying the change of scenery. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * ❤ Provide some diversions for me... (John ❤ +Romance)
 * Show me the ropes around here. (No effect)

"", +Etiquette x2

Diamond Choice 5
 * Find love. (No effect)
 * Adjust to my new home. (No effect)
 * Learn more about my sister. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * I see a silver lining. (No effect)
 * I'm determined to make something of my life here. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Disliked my sister. (No effect)
 * Think I'm using your family. (No effect)
 * Have an aversion to attractive Americans? (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Here out of duty! Not some ulterior motive. (No effect)
 * Not going to hurt your family. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * I'll be on my best behavior. (No effect)
 * How long have you worked here? (No effect)
 * I'll act as I please. (No effect)

Choice 15
 * That's Amelia's wax seal... (, 🔎 +Clue)

Choice 16
 * Did anything seem odd that day? (No effect)
 * Were you there when it happened? (No effect)
 * Did anyone seem unsurprised? (No effect)

Chapter Two: Blood Relatives Choices
Choice 1
 * Lord Ashbourne. (No effect)
 * Lady Ashbourne. (No effect)
 * The Dowager Viscountess. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Who was the debutante? (No effect)
 * Who else stayed in the townhouse? (No effect)
 * What did she do in the afternoon? (No effect)

Choice 3
 * I'm worried that someone might have hurt her. (No effect)
 * I'm just very anxious to meet my future in-laws. (No effect)

""

Choice 4
 * Enchanted Evening (💎 25) (No effect)
 * Evening Attire (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Compliment John's appearance. (No effect)
 * Admonish John for his sarcasm. (No effect)

+Impress if you're wearing "Enchanted Evening".

Choice 6
 * You are family, too. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +Impress)
 * What's done is done. (No effect)
 * I'm very happy to be here on her behalf. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * I'm not like that! (No effect)
 * Sometimes divorce is for the best. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +Impress)

Choice 8
 * He often travels for work. (No effect)
 * He has young children to care for. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +Impress)

Choice 9
 * ❤ You're a sight for sore eyes. (Gemma ❤ +Romance)
 * It's lovely to make your acquaintance. (No effect)

Choice 10
 * I'm fairly certain I'm not. (No effect)
 * Forgive me... I'm also grieving. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * 🔎 Ask Effie to search Francis's room! (💎 16)
 * Call her off. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Books and drawers. (Path A)
 * Wardrobe. (Path B)

Diamond Choice 2 (Path A)
 * What's in here? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Path B)
 * Looks like an invoice from Harrod's... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Looks like it's from Mr. John... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Let's see what this is... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * Oh my, what's this? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * Heavens! What else is there? (No effect)
 * No more, I'll be punished! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Mr. Francis truly loved her. (🔎 +Clue)
 * Mr. Francis was a bit obsessed... (🔎 +Clue)

Diamond Choice 8
 * I was returning something. (No effect)
 * I was looking for you! (No effect)

Choice 12
 * How decadent! (No effect)

"", +Impress if you toured the gardens with John in Chapter 1.

"" if you didn't tour the gardens with John in Chapter 1.

Choice 13
 * Have a little fun. (No effect)
 * Stay informed. (No effect)

If you unlocked special etiquette, the correct answer will be marked with an icon.

Choice 14
 * TUHIconEtiquette.png Turn to the viscount at my left. (+Impress)
 * Continue chatting with Gemma. ( if you didn't tour the gardens with John in Chapter 1)

Choice 15
 * How did you, personally, get on with Amelia? (No effect)
 * Did you notice Amelia having any difficulties here? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Enchanted Evening)
 * I recognize this...

Diamond Choice 10 (Enchanted Evening)

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you stare. (No effect)''
 * Jump in the air! (No effect)
 * Jump at the branch! (No effect) ⬅ Correct

Diamond Choice 11 (Enchanted Evening)
 * Grab Amelia's hand! (No effect)
 * Do it myself! (No effect)

"" if you aren't wearing "Enchanted Evening".

"" if you got 3 or more +Impress.

"" if you got 2 or less +Impress.

Choice 16
 * ❤ You're a bit distracted, Mr. John... (John ❤ +Romance)
 * Some dessert could do us good. (No effect)

Choice 17
 * Drink with Lady Gemma in the hedge maze! (💎 17)
 * Join the rest of the ladies. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12
 * Go left. (No effect)
 * Go right. (No effect) ⬅ Correct

Diamond Choice 13
 * Certainly not the standard item for young women! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 14
 * I'll stick to more ladylike beverages. (No effect)
 * This is what I've been craving! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15
 * My sister? (No effect)
 * John? (No effect)
 * Francis? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 16
 * I'm sorry you went through that. (No effect)
 * At least you have your freedom now. (No effect)
 * ❤ I can't imagine anyone not falling in love with you... (Gemma ❤ +Romance)

"" if you asked Effie to search Francis's room and thought Francis really loved Amelia.

"" if you thought Francis was obsessed with Amelia.

Chapter Three: Lay of the Land Choices
Choice 1
 * Mrs. Watmore's our biggest lead so far. (No effect)
 * Anyone is fair game at this point. (No effect)
 * I'm still more suspicious of Francis. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * See the town. (No effect)
 * Spend more time with you. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Take the receiver from Effie. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Such a riot! (No effect)
 * A little much for me. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Choice 5
 * Can you tell me more about the loss of your sister? (No effect)
 * Who is Victoria? (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Did you miss Windcroft while you were away? (No effect)
 * Do you miss traveling? (No effect)

Choice 7
 * A painted fan (No effect)
 * A rose necklace (No effect)
 * An antique brooch (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Any favorite activities? (No effect)
 * Friends who lived outside the estate? (No effect)

Choice 9
 * 🔎 Go to the village fair with John! (💎 17)
 * Skip the fair. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1

''This is a timed choice. Option order is random.'' ''If the timer ends, your mind goes blank. (No effect)''
 * Drop the ball! (No effect)
 * Throw the ball! (+Game)
 * Swing the ball! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

''This is a timed choice. Option order is random.'' ''If the timer ends, you lose your grip. (No effect)''
 * Hit the coconut! (+Game)
 * Hit the carnival barker! (No effect)
 * Hit John! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

''This is a timed choice. Option order is random.'' ''If the timer ends, you lose your grip. (No effect)''
 * Lose my grip! (No effect)
 * Hit the coconut! (+Game)

"" if you got 2 or more +Game.

"" if you got 1 or less +Game.

Diamond Choice 4
 * How delicious! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * Did he not make time for Amelia? (No effect)
 * Do you know what occupies him? (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 6
 * ❤ It's almost like you're courting me... (John ❤ +Romance)
 * It's made you almost tolerable! (No effect)

Choice 10
 * ❤ Solicitors were so handsome. (Hugh ❤ +Romance)
 * You and Amelia were close. (No effect)

Choice 11 ''You'll eventually see the answer to both. The one you didn't choose will automatically be asked.''
 * Are you originally from Windcroft? (No effect)
 * How long did you know Amelia? (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Could this be the gift that Amelia bought? (No effect)

Choice 13
 * 🔎 Spend time with Hugh to learn if they had an affair! (💎 16)
 * Head back to Windcroft Manor. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * What was she escaping from? (No effect)
 * What are you escaping from? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Don't you get lonely? (No effect)
 * You're sure nobody caught your eye... not even my sister? (No effect)

"" and 🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 9
 * I'm American. (No effect)
 * My family is 'new money'. (No effect)
 * I keep getting compared to my sister. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * ❤ Quite refreshing yourself, Mr. Crawford... (Hugh ❤ +Romance)
 * Too kind. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Choice 14
 * Pretending I need to ask him something. (No effect)
 * Sneaking up slowly and quietly. (, 🔎 +Clue)

Choice 15
 * I think I can manage navigating. (No effect)
 * Tell me what you had against my sister. (No effect)
 * Stay out of my way. (No effect)

Choice 16 You get to choose as many from the first three options as you want.
 * Mr. Barnes? (No effect)
 * Mrs. Watmore? (No effect)
 * Hugh Crawford? (No effect)
 * Actually, that's all for now. (Go to Choice 18)

Choice 17 (Mrs. Watmore)
 * What do you know of her background? (No effect)
 * Did she and Amelia ever argue? (No effect)
 * Does she have violent tendencies? (No effect)

Choice 18

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Claudio".
 * Name your pet horse!

Choice 19
 * Adopt Claudio! (💎 20)
 * Decline politely. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Brush out Claudio. (No effect)
 * Feed Claudio. (Diamond Choice 12)

Diamond Choice 12
 * Feed it to Claudio! (No effect)

""

Choice 20
 * Pick up the line. (🔎 +Clue)

Chapter Four: Roses & Thorns Choices
Choice 1
 * Eavesdropping. (No effect)
 * Gaining everyone's favor. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Stand out. (No effect)
 * Behave with proper decorum. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * An English Rose (💎 25) (No effect)
 * No thanks (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Amelia's sister. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +A Perfect Lady)
 * Francis's betrothed. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +A Perfect Lady)
 * The troublemaking American. (TUHIconAmericanCharmer.png +American Charmer)

"" if you got +A Perfect Lady.

"" if you got +American Charmer.

Choice 5
 * Has been perfectly hospitable. (TUHIconEtiquette.png +A Perfect Lady)
 * Tried to scare me away, but I like a challenge. (TUHIconAmericanCharmer.png +American Charmer)

"" if you got +A Perfect Lady.

"" if you got +American Charmer.

Choice 6
 * The baron and baroness? (No effect)
 * The marquess and marchioness? (No effect)

Choice 7
 * A religieuse (TUHIconEtiquette.png +A Perfect Lady)
 * A fancy tart (TUHIconEtiquette.png +A Perfect Lady)
 * A mint julep (TUHIconAmericanCharmer.png +American Charmer)

"" if you're wearing "An English Rose".

Choice 8
 * I'll play a game of croquet with you! (💎 16)
 * Actually, never mind. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * ❤ I want a way to your heart? (John ❤ +Romance)
 * That I'll never win? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you panic and overshoot. (No effect)''
 * Aim for the near hoop! (+Croquet)
 * Aim for the far hoop! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you loft the ball. (No effect)''
 * Throw the ball! (No effect)
 * Hit the ball! (+Croquet)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Why did you cut your tour short? (+Croquet)
 * Why did Earl Tully mention Victoria? (+Croquet)

"" if you got 2 or 3 +Croquet.

"" if you got 1 +Croquet.

Diamond Choice 5
 * ❤ Squeeze his shoulder in comfort. (John ❤ +Romance)
 * Say that you are here for him. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Choice 9 ''You'll eventually see the answer to both. The one you didn't choose will automatically be asked.''
 * Who was the recipient? (🔎 +Clue)
 * When was this payment? (No effect)

Choice 10
 * ❤ You're sure I can't convince you to stay? (Hugh ❤ +Romance)
 * I appreciate you stopping by. (No effect)

"" and "" if you got at least 2 A Perfect Lady.

"" and "" if you got at least 2 American Charmer.

Diamond Choice 6 (An English Rose)
 * Needed money for something? (No effect)
 * Was very generous? (No effect)

🔎 +Clue, ""

"" if you're not wearing "An English Rose".

"" if you got at least 2 +A Perfect Lady.

"" if you got at least 2 +American Charmer.

"" if you're wearing "An English Rose".

Choice 11
 * Did Amelia have a disagreement with someone? (🔎 +Clue x1, x2 if wearing "An English Rose")
 * Did Amelia love Francis? (🔎 +Clue x1, x2 if wearing "An English Rose")

Choice 12
 * And the two of you, stay far away from me. (No effect)
 * Let's take our leave. There's nothing more here for us. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Thank you for stepping in. (No effect)
 * ❤ I'm glad you were by my side for that. (Gemma ❤ +Romance)

Choice 14
 * How do you cope? (No effect)
 * ❤ You needn't worry... not with me here. (Gemma ❤ +Romance)

Choice 15
 * 🔎 Follow Francis and eavesdrop. (💎 15)
 * Stay out of it. (, 🔎 +Clue)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Tell me what you know. Right now. (No effect)
 * You can trust me. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 8
 * Tell the authorities right away. (No effect)
 * Investigate until we know more. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * I want them to pay too. (No effect)
 * I'm glad she had people who cared. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * How elegant! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Exciting and mysterious! (No effect)
 * Strange... (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 12
 * We learn the truth. (No effect)
 * Her murderer is behind bars! (No effect)
 * My sister's soul finds peace... (No effect)

Chapter Five: Without a Trace Choices
Diamond Choice 1 (Perfume)
 * Effie, and each other. (No effect)
 * The element of surprise. (No effect)

Choice 1 (No Perfume)
 * She was my sister!
 * Who else will be your ally?

Choice 2
 * The general timeline of that day. (No effect)
 * What Amelia was feeling before she died. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Choice 3
 * Relieved you feel the same way. (No effect)
 * Disappointed... but I understand. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * You've got a deal. (No effect)
 * This could be dangerous. (No effect)
 * You should get down on one knee! (No effect)

""

Choice 5
 * Think John could be useful. (No effect)
 * Will respect your wish. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Being with the love of my life forever! (No effect)
 * Bringing our families together. (No effect)
 * The honeymoon! (No effect)

Choice 7
 * That must frustrate you... (No effect)
 * Then why bother trying? (No effect)

Choice 8
 * 🔎 Explore the secret passageway with John! (💎 18)
 * Head back to your room. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Ingenious, really. (No effect)
 * Immoral... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3-5
 * Fire tile (+Puzzle if picked 1st)
 * Earth tile (+Puzzle if picked 3rd)
 * Water tile (+Puzzle if picked 2nd)

''You have to press the tiles in order: fire, water, earth. If you don't get all 3 +Puzzle, John will solve it.''

🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 6
 * Tell John the truth about Amelia's death.
 * Keep it quiet for now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Do you mind telling me about your natural parents? (No effect)
 * Tell me about this cousin Benjamin. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Wait... (🔎 +Clue)

Diamond Choice 9
 * ❤ Lean closer... (John ❤ +Romance)
 * Excuse myself. (No effect)

If you unlocked a special Clue, certain options will be marked with an icon.

Choice 9
 * 🔎 Amelia arguing with the marquess?
 * 🔎 Amelia arguing with the baroness?
 * 🔎 Amelia sending letters?
 * 🔎 Amelia sending packages? (🔎 +Clue)
 * 🔎 Amelia and the earl disagreeing?
 * 🔎 Amelia taking late night rides? (No effect)
 * Someone Mr. Crawford called 'Stanley Weatherington'? (No effect)

''You get the first option if Marchioness Huntsbury told you about disagreements between her husband and Amelia. (You were "A Perfect Lady" and asked if Amelia had disagreements in Chapter 4.)''

''You get the second option if Marquess Huntsbury told you about disagreements between Amelia and Baroness Pritchard. (You were an "American Charmer" and asked if Amelia had disagreements.)''

''You get the third option if Baron Pritchard told you that Amelia wrote to someone. (You were "A Perfect Lady" and asked if Amelia loved Francis.)''

''You get the fourth option if Baroness Pritchard told you that Amelia was sending packages. (You were an "American Charmer" and asked if Amelia loved Francis.)''

''You get the fifth option if Earl Tully told you about disagreements between Amelia and him. (You wore "An English Rose" and asked if Amelia had disagreements.)''

''You get the sixth option if Earl Tully told you that Amelia was always riding her horse into town late at nights. (You wore "An English Rose" and asked if Amelia loved Francis.)''

''You get to choose all of the ones them. This just determines the order.''

🔎 +Clue

Choice 10
 * Sunday Best (💎 25) (No effect)
 * No thanks (No effect)

🔎 +Clue, "" if you adopted Claudio.

Choice 11 ''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''
 * The bookshop. (No effect)
 * The tailor. (No effect)
 * The schoolhouse. (No effect)

Choice 12 (Bookshop)
 * You're already a lord in my eyes. (+Engagement) ⬅ Correct
 * You'll do fine at running the estate. (No effect)

"" if you're wearing "Sunday Best" or got Choice 12 right.

Choice 13 (Bookshop) (if you impressed the bookstore owner)
 * What kind of books did she read? (No effect)
 * Did she ever stay past closing hours? (No effect)

Choice 14 (Tailor)
 * A party in London! (No effect)
 * Our honeymoon travels! (No effect) ⬅ Correct

"" if you're wearing "Sunday Best" or got Choice 14 right.

Choice 15 (Tailor) (if you impressed the tailor)
 * Ever with someone? (No effect)
 * Distressed about something? (No effect)

Choice 16 (Schoolhouse)
 * We're truly in love. (No effect)
 * We're taking our time in growing our love. (+Engagement) ⬅ Correct

"" if you're wearing "Sunday Best" or got Choice 16 right.

Choice 17 (Schoolhouse) (if you impressed the teacher)
 * Hold these practices at night? (No effect)
 * Ever have trouble with the staff? (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Put the ring on! (No effect)

Choice 19
 * A thousand times yes! (No effect)
 * I love you so much. (No effect)
 * Why didn't you get me a bigger diamond?

"" if you got 2 or more +Engagement or are wearing "Sunday Best".

"" if you got 1 or less +Engagement and aren't wearing "Sunday Best".

Choice 20
 * Looks refreshing! (No effect)

Choice 21
 * I appreciate your efforts. (No effect)
 * ❤ I wouldn't be able to do this without you. (Hugh ❤ +Romance)

Choice 22
 * 🔎 Hear about the gift and take it. (💎 16)
 * Let Hugh keep it.

Diamond Choice 10
 * Certainly hope not. (No effect)
 * Don't mean to be this way.

Diamond Choice 11
 * How lovely!

Diamond Choice 12
 * Is it perfectly safe to touch it? (No effect)
 * What skillful craftsmanship... (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 13
 * ❤ Let my hand linger... (Hugh ❤ +Romance)
 * Apologize. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Diamond Choice 14
 * Tell him that Amelia was poisoned.
 * Keep it close for now. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue x2 if you're wearing "Sunday Best" or you've adopted Claudio.

Choice 23
 * Intimidate him. (No effect)
 * Reason with him. (No effect)

🔎 +Clue

Choice 24
 * Are you absolutely sure? (No effect)
 * Why would she do such a thing?! (No effect)