America's Most Eligible Theory Page

Welcome to the America's Most Eligible Theory Page. Here we can discuss current, unconfirmed, and debunked theories regarding the America's Most Eligible series.

Current and Unconfirmed Theories

 * Jen will be a love interest - It is believed that Jen will be a love interest given that you have the option to kiss her in Chapter 1.
 * Piper will be the Big Bad - Given Piper's derogatory attitude towards you, it is believed that she will attempt to sabotage you and your allies.
 * Antagonists - There are a couple theories for contestants who could end up being antagonists. Some fans believe that Zeke may be an antagonist given his narcissistic showboat personality. Some fans believe that Teagan, Ivy and Adam only pretend to be nice but will end up being cruel and manipulative. The MC even states that they didn't watch the last season of America's Most Eligible, so they wouldn't know a thing about Adam.
 * Final 2/9 Person Jury - Due to the contestants selecting the winner, it is presumed the season will end with a final 2 and a 9 person jury, with majority of the votes needed being 5. This is similar to the format of ‘Big Brother’, where there is a final 2 facing a jury of 9.
 * Yacht- Some fans believe that instead of losing her balance, Ivy was intentionally pushed overboard or that she potentially did it for sympathy and extra airtime.
 * Rumors - There a couple theories as to who spread the rumors about you. Some fans believe it was Ivy given that several players think her kind personality is just a ruse. Others believe that it was Omar given that he casually dodged the question when Jen asked him if he told Lina to accuse you of sleeping with the crew. If you didn't eliminate Lina, she will confess that she heard the rumor from another contestant.
 * Eliminated Contestants Returning to the Competition: It is theorized that at least one eliminated contestant will return to the competion thanks to some sort of twist.
 * Photoshoot challenge- It is widely believed that Ivy cheated/sabotaged the photoshoot challenge and won the audience vote in order to nominate you for elimination.

Debunked Theories

 * Gender Rotation - Some fans believe that the first few chapters will alternate between whether or not a man or woman gets eliminated. This was debunked in Chapter 6, as there is a 50% chance Han is the one to be eliminated, meaning two men are eliminated consecutively.

Confirmed Theories

 * Ryder's Sabotage - Many fans (and Ryder himself) believed that he was sabotaged in the second challenge by Beautiful Contestant (Mackenzie), due to her smiling when he was in the bottom two, fighting with him earlier that day, and potentially getting him eliminated to get her bed back. This has been proven in Chapter 5, when the Beautiful Contestant admits to doing so as she misled him with advice that prevented him from getting many numbers.