Thread:Agente-Leite/@comment-4786757-20191116190853/@comment-36836718-20191117164516

Okay, my opinion on the matter of dividing them. Short answer: I prefer to keep them combined. Long answer follows:

If we added a Hartfeld students category, any time a person graduates or drops out, we would have to remove the category and add the other one in. When our wiki manager suggested the category for ongoing series, I already said that adding one category just to remove it later and adding another one in is unnecessary work imo. I think the same applies here.

Probably most students have already graduated at the end of series, so the graduates category would probably be very long and the other one very short. And adding those characters that should have graduated but it's not confirmed yet to one of the categories just because they either have to be students or graduates/drop-outs feels wrong imo. And it may confuse newer users so we would have to come up with both a name and a description that clearly say which character goes where. I don't think that characters like Beau, Manny, etc would count as alumni? But they left Hartfeld so they're no longer students of Hartfeld... so the word alumni wouldn't work?

I personally find that dividing them would be too much work. I like how it is currently. If the majority thinks otherwise I will go along but that's my opinion. If anything is unclear, please ask :) I currently don't get to use as much English as usually so I already feel my use of English get worse.