The Elementalists: Winters Past Choices



This page contains the choices in The Elementalists: Winters Past and their outcomes.

''This game revolves heavily around choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make their right choice for the game. Good luck and happy playing!''

'''Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet. Please help this page by contributing those answers!'''

Setup Choices
Choice 1 (Finished Book 2)
 * Import now! (Go to Choice 2)
 * Play without importing.

Choice 2
 * Yes, I'd like to change my face.
 * No, I'll continue with my current face. (Go to Choice 3)

Choice 3 (Hair - Female)
 * All Curled Up
 * Sure, Jan
 * Bits and Bobs
 * Red Hot
 * Catch a Wave

Choice 3 (Hair - Male)
 * Twist And Shout
 * Sk8ter Boy
 * Bun-Believable
 * Red Alert
 * Curly Q

Choice 4
 * This look is perfect!
 * Let's try something else.
 * I want to change my gender.

Choice 5
 * No.
 * Yes, I'd like to date someone else.

Chapter One: Twas The Night Before Solstice Choices
Choice 1 (No Import) ''This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. The default is "Pend Pals."''
 * Name your friend group!

+Attunement

Choice 2

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, the snowball hits you in the face.
 * TESunIcon.png Melt it with Sun magick! (TESunIcon.png +Sun)
 * Do a barrel roll! (No effect)
 * TEFireIcon.png Incinerate it! (TEFireIcon.png +Fire)
 * TEAirIcon.png Blow it away! (TEAirIcon.png +Air)
 * TEEarthIcon.png Smash it! (TEEarthIcon.png +Earth)

You only get one of the last three options depending on your Attunement.

Choice 3 (No Import)
 * Beckett, the studious academic!
 * Shreya, the fiery fashionista!
 * Griffin, the selfless athlete!
 * Aster, the kindhearted wood nymph!
 * Nobody.

LI ❤ +Romance if you chose a love interest.

Choice 4
 * Plaid to the Bone (Female) / Turn up the Heat (Male) (💎 25) (, LI ❤ +Romance)
 * No thanks (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Winter Queen (Female) / Swept Away (Male) (💎 20)
 * No thanks (Go to the Closet)

Choice 6 The third option only appears if you chose an LI?
 * Getting up to as many shenanigans as I can! (No effect)
 * Relaxing, to be honest. (No effect)
 * Sneaking off for some snowy make outs. (LI ❤ +Romance)

+Attunement

Choice 7

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you don't do anything. (-Battle)''
 * Decorate our snowman's face! (-Battle)
 * Pack the snow tighter! (+Battle)

+Battle if you packed the snowman tight.

-Battle if you packed the snowman loose.

Choice 8

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you don't do anything. (-Battle)''
 * TEAirIcon.png Blow them away, literally! (+Battle, TEAirIcon.png +Air)
 * TEMetalIcon.png Slice up their snowman! (-Battle)

Choice 9

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you don't do anything. (-Battle)''
 * TEWaterIcon.png Make our snowman kick theirs! (TEWaterIcon.png +Water, +Battle)
 * TEWoodIcon.png Sabotage their snowman! (TEWoodIcon.png +Wood, +Battle)

LI ❤ +Romance

Choice 10
 * Let's skate. (💎 18)
 * I'll pass. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Lace up your skates! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Hold onto Atlas! (No effect)
 * Let go of Atlas! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, ?
 * Skate into Beckett!
 * Skate around Beckett! (+Skate)

Diamond Choice 4

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, ?
 * Skate through it! (+Skate)
 * Faceplant dramatically!

"" if you got both +Skate?

Diamond Choice 5
 * The ice... IT LIVES! (No effect)

LI ❤ +Romance

Choice 11
 * It's really scary. (No effect)
 * Someone holds my hand. (LI ❤ +Romance)

+Wood if Wood-Att.

Choice 12
 * I think it's a good idea. (No effect)
 * But only to protect you. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * TEMetalIcon.png Use magick to unlock it. (TEMetalIcon.png +Metal)
 * TEWoodIcon.png Rip the door open! (No effect)

Choice 14
 * In the fireplace. (No effect)
 * On the stairs. (No effect)
 * At the chandelier. (No effect)

Choice 15 (Fireplace)
 * Pick it up. (No effect)

+Fire if Fire-Att

Choice 15 (Stairs)
 * Pick them up. (No effect)

Choice 15 (Chandelier)
 * A scarf? (No effect)

Choice 16
 * TEMoonIcon.png Go easy on him/her. (No effect)
 * TESunIcon.png Show no mercy. (No effect)

Choice 17
 * An old locket? (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Is one of the ghost's targets. (No effect)
 * Knows what happened here. (No effect)

Choice 19
 * Take the locket. (💎 15)
 * Leave it. (No effect)

 +Water if Water-Att.

Choice 20
 * Please don't be creepy. (No effect)

Chapter Two: Can't Beat That Holiday Spirit Choices
 +Fire if Fire-Att.

Choice 1

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, Zeph blasts the spirit with water.
 * TEAirIcon.png Blow it away! (TEAirIcon.png +Air)
 * TESunIcon.png Blind it! (No effect)

 +Earth if Earth-Att

"" and +Clue if you got the locket from the previous chapter.

Choice 2

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, you say you're terrified and get -Clue.
 * From next door! (+Clue)
 * Friends... right guys? (-Clue)

Choice 3
 * Atlas, teach me that spell! (💎 16)
 * There's no time! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Freeze them! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * The cold affects you so much? (+Clue)
 * You get so angry during Solstice? (+Clue)

Diamond Choice 3 +Clue
 * How long have you been here? (+Clue)
 * Why did you keep going for Shreya earlier? (+Clue)
 * What's so important about this locket? (+Clue, this option is only available if you got the locket)

""

Choice 4
 * Way too creepy. (No effect)
 * A pretty sweet deal. (No effect)

 +Metal if Metal-Att, +Wood if Wood-Att.

❤ +Romance if Beckett is your LI

Choice 5 ❤ +Romance if Beckett is your LI
 * TEEarthIcon.png Replace Atlas's sugar with salt! (No effect)
 * TEAirIcon.png Steal all of Atlas's chocolate chips! (No effect)

Choice 6
 * No! (No effect)
 * Hey, you have to share! (No effect)

You may only get the following choices if you are dating someone.

Choice 7
 * That's just mistletoe... (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Pull him/her under the mistletoe! (LI ❤ +Romance)
 * Put cookie dough on his/her nose! (LI ❤ +Romance)

Choice 9
 * Let's get outta here. (💎19)
 * We should stay. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Shreya)
 * My lips. (No effect)
 * Peppermint Hot Chocolate.

Diamond Choice 5 (Shreya)
 * Forget about the piano! (No effect)
 * Play me something!

""

Diamond Choice 4 (Beckett)
 * Show me a side of you I've never seen. (No effect)
 * Start with this dance. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Beckett)
 * Kiss me. (No effect)
 * Hold me. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 4 (Aster)
 * Play the piano. (No effect)
 * Jump on the couches! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Aster) ""
 * Do it all. (No effect)
 * Look at each other (No effect)

Choice 10
 * The ghost's body. (No effect)
 * So. Much. Money. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Pet it! (No effect)
 * Be suspicious. (No effect)

+Air if Air-att.

Choice 12

This is a fill-in-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Pepper".
 * Name the friendly cat!

Choice 13
 * Take a look. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * Pepper, welcome to the team. (💎 20)
 * Sorry, Pepper... (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Kavya tried to stop the ghost? (No effect)
 * They were all friends? (No effect or if you purchased the cat) ⬅ Correct

 +Water if Water-Att.

Choice 16

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, Aster drags the dragon back down.
 * TEWoodIcon.png Pummel the dragon with books! (No effect)
 * Drag the dragon back down! (No effect)

Choice 17
 * A plush toy? (No effect)

Chapter Three: Silent Night Choices
Choice 1
 * Take a look. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * They didn't know her spirit was still here. (No effect)
 * She scared them away. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Pick it up. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * TEAirIcon.png Clear a path to the Mistry chateau! (No effect)
 * TEAirIcon.png Fight wind with wind! (No effect)

Choice 5
 * It's too far away! (No effect)

"" if you bought the locket in Chapter 1.

"" if didn't buy the locket in Chapter 1.

Choice 6
 * Read it. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Are you waiting here for Kavya? (No effect)
 * What kind of magick did you do with Kavya? (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Please show us your memories! (💎 17)
 * We should mind our own business. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Throw a snowball at her. (No effect)
 * Move closer for a better look. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Mind. (No effect)
 * Hands, and make a snowball. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Words of encouragement. (No effect)
 * Warmth. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * It's beautiful! (No effect)

"" if you recruited the ghost cat.

 +Water if Water-Att.

Choice 9
 * A creepy doll? (No effect)

 +Fire if Fire-Att?

Choice 10

This is a timed choice. Third option only if Water-Att.
 * TEMetalIcon.png Bind the doll's hands! (TEMetalIcon.png +Metal if Metal-Att, +Toys)
 * TEWaterIcon.png Cover the doll in snow!
 * TEWaterIcon.png Burst a water pipe to distract the doll!

''If the timer ends, you don't know what to do. (-Toys)''

Choice 11

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, ?
 * TEFireIcon.png Blast it away!
 * TEAirIcon.png Trap it in an air bubble! (TEAirIcon.png +Air, +Toys)
 * TEFireIcon.png Mesmerize it with fire!

The third option only appears if Fire-Att.

Choice 12
 * Let's cast it together! (💎 15)
 * There's no time! (Go to Choice 13)

Diamond Choice 5
 * Link our magick! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * The bunny! (+Toys)
 * The alien! (+Toys)
 * The bear! (+Toys)

''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''

Diamond Choice 7
 * Rabbit! (No effect)
 * Teddy bear! (No effect)
 * Pink thing! (No effect)

""

Choice 13 (Non-diamond)

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, ?
 * TEWoodIcon.png Hold it in place with the floorboards! (TEWoodIcon.png +Wood if?, Path A?)
 * TEAirIcon.png Send it flying!
 * TEEarthIcon.png Throw off its balance!

The third option only appears if Earth-Att?

Choice 14 (Non-diamond) (Path A?)
 * A teddy bear! (+Toys)

"" if you didn't learn the Immobilizing spell.

Choice 15
 * Voila! (No effect)

Choice 16
 * Freedom! (Path A)
 * Let's be careful. (Path B)

Choice 17 (Path A)
 * AAAAAH! (No effect)

Choice 17 (Path B)
 * Not creepy or anything. (No effect)

 +Air if Air-Att.

Choice 18 The last option only appears if you're not single.
 * Gorgeous. (No effect)
 * Really damn cold. (No effect)
 * So romantic... (LI ❤+Romance)

Choice 19 LI ❤+Romance
 * Swap cookies with the neighbors! (No effect)
 * Wear a onesie! (No effect)
 * Decorate a gingerbread house! (No effect)

Choice 20
 * Share our wishes! (💎 18)
 * Focus on the tree. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Win the Thief championship together! (No effect)
 * Enter the annual dragon links eating contest!
 * TP Professor Konto's office! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * Everyone's wishes to come true. (No effect)
 * More magick and power.
 * Hot cocoa with tons of marshmallows! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * Your wish already came true. (No effect)
 * It's okay to be sad. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 11
 * What are they? (No effect)

LI ❤+Romance

+Metal if Metal-Att.

Choice 21 LI ❤+Romance
 * Help arrange the presents! (No effect)
 * Hang candy canes! (No effect)
 * String some ribbon up the banister! (No effect)

Choice 22
 * TESunIcon.png Some toasty warm Sun magick? (No effect)
 * TEMoonIcon.png Some cool and sparkly Moon magick? (No effect)

Chapter Four: Solstice Bell Choices
 +Fire if Fire-Att.

Choice 1

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you don't do anything. (-Calm)''
 * TEWaterIcon.png Chill Isabella out! (-Calm)
 * TESunIcon.png Warm Isabella up! (+Calm)
 * TEFireIcon.png Distract her with fire! (+Calm)

The third option only appears if Fire-Att.

+Calm if you got +Calm in Choice 1.

-Calm if you got -Calm in Choice 1.

Choice 2 This choice only appears if you didn't see Isabella's memories in Chapter 3?
 * A flower? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 This choice only appears if you saw Isabella's memories in Chapter 3?
 * Their golden flower! (No effect)

+Wood if Wood-Att.

+Air if Air-Att.

+Metal if Metal-Att.

Choice 3
 * The tree looks lovely! (No effect)
 * My mom's ancient! (No effect)

"" if you bought the Freezing spell in Chapter 2.

"" if you learned the Immobilizing spell in Chapter 3 .

"" if you didn't learn the Immobilizing spell in Chapter 3.

Choice 4
 * The spooky doll! (No effect)

Choice 5
 * You've got Atlas all figured out. (No effect)
 * You're gonna make Atlas cry. (No effect)

Choice 6 (if you caught the dragon?)
 * The dragon! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * A teddy for Zeph! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * A majestic lion for Shreya! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * A velveteen rabbit for Beckett! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * A fluffy pink cat(?) for Griffin! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * A penguin plush for Aster! (No effect)

Diamond Choices 2-6 appear if you learned the Immobilizing spell in Chapter 3.

Diamond Choice 7
 * Here you go.

"" if you didn't buy the locket in Chapter 1.

+Earth if Earth-Att.

Choice 8
 * Of course! (💎 15)
 * I'm sorry.

Diamond Choice 8
 * TESunIcon.png A radiant luster!
 * TEMoonIcon.png An icy sheen! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * Tada! (No effect)

""

Choice 9 The third option only appears if Metal-Att.
 * TEWoodIcon.png A flower path. (TEWoodIcon.png +Wood if Wood-Att?)
 * TEAirIcon.png A nice warm breeze. (TEAirIcon.png +Air)
 * TEMetalIcon.png Ornaments from the tree.

Choice 10
 * Gimme! (No effect)

Choice 11
 * It's like I'm being watched. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Straight up bourbon. (No effect)
 * Peppermint candy cane. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Bottoms up! (No effect)

LI ❤ +Romance

+Water if Water-Att.

Choice 14
 * Aw... remember this? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * My surprise birthday party! (No effect)
 * Reuniting with my friends Sophomore year! (No effect)
 * Playing Thief with my professors! (No effect)

LI ❤ +Romance

Choice 16
 * A laser tag set! (No effect)

Choice 17
 * Play magickal laser tag! (💎 20)
 * Wait for another time. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you trip. (-Defense)''
 * Duck behind the piano! (-Defense)
 * TESunIcon.png Deflect the shot! (+Defense)

Diamond Choice 9

This is a timed choice. ''If timer runs out, Griffin saves you. (-Defense)''
 * TEWaterIcon.png Bury him/her in snow! (-Offense)
 * TEEarthIcon.png Make him/her lose his/her footing. (+Offense)

LI ❤+Romance

Diamond Choice 10

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer runs out, Atlas wins. (Skip Diamond Choice 11)''
 * Aster! (Win)
 * Myself! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11

This is a timed choice. If the timer runs out, Atlas shoots at you.
 * Fire!

""

Choice 18 (Beckett)
 * Looks cozy. (Beckett ❤+Romance)

Choice 19 (Beckett)
 * You look without your clothes. (No effect)
 * Incredibly warm this is.

Choice 20 (Beckett)
 * I can't wait for the day.
 * I don't think it's for me.
 * Only if you're by my side. (Beckett ❤+Romance)

Choice 21 (Beckett)
 * And make the most of tonight! (💎 30)
 * But just to warm up.

Diamond Choice 15 (Beckett)

This is a timed choice. If the timer runs out, Beckett mentions how you're speechless.
 * Get to the damn point already! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15 (Beckett)
 * I'm not going to beg! (No effect)
 * I'm going to make you beg. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15 (Beckett)
 * You better not stop this time. (No effect)
 * I don't think I can take any more. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 15 (Beckett)
 * A poetry book! (Beckett ❤+Romance)

""

Choice 18 (Griffin)
 * I'll be warm in no time!

Choice 19 (Griffin)
 * All your clothes.
 * Having you hold me.

Choice 20 (Griffin)
 * I can't wait for the day.
 * I don't think it's for me.
 * Only if you're by my side. (+Romance)

Choice 21 (Griffin)
 * And find someplace private! (💎30)
 * But just be with our friends.

Diamond Choice (Griffin)
 * I meant the perfect boyfriend!

Diamond Choice (Griffin)
 * Savory raspberry.
 * Frosty strawberry.

Diamond Choice (Griffin)
 * Muscles.
 * Heart.

Diamond Choice (Griffin)
 * Keep going!!
 * Let's slow down.

Diamond Choice (Griffin)
 * Aw, Griffin! (+Romance)

""

Choice 22 The third option only appears if Earth-Att?
 * TEWaterIcon.png Take an ice sculpture with you. (TEWaterIcon.png +Water)
 * TEAirIcon.png Enjoy one last chill. (No effect)
 * TEEarthIcon.png Make a final snow angel. (No effect)

You have reached the end of The Elementalists: Winters Past.