Immortal Desires, Book 1 Choices



This page contains the choices in Immortal Desires and their outcomes.

''This game revolves heavily around choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make their right choice for the game. Good luck and happy playing!''

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices
''Content Warning: This book contains realistic depictions of violence and gore. Player discretion is advised.''

Choice 1
 * She/her.
 * He/him.
 * They/them.

Choice 2
 * Body Type 1
 * Body Type 2

Choice 3
 * Face 1
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 4

Choice 4 (Body Type 1)
 * Braid Game
 * Cherry On Top
 * Red Alert
 * Swept Up
 * Woke Up Like This
 * Get Things Straight
 * Top Knot
 * Crimson Elegance

Choice 4 (Body Type 2)
 * Buzzkill
 * Get It Twisted
 * On Loc
 * Curl Up
 * Gingersnap
 * Woke Up Like This
 * Swept Away
 * Say It Louder

Choice 5
 * Great! I love it!
 * Let's try something else. (Go Back to Choice 1)

Choice 6

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Parker".
 * What is your name?

Choice 7

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Reese".
 * What is your last name?

Chapter One: Monsters in a Small Town Choices
Choice 1
 * Mom's at it again... (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Since literally forever. (No effect)
 * New town, new me. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * I'll just make sure not to get murdered. (No effect)
 * So that's your blessing to go crazy? (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Don't Cross Me (💎 15)
 * Cozy As Can Be (Body Type 1) / Bundled Up (Body Type 2) (💎 15)
 * The Everyday

Choice 5 (Gabe)
 * A boy.
 * A girl.

Choice 6 (Gabe)
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Show female/male options instead.

Choice 7

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, ?
 * Catch it! (No effect)
 * Catch it?
 * Flinch!

"" if you're wearing "Don't Cross Me" or "Cozy As Can Be"/"Bundled Up".

Choice 8
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png My secret admirer? (❤ +Mysterious Cutie)
 * One of the popular kids, obviously. (No effect)
 * ...I'm stumped. Who are you?

"" if you're wearing "Don't Cross Me" or "Cozy As Can Be"/"Bundled Up".

Choice 9
 * Pretty sure that's a deadly weapon. (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Now we're talking.
 * Any chance they're behind the murders? (No effect)

Choice 11 (Cas)
 * A girl.
 * A boy.

Choice 12 (Cas)
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Show male/female options instead.

Choice 13
 * Stand my ground. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Take a good look. (❤ +Cas)

Choice 14
 * You sure they're safe? (No effect)
 * This'll be inside those magic boundaries you talked about? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Nice party decorations!
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Maybe a little bit. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Choice 16
 * Are you the delinquent everyone's been talking about?
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Don't tell me, you crashed the party just to see me. (❤ +Cas)

"" if you're wearing "Don't Cross Me".

Choice 17
 * Count me in. (💎 18)
 * I don't think so.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Gabriel/Gabriela's lap! (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Jade's lap! (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Cas's lap! (❤ +Cas)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Speed up to get to Gabriel/Gabriela. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Slow down to stay near Cas. (❤ +Cas)

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela, "" if you chose Gabe both times.

❤ +Cas, "" if you chose Cas both times.

"" if you chose one of each.

Diamond Choice 3
 * Sorry, but I'm not showing my hand just yet. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png I don't blame him/her. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png But I don't want Cas to feel lonely. (❤ +Cas)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Kiss Gabriel/Gabriela's cheek. (, ❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Tell Cas she/he'll have to try harder. (, ❤ +Cas)
 * Ignore Cas.

Choice 18
 * Vampires? Demons? What's the truth? (No effect)
 * Have you actually seen a demon? (No effect)

Choice 19
 * Throw a rock at her/him! (No effect)
 * Scream at her/him to stop! (No effect)
 * Get the hell outta here!

Choice 20
 * We have to go back to help that girl! (No effect)
 * What the hell just happened?! (No effect)

""

Choice 21
 * It's reacting! (No effect)

Chapter Two: Into the Lair Choices
Choice 1
 * (Run!) (No effect)
 * (Punch him in the face!) (No effect)

Choice 2
 * What's going on? (No effect)
 * Where are we? (No effect)

Choice 3
 * What's the harm in learning a little more? (💎 17)
 * I don't want to know any more.

Diamond Choice 1
 * How dangerous is he to humans? (No effect)
 * So he doesn't hate humans? (No effect)

""

Choice 4
 * Telling the truth. (No effect)
 * A liar! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Why is she so defensive of Cas? (No effect)
 * She hates humans, I can tell. (No effect)

""

Choice 5
 * You can't punish me for trying to stay alive! (+Respect)
 * Please, have mercy!
 * I didn't do anything!

Choice 6
 * I'll repay you however you want!
 * I'm not foolish enough to repeat anything I've learned here. (+Respect)
 * It would be so unfair!

"" if you got 2 +Respect.

"" if you got 0-1 +Respect.

Choice 7
 * I don't owe you anything. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png What's in it for me? (❤ +Cas)

Choice 8
 * That's barbaric! (No effect)
 * And here I thought you were tough. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * You shouldn't have to keep that to yourself. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Just... let me help. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Choice 10
 * I can't pass this up. (💎 16)
 * I'll think I'll pass.

Diamond Choice 3
 * It sounds like the vampires didn't want humans here. (No effect)
 * Did nobody ever realize it was vampires?

Diamond Choice 4
 * If any of those vampires are still here today. (No effect)
 * What measures they've gone through to keep their secret safe.

Diamond Choice 5
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Lean closer to Gabriel/Gabriela! (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Hand Gabriel/Gabriela the book!

Diamond Choice 6
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Maybe I should be the one to protect you. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Knowledge is power and safety.

""

Choice 11
 * Boy/Girl I met named Gabriel/Gabriela--
 * Girl/Boy I met named Cassie/Cassius... (No effect)
 * Festival committee I'm thinking of joining. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * I stayed late at school with some friends.
 * ...Yes. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * This is gruesome! (No effect)

Choice 14
 * What kind of injuries did the girl have? (No effect)
 * Is this murder like the others you've been investigating? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * There are rumors about monsters in the woods... (No effect)
 * It couldn't be a townsperson, could it? (No effect)

Chapter Three: My Date With a Vampire Choices
Choice 1
 * You'd like that, wouldn't you? (No effect)
 * You vampires had just better stay away from my mom.

Choice 2
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png But have you ever thought maybe I want Gabriel/Gabriela to save me? (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png But who said I needed to be saved? (❤ +Cas)
 * And I think I'll start now. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * So show me what you've got. (💎 17)
 * But I probably shouldn't.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Gonna train me to be the next Buffy? (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Just looking for an excuse to spend time with me? (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png I need more hands-on help. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * I've got it. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Well, hello there. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Oh yeah, real casual, Gabriel/Gabriela. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Deflect and fight back! (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Get close to Gabriel/Gabriela! (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Diamond Choice 5
 * What's this for?

""

Diamond Choice 6
 * Think I understand you better. (No effect)
 * Feel more prepared. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Gabriel/Gabriela, stop letting Cas egg you on.
 * Cas, grow up.
 * Are we gonna make these signs or not? (No effect)

Choice 5
 * What did he/she ever do to you? (No effect)
 * I know vampires murdered his/her family. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * But they're dangerous...
 * The same woods where you attacked me? (No effect)
 * But Astoria told you not to leave! (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png I'm starting to think you're just jealous. (❤ +Cas)
 * But he/she has every right to be worried. (No effect)
 * Aw, someone has a crush. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * So they're like, vegetarian vampires? (No effect)
 * That's nauseating. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * A rock. (No effect)
 * A stick. (No effect)
 * Cas's car keys! (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Hunt humans? (No effect)
 * Show off? (No effect)

Choice 11
 * I'm not like most humans. (No effect)
 * You aren't really giving me a chance to. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png You don't want me to leave, admit it. (❤ +Cas)

Choice 12
 * Another talisman!

Choice 13
 * I'm game! (💎 15)
 * No chance.

Diamond Choice 7
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Lick the blood off of her/his fingertip. (❤ +Cas)
 * Swipe it onto my own finger first. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Strip as well! (No effect)
 * Jump in my clothes!

Diamond Choice 9
 * Race you to the bottom! (No effect)
 * Show me what you got first.

+Respect

Diamond Choice 10
 * (Dunk her/him!) (No effect)
 * (Splash her/him!) (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * There's nothing wrong with humans. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png You're into me. (❤ +Cas)

❤ +Cas if you've romanced her/him before?

Diamond Choice 12
 * Mine, all mine.

Choice 14
 * Even after you spent all day trying to impress me? (No effect)
 * That's... cruel. (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Too bad for you I'm not the only one with a secret. (No effect)
 * So you do have a heart. (No effect)

Chapter Four: Small Town Charms Choices
Choice 1
 * You are dangerous.
 * You don't take anything seriously. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Try not to miss me too much. (❤ +Cas)
 * What ever will I do? (No effect)
 * Thanks for today. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * You've done all you can. (No effect)
 * Don't fixate on this case.

Choice 4
 * You're new here. (No effect)
 * You shouldn't step on any toes. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Getting a tour of campus from Cas. (No effect)
 * ...In the woods. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Just another student. (No effect)
 * Misunderstood.
 * ...Nice. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Hasn't asked me yet. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * And I are just friends. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * And you were really connecting with the music. (No effect)
 * But how do you have the time? (No effect)

Choice 9
 * I'll join you! (💎 18)
 * I'll stick to listening.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png In Gabriel/Gabriela's lap! (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * With the kids.

Diamond Choice 2
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png A minor to C. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * E minor to G.

Diamond Choice 3
 * Rascal raccoon! (No effect)
 * Daring duck!
 * Timid mouse!

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela if you've romanced him/her before?

Diamond Choice 4
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png I'm super happy with Gabriel/Gabriela too. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Sure, but I'll leave the singing to Gabriel/Gabriela next time.

""

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela if you've romanced him/her before?

Choice 10
 * What kinda game is this again? (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Pizza from the food truck! (No effect)
 * A forgotten newspaper! (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Earth to Gabriel/Gabriela, chivalry is dead! (No effect)
 * I wasn't that bad! (No effect)

Choice 13
 * He's just a fictional character... right? (No effect)
 * There must be some truth to the tale. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * Vampire hunters are real?! (No effect)
 * Why didn't you tell me? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Yikes... (No effect)
 * Okay, I get not sharing that. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * I understand. (No effect)
 * ...It's complicated.

Choice 17
 * Now we're talking!
 * Should I be worried? (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Thank you. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * But I couldn't. (No effect)

Choice 19
 * It was a moment of poor judgment? (No effect)
 * I can take care of myself. (No effect)

Choice 20
 * I think you're wrong about her/him. (No effect)
 * I promise to be careful. (No effect)

Choice 21
 * What are we waiting for? (💎 16)
 * No thanks.

Diamond Choice 5
 * That's so dramatic!
 * Do they change their looks when they come back? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * They're both so nice! (No effect)
 * That sounds like torture! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Hug him/her. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Cup his/her cheek in my hand. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

""

Diamond Choice 8
 * Before the vampires get us, don't you? (No effect)
 * So you can pick more flowers.

Choice 22
 * Thanks for today, I needed it. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png's do this again sometime. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Chapter Five: The Autumn Festival Choices
Choice 1
 * ...Just complicated. (No effect)
 * Fine. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Ruffle And Tumble (Body Type 1) / Festival Vibes (Body Type 2) (💎 25)
 * No thanks (No effect)

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela if you've romanced him/her before.

"" if you're wearing "Ruffle And Tumble"/"Festival Vibes".

Choice 3
 * Do they think I'm not doing enough to keep their secret? (No effect)
 * When will they leave me alone?
 * And it's making me paranoid! (No effect)

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela if you've romanced him/her before.

Choice 4
 * You small town folk know how to have fun. (No effect)
 * I'm down for three corndogs and a ride on the Scrambler!

Choice 5
 * Rebalance and forge ahead! (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Grab onto Gabriel/Gabriela! (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

"" if you're wearing "Ruffle And Tumble"/"Festival Vibes".

Choice 6
 * Except it's not a date. (No effect)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Like you even could. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Sounds like someone's jealous. (❤ +Cas)

Choice 7
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png For Cas's board! (❤ +Cas)
 * For my bullseye! (No effect)

Choice 8
 * It's so... pink. (No effect)

Choice 9 You get to choose as many as you have diamonds for.
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Gabriel/Gabriela. (💎 16)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Cas. (💎 16)
 * Nobody.

Diamond Choice 1 (Gabe)
 * And that's one of the reasons you like me. (No effect)
 * But you don't have to worry about Cas right now.

Diamond Choice 2 (Gabe)
 * Your favorite place in town. (No effect)
 * Where you had your first kiss.

Diamond Choice 3 (Gabe)
 * For me? (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)

Diamond Choice 4 (Gabe)
 * Close my eyes.
 * Lean in. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 5 (Cas)
 * But I'm still here. (No effect)
 * You should be.

Diamond Choice 6 (Cas)
 * Flinch!
 * Hold steady. (No effect)

❤ +Cas

Diamond Choice 7 (Cas)
 * Lean in toward Cas. (No effect)
 * Pull Cas closer.

""

Choice 10
 * For my mom to be safe.
 * To know what to do about this Gabriel/Gabriela and Cas situation. (No effect)
 * For the vampires to leave me alone. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Another talisman? (No effect)

Choice 12
 * It's none of your business. (No effect)
 * I just found it on the tree! (No effect)

+Respect if you checked out the gravestones with Gabe in Chapter 4?

Choice 13
 * I'll need this. (💎 15)
 * I shouldn't.

Diamond Choice 8 (if you learned self-defense from Gabe in Chapter 3)
 * Grab it!

Choice 14
 * Help!
 * Get out of here! (No effect)

Choice 15
 * I'm your friend!
 * This isn't you! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Disorientation Talisman)
 * Take that, bloodsuckers!

Choice 16
 * Towel! (Distracted! if you have the Disorientation Talisman, +Damage if you don't?)
 * Soccer ball! (Distracted!)

Choice 17
 * Some rope! (Distracted! if you have the Disorientation Talisman, +Damage if you don't?)
 * A basketball! (Distracted! if you have the Disorientation Talisman, +Damage if you don't?)
 * These sneakers! (Distracted!)

Diamond Choice 10 (Silver Ward Talisman)
 * Eat this!

❤ +Damage if you don't have the Silver Ward Talisman?

''"" if you got ? +Damage.''

''"" if you got ? +Damage.''

Choice 18
 * Are you okay?
 * What the hell? (No effect)

Chapter Six: Second Chances Choices
Choice 1
 * No. Confused? Absolutely. (No effect)
 * Yeah, but only because you lied! (No effect)
 * More like shocked about the bloodbath that happened! (No effect)

Choice 2
 * So you've been watching me from the start? (No effect)
 * Was any of it real? (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Take it easy on him/her. (No effect)
 * Is right. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Look away... (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Hopefully I can return the favor one day. (No effect)
 * But why did you need to? (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Let's check out this chamber. (💎 17)
 * We'd better not risk it.

Diamond Choice 1

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, you wait the ten seconds before leaving. (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * Go now! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * How old is this place? (No effect)
 * Where did all this stuff come from? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * You did it! (No effect)
 * Enough showing off. (No effect)

''""'

Diamond Choice 4
 * Sad. (No effect)
 * Moving. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Gabriel/Gabriela. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Cas. (❤ +Cas)
 * No one. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * It was unprovoked!
 * It was in public! (+Respect)
 * It was within town limits! (+Respect)

+Respect if ?

Choice 9
 * Does she have to do with this? (No effect)
 * Is she up to now? (No effect)

''"" if you got ? +Respect.''

''"" if you got ? +Respect.''

Choice 10
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png Gabriel/Gabriela. (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Cas. (❤ +Cas)
 * Both of them. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Gabriel/Gabriela? (No effect)
 * Cas? (No effect)

Choice 12 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * I forgive you.
 * We all have our demons. (No effect)

Choice 13 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Worse.
 * Like the best possible outcome. (No effect)

❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela if you've romanced him/her before?

Choice 14 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Let's make it a date. (💎 18)
 * I think I'd better head home.

Diamond Choice 5 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Mint Chocolate Chip?
 * Orange Sherbet?
 * Pistachio.

Diamond Choice 6 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Butterscotch.
 * Bubblegum.

Diamond Choice 7 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * What's your happiest memory here?
 * What's something I wouldn't guess about you?

Diamond Choice 8 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png (Kiss Gabriel/Gabriela's cheek!) (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * (Put ice cream on his/her nose!)

''""'

Choice 15 (Gabriel/Gabriela)
 * Icon_Heart_Red.png(Kiss Gabriel/Gabriela.) (❤ +Gabriel/Gabriela, )
 * (Bid him/her goodnight.)

Choice 12 (Cas)
 * How noble of you. (No effect)
 * On whose authority? (No effect)

Choice 13 (Cas)
 * You're pretty okay yourself. (No effect)
 * I finally found your weakness. (No effect)

Choice 14 (Cas)
 * Sure, but it's on you. (💎 18)
 * I should get home.

Diamond Choice 5 (Cas)
 * Rum Raisin.
 * Rose Water. (No effect)
 * Mint Chocolate Chip. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Cas)
 * Mine. (No effect)
 * Yours.

Diamond Choice 7 (Cas)
 * Have a secret desire to be a worldwide culinary sensation. (No effect)
 * Are experimenting on some kind of new vampire torture. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Cas)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Take her/his hand. (❤ +Cas)
 * Kick her/his foot back! (No effect)

""

Choice 15 (Cas)
 * Icon_Heart_Purple.png Kiss Cas. (❤ +Cas, )
 * Bid Cas goodnight. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * I'm sorry. (No effect)
 * I stayed late to help the committee. (No effect)

Choice 17
 * The same one worn by my attackers! (No effect)