Talk:The Elementalists Theory Page/@comment-37621533-20181230215811/@comment-37621533-20190104131750

Yeah I always hate it when there's a "You're not ready to hear it" excuse used in stories. It' just frustrating. And I just wanna yell "How could you know that I'm not ready?" at Swan for using that excuse too because .. MC was literally thrown into this magic world and told "You're a wizard Harry and attending Hogwarts now" and adapted to it in a day or so. So Swan knows MC can handle that so maybe, just maybe, MC could also handle being told more of the truth? Especially because if SHE doesn't tell us, we will probably find out things only when it's too late OR good old Raife McEvil will use it to taunt us in a "Oh? So they haven't even told you that much? Some FRIENDS you have there!" kind of way when he inevitably catches us at one point.

And I honestly ask myself the same questions about Swan! I guess maybe MC and Atlas' parents made her their protector? They could have known each other and were friends? Could be just one more thing that Swan doesn't wanna tell us for .. reasons. My question is also: Why didn't SWAN rescue Atlas from the weird .. mirror dimension? If she's there as both of our protector then .. that would be her job? She does have access there through her office and she knew when MC was suddenly in danger and in this mirror dimension (at least if she wasn't lying about it) so .. why couldn't she tell that Atlas was there and hurt and .. go help? I think MC even tells her about seeing "someone that looks like me" in the mirrors so if she knew about Atlas she would know who we're talking about and maybe .. check up on them? That's one of those things we're I'm like .. is this bad writing? Is she just incompetent? Or is there more to it?

If Atlas and/or Swan don't give us at least SOME answers in today's chapter then I might lose my mind. If they'll once again say "You're not ready" or "We've got more important things to do" instead of telling us what's going on then I hope MC can just say "NO! I don't care! Until you give me some answers I'm not doing anything else, so just tell me wtf is going!!" because enough is enough.