Immortal Desires Theory Page

Welcome to the Immortal Desires Theory Page. This is a place where you can discuss confirmed, debunked, and unconfirmed theories from the Immortal Desires series.

Current and Unconfirmed Theories

 * Mentioned in the blog: Given the title, it is believed that this is the untitled supernatural book mentioned in PB's new year blog post. This is weakened in the October 2022 Choices newsletter when "supernatural" is included in a list of future themes.

Confirmed Theories

 * Love triangle: Since players feel that the cover is reminiscent of a Twilight movie poster, players theorized that the book will contain a love triangle. The blog on ID indeed stated that there would be a love triangle.
 * Gabe's family were Vampire Hunters: Given that Cas says that there's more Gabe's story that his/her family was murdered by vampires, it has been theorized that they were vampire hunters and the vampires who killed them were acting in self-defense. This is confirmed in Chapter 4 when Gabe reveals that he/she is descended from vampire hunters.
 * Gabe's allegiance: After Gabe is revealed to be a vampire in Chapter 5, it is believed that he/she is a Clement, which would explain Lewyn meeting him/her at the end of Chapter 4, as well as his/her rivalry with Cas, who is a Venandi. Lewyn confirms in Chapter 6 that Gabe is a member of his coven.
 * Standalone: Given that we are already a senior in high school, it is believed that ID will be a solo book. PB confirmed this on August 24, 2022 on their Instagram page replying to a comment asking if there would be a sequel, citing time allocation and staffing issues.
 * We will become a vampire: It is believed that we could be turned into a vampire at some point in the story. This is strengthened when we express "interest and enthusiasm about the turning ritual" in Chapter 9. This is confirmed at the end of the story, and if all the talismans are collected, the bonus scene reveals that Gabe and Cas turned us to save our life after we defeat the Supreme One.
 * New Coven: After the revelation in Chapter 10 that there are rogue vampires from various different covens, there is a theory that these rogue vampires are trying to form a new coven, and that they are led by and/or worship the Supreme One. This is strengthened by the presence of a third unknown sigil at the scene of the Venandi murders, and confirmed in Chapter 12.

Debunked Theories

 * Love Interests: Players believe that the two characters featured in Choices Insiders March 2022 are among the love interests in this book. This is debunked when it is revealed that Immortal Desires is a high-school story and the love interests are Gabe and Cas instead, and when it is revealed that Astoria and Lewyn are the coven leaders who are much older than the MC.
 * Good VS evil vampires: Given that the Clement coven is friendly towards humans, it is theorized that the Venandi coven consists of bloodthirsty human hunters who delight in feeding on humans, and potentially followers of the Supreme One. This is debunked when both covens joined forces to fight the Supreme One.
 * Our mom will die: Due to the fact that our mother is investigating the murder spree and the coven told us that if we tell anyone about their existence they'll hurt both of us, there is a theory that she'll keep investigating and/or refuse to back down, leading to her being killed either by one of the covens, or by the Supreme One and his vampire. This is debunked as she remains alive and well throughout the book.
 * Libby will be a villain: Some players are suspicious of her, believing that she's too invested in our personal life, and telling us about Gabe's family history of vampire hunting, and that Cas is bad news.
 * Some players are theorizing that she is either a vampire hunter, a vampire from another coven, or an accomplice to the Supreme One. Alternatively, maybe she has a crush on us, and that's why she is worried about us.
 * This is disproven as she remains our friend throughout the book.


 * Lewyn and the Supreme One: Some players have noted that the Supreme One resembles Lewyn, and are theorizing that they are related or even the same person. This gains traction when one of the Supreme One's followers is revealed to be a Clement, but is eventually debunked as Lewyn and the Supreme One are enemies and different people.
 * Morganville inspiration: After the reveal of the Chapter 2 description, some readers of The Morganville Vampires theorize that the vampire lair controls the whole town. This is debunked as nothing of the sort is brought up or mentioned.