Talk:The Elementalists Theory Page/@comment-37621533-20190104205702

I actually thought that we'd get some actual answers in this episode. I'm Boo Boo the Fool :) "Someone powerful inside this school is trying to kill you" Yeah, no sh*t Sherlock, we've known that for 5 episodes now. It's word for word what MC (or was it Shreya?) said after we told all our friends what's going on. I get that they have more episodes to fill and can't reveal everything at once but .. it'd be nice to get some answers and not go around in circles from time to time.

At least I am certain now more than ever that neither Shreya nor Beckett are the traitors. Not that I ever suspected one of them but if my excessive consume of crime shows has taught me anything over the years it's that the people that are suspected and investigated first are hardly ever the actual culprits. If anything I'm more suspicious that we haven't investigated Zeph OR Griffin .. we haven't even talked to or seen them in this episode. Again this could just be PB being unable to focus on that many characters at once but if they wanted to they could have made it work imho.

In any case, I'm not even certain that any of our friends actually is a traitor. I didn't believe it when Atlas first said it and I do't believe it now just because .. it seems so strange that Atlas could make out the bracelet of the person wandering that mirror dimension clear enough to say for certain that it's the one MC and their friends wear but .. they weren't able to make out anything else? Any other feature that could tell us who this person is? But they could make out the tiny little bracelet and identify it as the Pend Pals one? Just seems .. fishy to me. I'm not saying Atlas is evil, it might just be that our twin wants to protect us and is overzealous in doing so. The conversation with Atlas also imply that someone close to Atlas has betrayed them, so they could be projecting that on us and our friends? I honestly think that we will learn that Atlas was wrong and that none of our friends are the person wandering around the mirror dimension. I would laugh extra hard if they pull some kind of Harry Potter (when the person who saves Harry from the Dementors is Harry himself) and the person Atlas is seeing is either MC or Atlas themselves, traveling back in time to change things around or .. something like that.