Murder at Homecoming Choices



This page contains the choices in Murder at Homecoming and their outcomes.

''This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!''

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices
''Content Warning: This book contains depictions of death, substance abuse, and law enforcement that may be disturbing to some. Player discretion is advised.''

Choice 1
 * Body 1
 * Body 2

Choice 2
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 3 (Body 1)
 * Nancy (💎 15)
 * Velma
 * Enola
 * Veronica
 * Daphne

Choice 3 (Body 2)
 * Young Sherlock (💎 15)
 * Hardy
 * Fred
 * Shaggy
 * Jigsaw

Choice 4
 * She/her.
 * He/him.
 * They/them.

Choice 5
 * Great!
 * Let's try again. (Go Back to Choice 1)

Chapter One: Blood In the Water Choices
Choice 1

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Blake".
 * You can call me...

Choice 2
 * Didn't kill anyone! (No effect)
 * Will tell you everything I know! (No effect)

Choice 3
 * You don't wanna ditch the dance? (No effect)
 * You really need my help tonight? (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Roaring Twenties (Body 1) / Classic Glamour (Body 2) (💎 18)
 * Classic Black (Body 1) / Black Basics (Body 2) (No effect)

Choice 5 (Tyler)
 * Face 1
 * Face 2

Choice 6
 * ❤ You're looking fine as always. (❤ +Donovan)
 * What are you doing here? (No effect)

Choice 7
 * But now I really wish I had. (No effect)
 * I had other things to do. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * It'll be my fault, not yours. (No effect)
 * I'll make sure everyone knows who did it. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * I can spare a few minutes. (💎 12)
 * I shouldn't leave the ballot box unattended... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Couldn't agree more. (No effect)
 * Don't think that's true. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * I'm glad we're getting to know each other. (No effect)
 * But we can always talk in the future. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 3
 * Wrapped around a razor blade!

Choice 10
 * Handwriting. (No effect)
 * Ink color. (No effect)
 * Names. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Have you noticed anything weird in your boxes? (No effect)
 * I've got a lot of fake ballots over here. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Why ask questions you already know the answer to? (No effect)
 * Sorry, but that's classified information. (No effect)

"" if you're wearing "Roaring Twenties"/"Classic Glamour".

Choice 13
 * She seemed worried about something. (No effect)
 * I'm sure she's around somewhere. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * No way. Gabbie was totally sober. (No effect)
 * Are you suggesting it was her fault? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * I'll keep that in mind. (No effect)
 * You'd better find out who did this. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * How are you so sure? (No effect)
 * You don't sound sorry at all! (No effect)
 * Did you even listen to my testimony? (No effect)

Choice 17
 * You're wrong. There's no way Gabbie just drowned. (No effect)
 * I know more about 'the real world' than you think. (No effect)

Chapter Two: Keep Your Enemies Close Choices
''Content Warning: This book contains depictions of death, substance abuse, and law enforcement that may be disturbing to some. Player discretion is advised.''

Choice 1
 * Heading to a party. (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * Sneaking off to see your boyfriend. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Kid Detective (Body 1) / Genius Sleuth (Body 2) (💎 20)
 * Everyday Grey (Body 1) / Casual Black (Body 2) (Go to Closet)

Choice 3
 * To investigate the crime scene. (No effect)
 * So I could talk to you. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Smoking on the soccer field. (No effect)
 * Keying cars in the staff parking lot. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * A pocket square?

Choice 6
 * I've gotta get in there! (💎 16)
 * It's way too risky. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, the third option is selected.
 * Hold it in! (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * Stay quiet! (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * Sneeze! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 You get to choose as many as you need to find the correct answer.
 * 09-16-21 (No effect)
 * 03-16-21 (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * 06-19-21 (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 ''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''
 * Tyler's report card. (No effect)
 * A half-finished essay. (No effect)
 * Some college brochures. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Better get a picture.

Diamond Choice 5
 * Leave Tyler a warning. (No effect)
 * Stay out of it. (No effect)

""

Choice 7
 * ❤ It's cute, picturing your domestic side. (❤ +Stevie)
 * Sorry. How's little Sophia doing? (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Surprisingly okay, actually. (No effect)
 * Taking it one day at a time. (No effect)
 * A total mess, honestly. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * For your loss. (No effect)
 * For running into you. (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Didn't realize I was so popular. (No effect)
 * And, yes, I was the one who found the body. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Think back to the day of the funeral. (💎 15)
 * Shrug it off. (Go to Choice 12)

Diamond Choice 6
 * By lying and saying she died? (No effect)
 * But she could still be out there! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * You're grieving right now. That's a kind of sickness. (No effect)
 * Gabbie wouldn't want you wishing to die. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Live up to Perdita. (No effect)
 * Be happy again. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * What if that's what I want to do? (No effect)
 * I don't need forever. I just need more time. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 10
 * You're pretty amazing yourself. (No effect)
 * I guess you're the 'it girl' of Beachwood now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * But they were so cozy at Homecoming! (No effect)
 * They did seem kinda distant at Homecoming. (No effect)

""

Choice 12 (Non-diamond)
 * Gabbie's in a better place now. (No effect)
 * It happens to everyone eventually. (No effect)

Choice 13 You get to choose as many as you need to find the correct answer.
 * The locks. (No effect)
 * The windows. (No effect) ⬅ Correct

Choice 14 You get to choose as many as you need to find the correct answer.
 * A tube of chapstick. (No effect)
 * Dental floss and chewing gum. (No effect)
 * A pencil. (No effect) ⬅ Correct

Chapter Three: Not Alone Choices
Choice 1

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, the second option is selected.
 * Jump! (You die, but restart from this point and repeat this choice)
 * Wait. (No effect)

Choice 2

This is a timed choice. ''If the timer ends, you can't bring yourself to jump. (No effect)''
 * Keep waiting. (No effect)
 * Jump out! (No effect)

Choice 3

This is a timed choice. If the timer ends, the second option is selected.
 * Leap over it! (Path A)
 * Trip over it! (No effect)

Choice 4 (Path A)
 * Stick to the trees! (No effect)
 * Sprint for the opening! (You die, but restart from this point and Tyler catches you before you fall)

Choice 5
 * That she was murdered too? (No effect)
 * It's that easy to gain my trust? (No effect)

Choice 6
 * I can't pass this up. (💎 15)
 * I'll take his word for it. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Suspicious. (No effect)
 * Kinda rude. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * I guess she could be a little intimidating. (No effect)
 * But she was gorgeous! (No effect)
 * ❤ What is your type? (❤ +Tyler)

""

Diamond Choice 3
 * Have dirt on you? (No effect)
 * Ever threaten you? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * You shouldn't have agreed to that. (No effect)
 * Gabbie was being manipulative. (No effect)
 * Your hands were tied. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * That would be great, actually. (No effect)
 * I usually work alone... (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Are you ever going to let me live this down? (No effect)
 * ❤ Backseats can be fun for many reasons. (❤ +Tyler)

Choice 9
 * You had me at diner food. (💎 18)
 * I can't tonight. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * The original cheeseburger and a strawberry milkshake. (No effect)
 * A short stack of chocolate chip pancakes. (No effect)
 * The goat cheese, apple, and candied walnut salad. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * Podcasts. (No effect)
 * Tabletop games. (No effect)
 * Skateboarding. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Am ambidextrous. (No effect)
 * Almost qualified for the National Spelling Bee one year. (No effect)
 * Can speak Portuguese. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Hired me for a case. (No effect, but you tell Tyler about the ballot fraud)
 * Found out I didn't have a group. (No effect, but you don't tell Tyler about the ballot fraud)

Diamond Choice 9
 * It was a mistake, but you're making up for it. (No effect)
 * You were being a good friend. I would've done the same. (No effect)
 * There's no use dwelling on the past. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * Why bring me? (No effect)
 * ❤ Are you saying I'm special? (❤ +Tyler)

Choice 10
 * To check on you. (No effect)
 * To ask you a few questions. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Get over yourselves and focus on Gabbie! (No effect)
 * Consider that maybe everything you know about Tyler is wrong? (No effect)

Choice 12 ''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''
 * Textbooks and binders. (No effect)
 * Pencil case. (Path A)
 * Purse. (No effect)

Choice 13 (Path A)
 * Sounds like a threat... (No effect)

Choice 14
 * Are all pretty caught up in our grief. (No effect)
 * Never should've bothered you. (No effect)
 * Just want to figure out what happened to Gabbie. (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Has a point. (No effect)
 * Is working through it his own way, too. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * Can I stick around and cook some dinner for you? (💎 16)
 * Never mind. Let's head out. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Why won't you talk to me about Gabbie? (No effect)
 * What's your problem with Tyler? (No effect)
 * Did I screw up with you by intruding like this? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12
 * The drugs angle. (No effect)
 * Gabbie. Who was she? (No effect)
 * Any enemies. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 13
 * How fast a swimmer Gabbie was! (No effect)
 * The way we all looked up to Gabbie. (No effect)

"" for finding the note in Gabbie's backpack earlier.

Chapter Four: You've Changed Choices
Choice 1
 * Stevie, enough with the empty threats. (No effect)
 * Tyler, cut the tough guy crap. (No effect)
 * You both need to chill. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * The truth. In your own words. (No effect)
 * You to turn yourself in... before I do. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * It comes with the job. (No effect)
 * ❤ I can't help it. (❤ +Stevie)

Choice 4
 * Fine, you can ask us something. (No effect)
 * We're the ones asking questions. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * I can handle myself. (No effect)
 * ❤ I appreciate you looking out for me. (❤ +Stevie)

Choice 6
 * I do have more questions... (💎 17)
 * I'm not sure what good it'll do. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1 ''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''
 * When and how did the fake ID business start? (No effect)
 * Do you have any idea what she was using the money for? (No effect)
 * Why team up with Gabbie at all? (No effect)
 * How did word of this not get out? (Path A)
 * Are you still selling fake IDs? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Path A)
 * Turned her in. (No effect)
 * Done nothing. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * We all need to stick together. (No effect)
 * This is a serious investigation. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Fine, I think he's cute. Sue me. (No effect)
 * It's all business between us. (No effect)
 * He's not the one I have a crush on. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * Sensible, especially at our age. (No effect)
 * Kind of sad. Why close yourself off? (No effect)
 * ❤ A shame. You're a total catch. (❤ +Stevie)

Choice 10
 * Of course I'll stay! (💎 15)
 * Actually, I should be getting home anyway. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Pretty much amazing. (No effect)
 * No expert, but I do okay. (No effect)
 * Kind of awful, actually. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Cute teddy bear! (No effect)
 * Pretty doll house! (No effect)
 * Fun picture book! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * No fair! (No effect)
 * I think she likes you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * I'm sorry. I had no idea! (No effect)
 * Unplanned doesn't mean unloved. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * They let you babysit Sophia. (No effect)
 * They're paying private school tuition. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * You're always welcome at my place. (No effect)
 * ❤ I promise that I'll always see your worth. (❤ +Stevie)

Choice 11
 * Went to Gabbie's funeral... (No effect)
 * Was pretty busy following leads. (No effect)
 * Am so sorry, I forgot. Rain check? (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Just don't tell anyone else, okay? (No effect)
 * What were you thinking? (No effect)

Choice 13
 * But I do trust Tyler. (No effect)
 * I trust you, Millie. I know your heart's in the right place. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * I want to see what you've got. (💎 16)
 * I don't have time for this. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * This school spares no expense, truly. (No effect)
 * Since when are you so interested in tech? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * That looks like... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * But Tyler wasn't expelled! (No effect)
 * We don't know the context of these. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 12
 * Need him to solve the case! (No effect)
 * Can't just cut ties with him! (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Stevie. (No effect)
 * Tyler. (No effect)

Chapter Five: Bad Boys Choices
Choice 1
 * Right about the cops. (No effect)
 * Too reckless. (No effect)
 * ❤ Cute when you talk crime. (❤ +Stevie)

Choice 2
 * You think I need defending. (No effect)
 * ❤ You're so protective, Tyler. (❤ +Tyler)

Choice 3
 * He even looks like a jerk. (No effect)
 * You guys didn't mention he was hot. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Fake IDs. (No effect)
 * Gabbie. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Don't do it! (No effect)
 * Kick his ass! (No effect)

Choice 6
 * I'm sorry about that. (No effect)
 * Thanks for stepping in. (No effect)
 * We had it handled. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * It's not something I really like to discuss. (No effect)
 * Maybe that's because you don't pay attention. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * Remember Perdita's disappearance. (💎 15)
 * Stay focused on the present. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 1
 * Listen through the door. (No effect)
 * Pretend I need to ask Dita something. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Wasn't! (No effect)
 * Heard it all. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Is right. (No effect)
 * Don't tell Perdita what to do. (No effect)
 * What is it? Maybe I can help! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Know she snuck out last night. (No effect)
 * Don't have any idea. Sorry. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * That doesn't mean they didn't love us. (No effect)
 * I ended up just like her. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * We need those to find my sister! (No effect)
 * You don't have permission to do that! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7
 * Of course I am! (No effect)
 * I thought I was... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * The truth is, it just sucks. (No effect)
 * But sometimes, even painful memories have joy hidden in them. (No effect)
 * ❤ You don't have to face it alone. (❤ +Donovan)

""

Choice 9
 * So you do think we're onto something? (No effect)
 * You'll have to make nice with Tyler first. (No effect)
 * You're a really great brother, you know that? (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Isn't usually like this, I swear! (No effect)
 * Seems to be the Beachwood boys' favorite target. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Defend Tyler and demand some answers! (💎 18)
 * Get Tyler out of here ASAP! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * Where the hell you got that idea from. (No effect)
 * Why you even give a crap. (No effect)
 * If your vocabulary starts and stops at the word 'coward'. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * You shouldn't believe everything you hear. (No effect)
 * My friend Tyler did you a favor. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Valentine Blake Stone. Don't you forget it. (No effect)
 * Not important here. (No effect)
 * ❤ Someone who cares about Tyler. (No effect)

""

Choice 12
 * Good on you for sticking up for yourself. (No effect)
 * You really need to watch your temper. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Maybe this can be a fresh start. (No effect)
 * We need his help to solve this. (No effect)

Choice 14 You get the first option instead of the second if you defended Tyler.
 * You were the reason for the missed track meet. (No effect)
 * It had something to do with track. (No effect)
 * Gabbie had something on you. (No effect)
 * You know more than you're saying about Brett. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 12 (if you collected the clue about the photos in Chapter 5)
 * Pretty funny. (No effect)
 * Kind of mean-spirited. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 13 (if you collected the clue from Tyler's locker in Chapter 3)
 * They weren't that bad. (No effect)
 * Did you ever try tutoring? (No effect)
 * Grades aren't everything. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 14 (if you collected at least 1 premium clue)
 * Really screwed up. (No effect)
 * Got played. (No effect)
 * Weren't at fault here. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 15 (if you collected at least 1 premium clue)
 * You made a mistake. (No effect)
 * You're making up for it. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 16 (if you collected at least 1 premium clue)
 * Hug Tyler. (No effect)
 * ❤ Kiss him! (❤ +Tyler)

Choice 15 (if you didn't collect enough premium clues)
 * She shouldn't have held that over you. (No effect)
 * You've made a lot of mistakes... (No effect)

""

Choice 16
 * Nope. You can take it. (No effect)
 * Yeah, It's for my invisible friend Pablo. (No effect)
 * ❤ It is now. By you. (❤ +Donovan)

Choice 17
 * That would be amazing! (No effect)
 * Are you sure you're okay with that? (No effect)

Choice 18
 * I'd love to go. (💎 19)
 * If I didn't have a mountain of studying... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 17
 * I'm sure it means a lot that you're trying. (No effect)
 * Consider yourselves lucky. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 18
 * 'Gone'. (No effect)
 * 'The Best of You and Me'. (No effect)
 * 'Secret Admirer'. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 19
 * Know that we all miss you. (No effect)
 * I wish I could've known you better. (No effect)
 * I promise, we're going to avenge you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 20
 * Incredible! And I'm not just saying that. (No effect)
 * Not my usual thing, but I actually enjoyed it a lot. (No effect)
 * ❤ Great. You're quite the frontman. (❤ +Donovan)

Diamond Choice 21
 * I like having just a couple good friends too. (No effect)
 * And am I one of your friends? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 22
 * Pop. (No effect)
 * Alternative. (No effect)
 * Lofi, dreamcore, that kinda thing. (No effect)

Chapter Six: Behind Closed Doors Choices
Choice 1
 * Donovan, leave Tyler alone.
 * Tyler, take a deep breath.
 * Stevie and I are in charge here.

Choice 2
 * Is how she never got caught.
 * Just means we have to work harder.

Diamond Choice 1
 * I thought you were mad at me too
 * I figured you'd be too busy

Diamond Choice 2
 * totally unrelated
 * about gabbie, yeah

Diamond Choice 3
 * Was written for someone else.
 * Wasn't what she wanted.

Diamond Choice 4
 * I'm sure there's more to the story.
 * We can't rule it out.

""

Choice 3
 * Her boyfriend?
 * A client of yours?

Choice 4
 * The only lead we've got.
 * Our new prime suspect.

Choice 5 ''You get to choose all of them. This just determines the order.''
 * The dresser.
 * The closet.
 * The bookshelf.

Choice 6 (Dresser)
 * A romantic gift?

Choice 7 (Dresser)
 * If someone loves you, they'll love whatever you pick out.
 * ❤ You're a catch. You don't need to buy anyone's love. (❤ +Tyler)

""

Choice 8 (Closet)
 * I'm sorry. This must be harder for you than any of us.
 * Where else was she gonna store them? Some secret lab?

Choice 9 (Bookshelf)
 * January 1 and count up.
 * December 31 and count down.
 * Gabbie's birthday.

Choice 10 (Bookshelf)
 * Looks like a ledger of sales.

Choice 11 (Bookshelf)
 * These records wouldn't go back so far.
 * Why not join up with Brett and eliminate you?

Choice 12
 * Leave no stone unturned. (💎 18)
 * Should leave it alone.

Diamond Choice 5
 * Why are these hidden?

Diamond Choice 6
 * Were you really part of that crowd?
 * What caused you to stop hanging out?

Diamond Choice 7
 * Why didn't you come to me?
 * ❤ I hope you'll learn to trust again someday. (❤ +Stevie)

""

Choice 13
 * Treat each other with respect.
 * Get over ourselves and do the work.

Choice 14
 * Go to trivia! (💎 20)
 * Get some rest.

Diamond Choice 8

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "The Scoobies".
 * Let's call ourselves...

Diamond Choice 9
 * Houston
 * Dallas
 * Austin ⬅ Correct

Diamond Choice 10
 * Panda Bear
 * Polar Bear ⬅ Correct
 * Koala Bear

Diamond Choice 11

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. The correct answer is "luminol".
 * The answer is...

Diamond Choice 12 (if you got all 3 right)
 * Delicious and creamy!

Diamond Choice 12 (if you didn't get all 3 right)
 * Mmm, chocolate.

Diamond Choice 13
 * Tyler.
 * Stevie.
 * Donovan.

Diamond Choice 14 (Tyler)
 * You're plenty smart. You're just a different kind of smart.
 * Smarts aren't everything, you know.

Diamond Choice 15 (Tyler)
 * Pull back.
 * ❤ Kiss Tyler. (❤ +Tyler)

Diamond Choice 14 (Stevie)
 * Not under normal circumstances.
 * Yes.

Diamond Choice 15 (Stevie)
 * Of course not. I was just messing with you.
 * ❤ (Kiss her.) (❤ +Stevie)

Diamond Choice 14 (Donovan)
 * Yeah. I can't stand not knowing things.
 * Not really. I just want to help other people.

Diamond Choice 15 (Donovan)
 * You're very brave.
 * ❤ (Take his hand.) (❤ +Donovan)

Diamond Choice 16 (Donovan)
 * ❤ Meet his kiss. (❤ +Donovan)
 * Hug him.