First Comes Love Theory Page

Welcome to the First Comes Love Theory Page. This is a place where you can discuss confirmed, debunked, and unconfirmed theories from the First Comes Love series.

Current & Unconfirmed Theories

 * Plot of whole series: The first part of this story might revolve around us and Blake falling in love, followed by getting married to him/her, and finally, having or adopting a baby with Blake. This seems to be strengthened in the March 2023 newsletter when emojis seem to include all 3 of these events.
 * Eve and Rebecca: Some players theorize that if or when Rebecca ends up breaking up with Blake, there might be a choice to matchmake Eve and Rebecca as a couple. This is supported by their friendship, and from how Eve supports Rebecca in Chapter 2.

Confirmed Theories

 * Single-LI: Like recent books, this book might have a single love interest. This seems to be strengthened by Chapter 1's summary, and eventually confirmed at the very start of the Book.
 * Rival: Like Cassandra with Mr. Covington in Baby Bump, Book 1, we might compete with another woman for Blake's attention. This seems to be strengthened by Chapter 2's summary and by this book's "Rivalry" tag, and eventually confirmed with Rebecca who's Blake's girlfriend.
 * Standalone: Since the emojis teased for the book seem to indicate one book, it might be likely that this will be a standalone. This is confirmed when PB announced that Chapter 20 will be the series finale.

Debunked Theories

 * New Flirt/Fling for MC: Based on the summaries of Chapter 8 and 9, some players theorize that we will get to meet a new character and start flirting with them or date them, in order to make Blake jealous. This is strengthened with Sky's appearance in Chapter 8, but eventually debunked since nothing happens between us and Sky other than a couple of flirt instances.
 * If that's the case, it's also possible that said new character and Rebecca to start liking each other, and by the end of the Book realizing that the two of them are more compatible together than with us and Blake. This is debunked as Sky exits the story.
 * Fight with Blake and/or Rebecca: Given our behaviour towards Rebecca, many players theorize that our feelings for Blake will eventually come out abruptly, and we will have a fight with them for trying to break up their relationship. This is debunked, as no such fight happens, and Blake and Rebecca break-up peacefully, and the latter at first decides to leave, before changing her mind.