User blog comment:StoryGirl83/Starting a Second or Later Book While Replaying the First Book/@comment-31546695-20171204002452/@comment-3452092-20171204005406

Interesting. I wonder if this is a new thing. . . no wait. You said you hadn't finished book three at all? That's probably the difference. I am on my second playthrough of Endless Summer Book 1. I've already finished it once and wanted to do a second playthrough where I picked up a bunch of diamond options, but I definitely had a completed book 1 for them to look at. It's just it wasn't from my current playthough, but instead from my first playthrough.