Thread:Jadelady/@comment-38677784-20200210234645/@comment-37484301-20200211000729

If you've read the entire message, she added 30 quotes to Adam Vega's page under "Memorable Quotes". I was trying to explain that "Memorable Quotes" usually refers to a handful of quotes - maybe 5? not more than 10? the number is arbitrary but basically "memorable" to the character. A lot of dialogue that is taken from a character in a story is used to add to their Personality and Relationship sections. If a character says "keep away from her!" to another character, we infer that the first character is protective of the second; we don't need the actual dialogue because honestly, the dialogue is generic and not character-specific and can be / has been used in a variety of books.

What is "memorable" to her is not "unique" to the character and not "memorable" to a majority of readers. Yes - "memorable" is subjective, but she did not want to take the criticism. She appeared that she wanted all 30 quotes to be on his page and not incorporated into the Personality and Relationship sections which is what is usually done. For example, Adam says "I have no love for humans." That can be incorporated into his Personality Section under: Adam has no love for humans. There is no reason it needs to be "quoted" as dialogue. If you look at a lot of character pages, what we get as "information" for the personality, background, and relationship sections comes from a lot of dialogue that is spoken between characters. We don't put them just as "dialogue" or a transcript of the story.

The reason she is blocked is because she was viewed as being rude to me, MondlichtPanda, and JessieJJD13. If she wants to explain why she chose those 30 quotations, she can. She chose not to and instead said "If I looked at a character I don't care about and their quotes, do you think I would think of any of them as memorable? No. And if you confuse perfectionism and the passion for expanding a page to its greatest potential with a "shrine", I'm sorry for you."