User blog comment:HersheysAlmonds/High School Story FanFic Ideas/@comment-36606206-20181006010438

I think you should let the readers choose who's route. Because example, if Michael wins, people who chose him will be happy but not the people who chose the other 4. Thus, making people who did not choose Michael as their LI will not read your fanfic.

Maybe you should do some routes, like "If you pick Caleb/Emma/Maria/Aiden/Michael, you get bonus scenes" and bonus scene there and here.