Talk:The Elementalists Theory Page/@comment-37621533-20181230215811

I can't be the only one here who really REALLY doesn't trust Prof. Swan, right? Like .. I tried with her and tried to see past her creepily watching us from the shadows at the start of the book. I tried to think that she's just one of those .. kooky mentor archetypes that are popular in the fantasy genre. But I just .. can't do it and with every new chapter I trust her less and less and I think she just ACTS this quirky and incompetent to mask her true intentions. And maybe it's because I /just/ finished playing through Veil of Secrets but yeah .. I think she's just pulling a Duffy on us, lmao.

I think I started to actually mistrust her when she did that truth spell on the MC if we choose to not tell her to truth about having looked into the shadow monsters and all that. Like that right there made me go .. hmmm. And then she just happens to always show up right on time to save/help the MC. Except in the fight with the huge monster in the last chapter where she conveniently disappeared and stayed gone during the entire fight but then popped back up right when the fight was ending. (And also .. we saw Raife watching us and then as soon as he was gone SHE was back again with no explanation as to how .. hmmmmm. Much coincidence. Wow!) She also just so happens to have one of the three entryways to the weird mirror world of the whole school. Why does she have that? WHO KNOWS! And then of course the fact that she is only feeding us bits and pieces of information, just enough to make us wanna go investigate - like what else does she expect the MC to do when she only gives out those tiny bits of information? She could very well do it on purpose to MAKE us go look for more information and with that make the MC reveal themselves to Raife and oh, almost get killed on a daily basis. I just .. don't buy her "I didn't tell you everything because I thought it would be too much and I wanted to protect you" spiel. If she wanted the MC to be save she would have told them everything and then helped them deal with it and not .. withhold information that almost got us killed several times.

So yeah, I'm not saying she's evil and working with Raife but .. at the very least she has some hidden agenda and I do not trust her. At all. If one of our friends is really working against us or hiding something from us, I bet SHE is involved as well.