Untameable Theory Page

Welcome to the Untameable Theory Page. This is a place where you can discuss confirmed, debunked, and unconfirmed theories from the Untameable series.

Current & Unconfirmed Theories

 * Crossover with Big Sky Country in Book 2: The Oakley family might show up in guest appearances.
 * Mandy will return in Book 2: The summary for Book 2, Chapter 2 mentions the MC ends up on the Martinez ranch, which leads players to believe Mandy will return.
 * Single-LI: It is believed Book 2 will be a single-LI book like Book 1, and the LI will most likely be one of Mandy's siblings, as the summary for Book 2, Chapter 2 mentions the MC ends up on the Martinez ranch.

Confirmed Theories

 * Romance: It is confirmed that this is a Western romantic drama.
 * NC-17: Due to the recent surge in mature-tagged stories, it is believed this story will be mature as well. This is confirmed when the book cover is revealed.
 * Single Love Interest: Due to the recent surge in single love interest stories, it is believed this story will have one love interest as well. PB confirmed this in a blogpost on February 24, 2022.
 * Matchmaking Austin and Mandy: In Chapter 12, both Austin and Mandy seem flustered when they are around each other, which makes people believe that they have a crush on each other, and that in future chapters, we could encourage their relationship and set them up together. This is confirmed in Chapter 14, where there is a premium scene in which we can set them up together.

Debunked Theories

 * Love triangle relationship: Given that Kit fights his/her feelings towards the MC because of Austin, players believe that he/she and Austin are more than friends, and that Austin has feelings for him/her and/or vice-versa, resulting in a love triangle between the MC, Austin and Kit. However, this is debunked as it is clear that Kit only has feelings for the MC, and Austin has feelings only for Mandy (As it is proven from the premium scene in Chapter 14 where we can matchmake them together).
 * Horses: The Choices Insiders newsletter for December 2021 features two emojis, one depicting a horse and the other depicting a cowboy. Players believe the story will focus on taming a horse long thought untameable.
 * Rodeo: Tying with the theory on horses is that the book will focus on rodeo, as a pre-release sneak peek shows a poster advertising a rodeo. Both of these theories are debunked by the end of Book 1, given that the story was entirely different.
 * Playing as Austin and/or Mandy in Book 2: Given that the message at the end of Book 1 says that Book 2 will feature a new but familiar couple hoping to find love, many players suspect that we will no longer be playing as the MC and Kit, but instead, as Austin and/or Mandy. Social media posts on May 4, 2023 disproved this when it is revealed that Book 2 will be a GOC book.