User blog comment:StoryGirl83/Elemental Attundement in the Test for "The Elementalists"/@comment-28520869-20181112070429/@comment-28520869-20181112103115

5) aiming for a tie between fire/metal (with a fallback of 5 elements). Result: tie between fire and metal.

working in a group: take the lead (fire, metal) dragon hoard: dragons scales (fire, water?) (metal?) potion: mercurial (earth, metal?) live anywhere: coral city (water) pixies: rush in (fire, air) magickal creature: dragon (earth, air)

fire - 1 (2) (3), metal - (2) (3), water - 1 (2), earth - (2), air - (2)

so its highly likely that fire is 3 and metal is 3 is correct. so take the lead is fire and metal, the dragon scales is fire, metal and mercurial potion is metal, earth (not metal, fire)

and if dragon scales is fire, metal then my previous playthrough where I got a tie between fire and water, water should be either trick the sphinx, back the way I came or No, I will live this life to the fullest.

and that means the playthrough above, I probably got 4 metals (answer my own riddle, dragons scale, city with vampires, winter) and fire could probably be 3 and water was 2.