Talk:The Elementalists Theory Page/@comment-37723194-20190511091955

So I’m a little lost and confused about whether the evil one is Kane or Alma.

Can I hear some of your thoughts on these two characters?

Because in all honesty, I think both of them are a little off, but each one believes they’re on the right, and the other is on the wrong.

Yeah, Gemma and Theia/mom buried Kane for thousands of years, and he killed that one hiker trying to help him at the end of Book 1, if I remember correctly. And yeah he’s really sketchy and his goons totally attacked MC at the tea party and he let it happen anyway, but only after Alma got there. He also said he doesn’t really want to kill mom, and mom seems to have confided a lot in him and visited him while he was underground. Then again, Julius Caesar, Alexander the Great, Sun Tzu, if they’re his friends and he thought they were worth mentioning, his whole thing probably is about warfare and conquest.

But I think Alma is hiding our mom somewhere! Gemma too! I mean, look at the clearly blood-att imprisonment on Gemma, yet Alma can’t locate her, even though she can locate/sense blood magic? Raife is a blood att, so is your blood magic GPS broken or something? And really, I just find her whole attitude towards “mortals” off-putting. But she did come after Kane in the book series, so maybe she is trying to save the world from Kane. But then why is PB letting me romance Kane then?!

Right now, I’m leaning towards: I think both of them are evil and have their own agenda, but they both think they are good.

I feel like I want to know how Swan feels about them both first. I don’t think she ever got to tell us.

Please feel free to chime in with your thoughts. Thanks!