Talk:Desire & Decorum, Book 1 Choices/@comment-27818075-20181106073219/@comment-36836718-20181106161910

If you had all manners points you should have gotten the jewels. I didn't spend diamonds on parlor items or dresses. The achievement text says it's because of the manners.

PB sometimes likes to show what could have been to make us replay a chapter or the whole book. But I agree that they could have done it better than the way you described.