Talk:The Elementalists Theory Page/@comment-3452092-20190104233658/@comment-3452092-20190105000804

That was more or less what I said, although I think you mean trying to trick us into believing they aren't guilty when they are by making them look too guilty. I've not really seen any evidence from Pixelberry that they either can or are willing to think they deviously. They can plant hints, but if they say to look out for something and then, "Oh, look, there it is," they are pretty consistantly throwing red herrings at us, so if you mean are they trying to trick us into thinking they aren't guilty when they are, I don't think so. I think they are trying, badly, to convince us that they are guilty when they aren't. Also, there is no reason to believe that multiple of our friends are guilty. There is maybe evidence to believe that one of them is guilty, but not that multiple and it's still possible that all of them are innocent. Beckett and Shreya, however, are out of the running. They didn't do it. Or at the very least, they aren't working with Raife. It is possible, though after this chapter less likely, that Beckett was the one in there, but for innocent reasons. Shreya definitely wasn't in there. And this chapter kind of made it less likely that Zeph is involved as well since apparently he's not a great student, so he would be unlikely to be able to do the spells needed.