With Every Heartbeat Choices



This page contains the choices in With Every Heartbeat and their outcomes.

''This game revolves around the choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make the right choice for their game. Good luck and happy playing!''

Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet, please help this page by contributing those answers!

Setup Choices
Choice 1
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 2
 * Halcyon Half-Up (💎 15)
 * Straight With Bangs
 * Glossy Curls
 * Simple Blonde

Choice 3
 * Great! I love it!
 * Let's try something else.

Choice 4

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Sage"
 * Enter your character's first name:

Choice 5

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Woods"
 * Enter your character's last name:

Choice 6
 * Boyfriend.
 * Girlfriend.

Chapter One: The New Kid Choices
Choice 1
 * First Impressions (💎 12)
 * The Usual

Choice 2
 * Dominate this school year.
 * Get this over with. (No effect)
 * Fall in love... (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 4
 * Whoops, sorry! (No effect)
 * I'm not moving until I get this guy's number. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * How did you know? (No effect)
 * You must be the class flirt. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * So far, it's been pretty typical. (No effect)
 * I've already met some serious hotties. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * I bleed school colors. (No effect)
 * Not even a little bit. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * I'm looking forward to getting to know all of you! (No effect)
 * I'm the new kid. Obviously. (No effect)
 * There's no point in even getting to know me. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * Why would he do that? (No effect)
 * Do you think he likes me? (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Did you just cut in line? (No effect)
 * Are you following me? (No effect)
 * Running into you this much is starting to feel like fate. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * A double-double burger. (No effect)
 * A garden salad. (No effect)
 * One of those famous milkshakes. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Thanks, you're a lifesaver! (No effect)
 * Eh, I'm sure Amy found us seats. (No effect)
 * Only if I get the seat next to yours. (No effect)

Choice 13
 * It was... interesting. (No effect)
 * You owe it success to the star... me! (No effect)
 * I'd have liked it better if I weren't in it. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * That's one word to describe it... (No effect)

""

Choice 15
 * I'm gonna have to start calling you my knight in shining armor. (No effect)
 * I don't want to impose. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * If you insist. (No effect)
 * But only if I pay next time. (No effect)

Choice 17
 * Return the puppy with Dakota. (💎 18)
 * Walk back alone.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Take his hand. (No effect)
 * Lead the way yourself. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Slow down, we just met! (No effect)
 * Are you always like this? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * To find true love. (No effect)
 * To be a success. (No effect)
 * To never have a stranger ask me such a personal question ever again. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Brave. (No effect)
 * Confident. (No effect)
 * Reckless. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * A leader. (No effect)
 * A creative. (No effect)
 * ...I honestly have no idea. (No effect)

""

Chapter Two: Hope Springs Choices
Choice 1
 * Not long. (No effect)
 * Long enough to hear you fighting with your dad. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * What's the most embarrassing thing that ever happened to you? (No effect)
 * What's the worst thing you've ever done? (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Yeah, I'm impressed. (No effect)
 * No way. I was clearly too easy on you! (No effect)

Choice 4
 * I got a ride from a friend. (No effect)
 * This guy I met gave me a ride. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * #EmpathyAtEdenbrook. (No effect)
 * #WorldClassCaring. (No effect)
 * #StateOfTheHeart. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Why are you guys filming? (No effect)
 * Could I be in the presence of a famous orin-- whatever? (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Direct Dakota toward Gracie. (No effect)
 * Direct him away from her. (No effect)

Choice 8
 * It's nice of you to play with her like that. (No effect)
 * You're way too committed to this whole thing. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * I'm so sorry. (No effect)
 * And none of the fun stories! (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Groan-worthy, I guess? (No effect)

Choice 11
 * Join the pudding heist to cheer up the kids! (💎 16)
 * Head home instead.

Diamond Choice 1

This is a timed choice.


 * Run! ⬅ Correct (No effect)
 * Trip! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Behind the juice bottles. (No effect)
 * Near the fruit platter. (No effect)
 * In front of the cherry jars. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Eureka! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4

''This is a timed choice.


 * Fake left! ⬅ Correct (No effect)
 * Fake right! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * Lean in... (No effect)
 * Check to see if the coast is clear. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 6
 * To the heist! (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Go save some lives! (No effect)
 * Seriously? (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Eavesdrop! (No effect)
 * Let them know I'm here. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * I need a favor! (No effect)
 * I couldn't resist Mateo's charms! (No effect)

Choice 15
 * I get this feeling you've been keeping something from me. (No effect)
 * I overheard you and Mateo talking just now. (No effect)

Choice 16
 * Go to the vista with Dakota. (💎 16)
 * Head inside.

Diamond Choice 7
 * That's a pretty strong reaction to moving to a new city. (No effect)
 * I can see how this view would make you feel more at home. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8
 * Hug him. (No effect)
 * Wait for him to continue. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * Is that how you met Mateo? At the hospital? (No effect)
 * I can see why you were nervous about telling me. (No effect)
 * So that's why you knew so many people at Edenbrook. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * Only if you promise not to fall in love with me! (No effect)
 * No promises. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Mateo's cancer to go into remission. (No effect)
 * The best kiss of my life. (No effect)
 * Lots and lots of money. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 12
 * Lean in for a kiss. (No effect)
 * Give him a hug. (No effect)

Choice 17

This choice only appears if you did not spend diamonds to go to the vista with Dakota.


 * Kind of full of yourself, aren't you? (No effect)
 * That's a shame to hear. (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Coming soon... (No effect)

Chapter Three: Just Friends Choices
Choice 1
 * What's wrong with Dakota? (No effect)
 * What's your problem? (No effect)

Choice 2
 * I appreciate the concern. (No effect)
 * Are you speaking from experience or something? (No effect)

Choice 3
 * I was just trying to convince Amy to go. (No effect)
 * I don't know much about it. (No effect)

Choice 4
 * You think he's into me? (No effect)
 * Dakota and I are just friends. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Encourage Amy to go to the carnival with Heather! (💎 15)
 * Let Amy study on Saturday night.

Diamond Choice 1
 * A well-rounded high school experience. (No effect)
 * A date, you idiot! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Do you have anything to say to that, Amy? (No effect)
 * Or you guys could just go together! (No effect)

""

Choice 6
 * I didn't want to presume anything. (No effect)
 * But you're right, you're basically my chauffeur. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Anything for Mateo. (No effect)
 * You sure you're not the one who wants to hang out with me? (No effect)

Choice 8
 * They're impressed by me? (No effect)
 * Do you have proof? (No effect)

Choice 9
 * An awesome opportunity! (No effect)
 * You're just asking me because I'm not afraid of technology. (No effect)

Choice 10

This is a timed choice.


 * Jump out of the way! (No effect)
 * Cheer them on! (No effect)

If the timer runs out, you stand there frozen but jump out of the way in time. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * It's nice to finally meet you. (No effect)
 * You're even ruder in person. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Join the wheelchair race! (💎 18)
 * Spectate instead.

Diamond Choice 3 Diamond Choice 4
 * Dakota (No effect)
 * Mateo (No effect)

This is a timed choice.


 * Turn right! (-RACE) (No effect)
 * Turn left! (+RACE) (No effect)

If the timer ends, you turn in the wrong direction and get -RACE. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5

This is a timed choice.


 * Speed up! (+RACE) (No effect)
 * Slow down! (-RACE) (No effect)

If the timer ends, you get distracted and get -RACE. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * We're mixing metaphors, but who cares? (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 7
 * A high five. (No effect)
 * A fist bump. (No effect)
 * An impromptu secret handshake! (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Really cool! (No effect)
 * Seriously hard. (No effect)

Choice 14
 * Should you guys be joking about that? (No effect)
 * Did it suddenly just get morbid in here or is it just me? (No effect)

Choice 15
 * You looking like a total dork. (No effect)
 * An amateur filmmaker... slash gymnast? (No effect)

Choice 16
 * I think it's cool you have a hero! (No effect)
 * Which movie is Retribution again? (No effect)
 * Isn't horror kind of a trashy genre? (No effect)

Choice 17
 * I don't have any experience... (No effect)
 * I get stage fright! (No effect)
 * I'm so good I might distract the admissions board. (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Location scout with Dakota. (💎 19)
 * Just go home.

Diamond Choice 8
 * She's in love with you. (No effect)
 * She's very different from you and Mateo. (No effect)
 * She already hates me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9
 * All the great work the hospital does! (No effect)
 * The realities of hospital life... the highs and lows. (No effect)
 * The dire situation the people we help are in. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10
 * Patients. (No effect)
 * Doctors. (No effect)
 * Staff. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 11
 * I love them! (No effect)
 * They're okay. (No effect)
 * They're too scary for me. (No effect)

""

Choice 19

This choice is the same as Diamond Choice 8 in the previous diamond scene, and will not appear again if you bought the diamond scene.


 * She's in love with you. (No effect)
 * She's very different from you and Mateo. (No effect)
 * She already hates me. (No effect)

Choice 20

This choice only appears if you did NOT spend diamonds to go to the vista with Dakota in the previous chapter.


 * Hug him. (No effect)
 * Wait for him to continue. (No effect)

Chapter Four: Falling Choices
Choice 1
 * It must've been hidden here for months. (No effect)

Choice 2
 * He actually spends a lot of time at the hospital. (No effect)
 * I've already told you everything you need to know about Dakota. (No effect)

Choice 3
 * Pumpkin Spice (💎 25)
 * No thanks

Choice 4
 * It's kind of magical! (No effect)
 * I'm glad I get to explore it with you. (No effect)

The following Diamond Choices 1-3 only appear if you spent diamonds to encourage Amy and Heather in the previous chapter.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Romantic! (No effect)
 * Bumpy. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * How did you and Amy first meet? (No effect)
 * Did you know Amy's up for valedictorian? (No effect)
 * Why did you join AV Club? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Grab Dakota! (No effect)
 * Grab Amy! (No effect)

""

Choice 5
 * Why not? (No effect)
 * Who are you close with, then? (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Twirl! (No effect)
 * Flip him the bird. (No effect)
 * Blow him a kiss. (No effect)

Choice 7
 * Carve pumpkins!
 * Bob for apples!
 * Enter the pie eating contest!

''You get to pick all of them. This just determines the order.''

Choice 8 (Pumpkin carving)
 * A vampire! (No effect)
 * Frankenstein's monster! (No effect)
 * A cat! (No effect)

Choice 9 (Apple bobbing)

This is a timed choice.


 * The apple ⬅ Correct (No effect)
 * A... keychain? (No effect)
 * Some leaves (No effect)

Choice 10 (Pie eating contest)

This is a timed choice.


 * Eat faster! ⬅ Correct (No effect)
 * Slow down! (No effect)

If the timer ends, you can't keep up. (No effect)

Choice 11
 * The sweetest prize of all. (No effect)

Choice 12
 * Are you okay? (No effect)
 * Am I boring you? (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Climb the tower with Dakota! (💎 20)
 * Go home.

Diamond Choice 3
 * It's breathtaking.
 * You've got a thing for heights, don't you?

Diamond Choice 4
 * Really fun.
 * A bit too cheesy.
 * Nice spending time with you.

Diamond Choice 5
 * I feel exactly the same way.
 * It took you long enough!

Diamond Choice 6
 * Kiss him.
 * Snuggle with him.

""

The following Choices 14-15 only appear if you did NOT spend diamonds to climb the tower with Dakota.

Choice 14
 * But why not? (No effect)
 * Fine. I don't want to be your friend either. (No effect)

Choice 15
 * Tell him I feel the same way. (No effect)
 * Kiss him already! (No effect)