America's Most Eligible: All Stars Choices

This page contains the choices in America's Most Eligible: All Stars and their outcomes.

''This game revolves heavily around choices you make. They can improve or decrease relationships with the characters. This walkthrough is made to assist others in helping them make their right choice for the game. Good luck and happy playing!''

'''Choices that have no outcome on the side have not been explored yet. Please help this page by contributing those answers!'''

Setup Choices
Choice 1
 * Import now!
 * Play without importing. (Go to Choice 3)

Choice 2
 * Yes, I'd like to change my face. (Go to Choice 4)
 * No, I'll stick with my current face. (Go to Choice 5)

Choice 3
 * Female.
 * Male.

Choice 4 (Female)
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 4 (Male)
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3
 * Face 4

Choice 5 (Female)
 * Lapiz Lazuli (💎15)
 * Rose Gold (💎15)
 * Curly Bun
 * Long Curls
 * Short Blonde
 * Medium Straight
 * Sleek and Smooth

Choice 5 (Male)
 * Violet Crush (💎15)
 * Luscious Locks (💎15)
 * Short Black
 * Medium Blond
 * Cropped Brown
 * Tousled Red

Choice 6 (Female)
 * Flirty Floral (💎20)
 * Bird of Paradise (if you purchased it in Book 1)
 * Sweater n' Shorts
 * Bold in Blue Green
 * Pretty in Pink

Choice 6 (Male)
 * Plaid to the Bone (💎20)
 * Seafoam Stripes
 * Old Staple
 * Miami Casual

Choice 7
 * This look is perfect!
 * Let's try something else. (Go back to Choice 4)
 * I want to change my gender. (Go back to Choice 3)

Choice 8
 * Yes, I'd like to rename Jamie.
 * No, I'll keep my current name. (Go to Choice 10)

Choice 9

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Jamie"
 * Enter your name:

Choice 10
 * Yes, continue with this look. (Go to Choice 12)
 * No, I'd like to choose a new look.

Choice 11
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3

Choice 12
 * Yes, his name is Adam. (Go to Choice 14)
 * No, he has another name.

Choice 13

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Adam"
 * Enter the name of the Bad Boy:

Choice 14
 * Yes, continue with this look. (Go to Choice 16)
 * No, I'd like to choose a new look.

Choice 15
 * Face 1
 * Face 2
 * Face 3

Choice 16
 * Yes, her name is Mackenzie. (Skips Choice 17)
 * No, she has another name.

Choice 17

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice. Default is "Mackenzie"
 * Enter the name of the Tough Girl:

Chapter One: Baby, You're a Star Choices
Choice 1
 * Handsome Stranger (No effect)
 * Beautiful Contestant (No effect)
 * Derek (No effect)
 * Bianca (No effect)

Choice 2
 * Blow a kiss to your fans! (😘 +Flirt)
 * Wave cheerfully! (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * Give 'em the cold shoulder! (😈 +Villain)

Choice 3
 * Is everything okay? (No effect)
 * Have you seen Jen? (No effect)

Choice 4
 * Single? (Slater +2)
 * A new contestant? (Slater +2)

Choice 5
 * I've missed you so much! (No effect)
 * You're as gorgeous as ever. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * I totally agree! (No effect)
 * I'd rather keep my old one. (Skips Choice 7)

Choice 7

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
 * Default is "Leader!"

""

Choice 8
 * I missed the cast and crew! (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * My adoring public needs me! (😘 +Flirt)
 * This show would suck without me. (😈 +Villain)

Choice 9
 * Hook up with every contestant! (😘 +Flirt)
 * Sabotage my way to the top! (😈 +Villain)
 * Form meaningful friendships! (❤ +Sweetheart)

Choice 10
 * You're gonna love to hate me. (😈 +Villain)
 * I'll make you all proud! (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * You'll be head over heels for me. (😘 +Flirt)

"" if got at least 2 ❤ +Sweetheart.

"" if got at least 2 😘 +Flirt.

"" if you got at least 2 😈 +Villain.

"" if you got one of each answer.

Choice 11
 * Catch up with Jen! (💎12)
 * Stay in the mansion.

Diamond Choice 1
 * I've missed you like crazy. (No effect)
 * I have a good feeling about this season. (No effect)
 * Things were pretty tense on set. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2
 * I'll do anything I can to help. (No effect)
 * You'll make this season great. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Carson bit off more than he can chew. (No effect)
 * You've got it under control! (No effect)
 * You could use a hug. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4
 * Was a horrible showrunner. (No effect)
 * Was just doing her job. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5
 * A welcome back kiss! (No effect)
 * Some tips for this season. (No effect)

""

Choice 12
 * I can live with that. (No effect)
 * I didn't sign up for this! (No effect)

Choice 13
 * Heath needs to apologize! (Eden +2, Heath -2)
 * Eden needs to relax! (Heath +2, Eden -2)
 * You're both being babies! (Eden -2, Heath -2)

Choice 14
 * Yeah, kind of. (Eden -2)
 * I wouldn't say that. (Eden +2)

Choice 15
 * Buy this item! (💎20)
 * No thanks. (No effect)

This item is called "Striking Sage" if you are a male and "Fuchsia Beauty" if you are a female.

Eden +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 16
 * It's good to see you! (Eden +2)
 * Why aren't you helping the crew? (Eden -2)
 * Congrats on the promotion, snake. (Eden +2)

Beautiful Contestant +2, Derek +2, Bianca +3 and Handsome Stranger +2 if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 17
 * A group hug! (Bianca +2, Derek +2) (Skips Choice 18)
 * A kiss hello! (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Handsome Stranger (Handsome Stranger +2)
 * Beautiful Contestant (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Derek (Derek +2)
 * Bianca (Bianca +2)

Choice 19
 * Play strip Truth or Dare. (Bianca +2, Heath +2, Eden -2)
 * Make it a drinking game! (Beautiful Contestant +2, Eden +2, Heath -2)

Choice 20
 * Is Slater, Eden, or Heath the hottest? (Slater +2, Eden +2, Heath -2)
 * What do you think about Carson as showrunner? (Handsome Stranger +2, Derek +2, Eden -2, Heath +2)

Choice 21
 * The Confessional room! (Derek -2, Heath +2)
 * The study! (Derek +2, Eden +2, Beautiful Contestant -2)

Choice 22

This is a fill-in-the-blank choice.
 * Default is "Derek was here!"

Choice 23
 * Catch up with Handsome Stranger! (💎12)
 * Catch up with Beautiful Contestant! (💎12)
 * Catch up with Derek! (💎12)
 * Catch up with Bianca! (💎12)
 * Wait for filming to start.

You can do all paths as long as you have enough diamonds.

Diamond Choice 6 (Handsome Stranger)
 * My kind of summer. (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * You need some human contact. (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 7 (Handsome Stranger)
 * You had so much fun. (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * You missed me so much! (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 8 (Handsome Stranger)
 * We can spend more time together. (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * You can actually relax for once. (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 9 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Kiss Handsome Stranger! (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * Lean against his shoulder. (Handsome Stranger +1)

""

Diamond Choice 6 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Another chance at the grand prize. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * Cozying up with me this fall. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * Getting back at Carson. (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 7 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * You're seriously incredible. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * Will Carson let you do that? (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * I wanna help you! (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 8 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Of course she'd like me! (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * I hope I get to meet her. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * She must be really proud of you. (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 9 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * How about a good luck kiss? (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * I'll stick with you this season. (Beautiful Contestant +1)

""

Diamond Choice 6 (Derek)
 * You missed the game more. (Derek +1)
 * You missed me more. (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 7 (Derek)
 * A smart move. (Derek +1)
 * Kinda risky... (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 8 (Derek)
 * So proud of you. (Derek +1)
 * Sorry you didn't win. (Derek +1)
 * My biggest fans. (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 9 (Derek)
 * I really wanna kiss you. (Derek +1)
 * I'm glad we're both back. (Derek +1)

""

Diamond Choice 6 (Bianca)
 * Are you excited to be back? (Bianca +1)
 * Did you miss me during the break? (Bianca +1)

Diamond Choice 7 (Bianca)
 * Steal all the screen time you want! (Bianca +1)
 * Spend every day with yours truly. (Bianca +1)

Diamond Choice 8 (Bianca)
 * Quite the adventure! (Bianca +1)
 * Chill, just how I like it. (Bianca +1)
 * Not as glamorous as yours. (Bianca +1)

Diamond Choice 9 (Bianca)
 * I'm terrified. (Bianca +1)
 * I'm not worried. (Bianca +1)

Diamond Choice 10 (Bianca)
 * Kiss Bianca! (Bianca +1)
 * Challenge her! (Bianca +1)

""

Slater +3 and Heath +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 24
 * So immature! (Slater +2, Heath -2)
 * My hero! (Heath +2, Slater -2)

Chapter Two: Guess Who's Back Choices
Vince +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit from Chapter 1.

Choice 1
 * Don't start any trouble, and we won't have a problem. (Vince +2, Handsome Stranger -2, Bianca +2, Derek +2)
 * Carson's the only one who wants you here. (Vince -2, Handsome Stanger +2, Beautiful Contestant +2, Bianca -2)

Ivy +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit from Chapter 1.

Choice 2
 * None of us are your 'friends'. (Ivy -2, Beautiful Contestant +2, Heath +2)
 * Are you gonna play fair this season? (Ivy -2, Handsome Stranger +2, Eden +2)
 * I'm ready for a clean slate if you are. (Ivy +2, Beautiful Contestant -2, Bianca +2)

Choice 3
 * Yvette (Slater -2, Yvette +2, Bianca +2)
 * Ronan (Ronan +2, Bianca -2, Slater +2)
 * Kiana (Kiana +2, Bianca -2, Slater +2)

Choice 4
 * Had his reasons for bringing them back. (Beautiful Contestant -2, Handsome Stranger -2, Derek +2)
 * Has gone mad with power! (Beautiful Contestant +2, Handsome Stranger +2, Derek -2)

Choice 5
 * Handsome Stranger (No effect)
 * Beautiful Contestant (No effect)
 * Derek (No effect)
 * Jen (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Relive your trip with Choice 5 selection! (💎20)
 * Focus on today's Challenge.

Diamond Choice 1 (Handsome Stranger)
 * But you really don't miss the spotlight? (Handsome Stranger +2)
 * I wish we'd done this months ago! (Handsome Stranger +2)

Diamond Choice 2 (Handsome Stranger)
 * I'm letting my bad side show. (No effect)
 * I need to play it smart. (No effect)
 * I'm not gonna change a thing! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Martini (No effect)
 * Champagne (No effect)
 * Mint Tea (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Us! (No effect)
 * The best season ever! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Cheers! (No effect)

Handsome Stranger +2

""

Diamond Choice 1 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * That grand prize check! (No effect)
 * To party it up! (No effect)
 * To spend as much of it as I can with you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * You've got a big heart under that tough exterior. (No effect)
 * You'd better still make time for some fun. (No effect)

Beautiful Contestant +2

Diamond Choice 3 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Be the cutest couple AME has ever seen! (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Make it to the Final Two together. I can feel it! (Beautiful Contestant +2)

""

Diamond Path (Derek): Derek +2

Diamond Choice 1 (Derek)
 * Totally freaking out! (No effect)
 * Ready to kick back and relax! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Derek)
 * Don't forget that I'm your biggest fan!
 * You'll need to show off your art first!
 * Will you draw me like one of your French girls? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Derek)
 * Religieuse (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Derek)
 * This is my favorite! (Derek +2)
 * What made you pick this dessert? (Derek +2)

""

Diamond Choice 1 (Jen) You will only get this choice if you won last season.
 * Handsome Stranger
 * Beautiful Contestant
 * Derek
 * Bianca
 * Teagan

Diamond Choice 2 (Jen) ''You will get either the second option or the third option depending on if you have romanced Jen in the past. If you have not romanced her, you will get the second option. If you have romanced her, you will get the third option.''
 * Taking it easy. (No effect)
 * Doing some traveling. (No effect)
 * Thinking about you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Jen)
 * I always knew we'd make things work. (No effect)
 * I feel the same. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 4 (Jen)
 * Martini (No effect)
 * Champagne (No effect)
 * Mint Tea (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Jen)
 * You! (No effect)
 * New York City! (No effect)
 * Both of us! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Jen)
 * Cheers! (No effect)

""

Choice 7
 * This idea sucks! (+Villain) (Ivy -2, Ronan -2, Kiana +2)
 * Bring it on! (+Sweetheart) (Slater +2, Yvette +2, Eden -2)
 * My partner better be as smokin' as me! (+Flirt) (Heath -2, Bianca +2, Derek +2)

Choice 8
 * Go over the Challenge rules again. (No effect)
 * Turn up the music! (No effect)

Choice 9
 * A good time is me, a beach, and three Mai Tais. (Beautiful Contestant +2, Ivy -2, Eden +2, Yvette +2)
 * Let's get this over with already. (Eden -2, Heath +2, Ivy +2, Ronan +2)
 * This is your last chance to turn around and go home. (Heath -2, Vince +2, Beautiful Contestant +2, Handsome Stranger +2)

Choice 10

This is a timed choice!
 * Stumble! (-Waltz)
 * Step back! (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct
 * Kick Vince's shin! (Vince -2) (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct

Choice 11

This is a timed choice!
 * Step on Vince's toes for three beats! (Vince -2) (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct
 * Step in place for two beats! (-Waltz)
 * Step in place for three beats! (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct

Choice 12

This is a timed choice!
 * Twirl! (-Waltz)
 * Bow! (Vince -2) (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct
 * Dip! (+Waltz) ⬅ Correct

Vince -2 if you got one or more -Waltz.

Vince +2 if you got all three +Waltz.

Ronan +3, Yvette +3, Kiana +3 if you wore the premium outfit.

Choice 13
 * Get to know the new contestants. (💎16)
 * Keep to yourself.

Diamond Choice 6
 * Yvette (No effect)
 * Eden and Heath (Eden +2)
 * Slater (Slater +2)
 * Kiana (Kiana +2)
 * Ronan (Ronan +2)

You will select all of these, this just determines the order.

Diamond Choice 7 (Yvette)
 * Try it! (Yvette +2)

Diamond Choice 8 (Yvette)
 * It must've been hard raising the kids on your own. (No effect)
 * Do you have your eyes on anyone new? (No effect)

Yvette +2

Diamond Choice 9 (Eden and Heath)
 * Eden's 'Present'

Heath +2

Diamond Choice 10 (Eden and Heath)
 * Take all this drama to the next level! (No effect)
 * Give each other another chance. (No effect)

Heath +2, Eden +2

Diamond Choice 11 (Slater)
 * Can appreciate a dramatic entrance. (No effect)
 * Wish I'd been there to admire the view... (No effect)

Slater +2

Diamond Choice 12 (Kiana)
 * Love gaming as much as you and I do. (No effect)
 * Like people who are passionate about their hobbies. (No effect)

Kiana +2

Diamond Choice 13 (Ronan)
 * Please tell me that's not a joke. (No effect)
 * What were you like back in Season 1? (No effect)

Ronan +2

""

Choice 14

This is a timed choice!
 * Sneak toward the kitchen! (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * Stumble into the wall! (Ivy -2, Vince -2)

""

Choice 15
 * Heath is obviously the weakest link. (Eden +2, Heath -2, Yvette +2, Bianca +2)
 * Eden, get over yourself already. (Eden -2, Kiana -2, Slater +2, Heath +2)
 * It's a little late to point fingers. (Kiana +2, Eden -2, Heath -2, Ronan +2)

Chapter Three: Back in the Saddle Choices
Choice 1
 * I'm gonna give Ivy another chance. (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * She'd better watch her back. (😈 +Villain)
 * I can't hold a grudge against a pretty face! (😘 +Flirt)

Choice 2
 * An arrogant bastard. (😈 +Villain)
 * My guilty pleasure. (😘 +Flirt)
 * Bad news. (❤ +Sweetheart)

Choice 3
 * Get some action. (😘 +Flirt)
 * Hang out with Adam and Mackenzie. (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * Put these losers in place. (😈 +Villain)

"" if you got at least 2 😈 +Villain.

''Like What You See? ''if you got at least 2 😘 +Flirt.

""if you got at least 2 ❤ +Sweetheart

"" if you got one of each answer.

Choice 4
 * I won't let him get under my skin. (No effect)
 * There's no way he'll mess with me after tonight. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Quit being such a diva, Vince. (Vince -2)
 * Don't let us interrupt the magic! (Vince +2)

Choice 6
 * Buy this item! (💎25)
 * No thanks. (No effect)

This item is called "Cowgirl Chic" if you are a female and "Rough Rider" if you are a male.

Ivy +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 7
 * Ivy wasn't bothering me. (Ivy +2, Ronan -2, Heath +2, Derek +2, Bianca -2)
 * Her opinion means nothing to me. (Ronan +2, Eden +2, Slater +2, Ivy -2, Yvette -2)

Kiana +3, Yvette +3, Derek +2, Bianca +3, Eden +3, Heath +3, Slater +3, Ronan +3, Beautiful Contestant +2, Handsome Stranger +2, Vince +3 if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 8
 * Whiskey. (No effect)
 * Sparkling water. (No effect)
 * Fruit Punch. (No effect)
 * Beer. (No effect)
 * Mint Julep. (No effect)

Choice 9
 * We can handle this ourselves, Vince. (Beautiful Contestant +2, Vince -2)
 * I'm sure Vince was just trying to help. (Vince +2, Beautiful Contestant -2)

Choice 10
 * Teach Beautiful Contestant to play pool! (💎18)
 * Rejoin the others.

Diamond Choice 1
 * Demonstrate how to hold the cue. (No effect)
 * Thrust the cue over your head like a sword! (No effect)
 * Hold her hands and show her. (No effect)

Beautiful Contestant +1

Diamond Choice 2
 * Maybe someone should knock him off it. (No effect)
 * He might not be all that bad... (No effect)
 * I'm glad I was here to help you. (No effect)

Beautiful Contestant +1

Diamond Choice 3

This is a time choice!
 * The striped ball! (No effect)
 * The solid ball! (No effect) ⬅ Correct
 * The ball at the edge of the table!

Diamond Choice 4
 * Bragging rights? (No effect)
 * A kiss? (No effect)

Beautiful Contestant +2

""

Choice 11
 * Is that... safe? (No effect)
 * Hell yeah! (No effect)

''The following three choices are random. The icons show up by the timer. ''

Choice 12

This is a timed choice!
 * Forward
 * Back
 * Right
 * Left

Choice 13

This is a timed choice!
 * Forward
 * Back
 * Right
 * Left

Choice 14

This is a timed choice!
 * Forward
 * Back
 * Right
 * Left

"" if you got all 3 correct.

"" if you didn't get all 3 correct ?

Choice 15
 * I didn't know you were such a badass! (Vince +2, Beautiful Contestant -2)
 * That bull should've tried harder. (Handsome Stranger +2, Vince -2.)

Choice 16
 * Tend to Handsome Stranger's injuries. (💎17)
 * Enjoy the rest of the date.

Diamond Choice 5
 * I'm gonna need to look at those bruises. (No effect)
 * Let me give you a hand you with that shirt... (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6
 * Ice the bruise. (No effect)
 * Kiss it better. (No effect)

Handsome Stranger +1

Diamond Choice 7
 * Letting him off easy. (No effect)
 * Very big of you. (No effect)

Handsome Stranger +1

Diamond Choice 8
 * Next time, don't let Vince win. (No effect)
 * How about a kiss? (No effect)

Handsome Stranger +2

""

Choice 17
 * This is too much pressure! (Derek +2, Ivy -2)
 * They picked the perfect (wo)man for the job! (Vince -2, Kiana +2)

Choice 18
 * Heath. (Heath -10, Eden +10, Ronan +2, Slater -2)
 * Eden. (Eden -10, Heath +10, Yvette -2, Vince +2)

""

""

Chapter Four: Sand, Sun, and Strife Choices
Choice 1
 * But we shouldn't stoop to his level. (Kiana +2, Beautiful Contestant -2)
 * So let's take him down together! (Beautiful Contestant +2, Kiana -2)

Choice 2
 * Buy this item! (💎25) (Beautiful Contestant +2, Kiana +3, Eden/Heath +3, Bianca +3, Yvette +3, Ronan +3)
 * Green Swimsuit (No effect)

This item is called "Belle of the Beach" if you are a female and "Blue of the Flamingo" if you are a male.

Choice 3
 * How soon can we start? (Derek +2, Eden/Heath +2, Vince -2, Yvette +2)
 * How do we know you won't play favorites? (Ivy -2, Beautiful Contestant +2, Handsome Stranger +2, Ronan -2)
 * What does this have to do with being Most Eligible? (Derek -2, Slater -2, Bianca +2, Ronan +2)

Choice 4
 * Can you repeat the rules? (No effect)
 * Let's get going already. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * Please tell me I can switch partners. (No effect)
 * I'm gonna kill Vince. (No effect)

Choice 6
 * Play nice with Vince. (💎15) (Skips Choice 11)
 * Do your best to ignore him.

Diamond Choice 1
 * A modern sandcastle. (Vince +1)
 * An elegant sandcastle. (Vince +1)

Diamond Choice 2
 * Why did you try out for AME? (Vince +1)
 * What makes you happy? (Vince +1)
 * What do you do for a living? (Vince +1)

Diamond Choice 3
 * Why are you picking fights with Handsome Stranger? (Vince +1)
 * Aren't you tired of being fake all the time? (Vince +1)

Choice 7 (Non-diamond only)
 * What do you need help with? (Vince +2)
 * Shut up.

Choice 8 
 * You should totally ask Kiana out. (Eden/Heath +2)
 * You're distracting them from the Challenge. (Kiana -2)

Diamond Choice 4
 * At least you're being honest. (Vince +1)
 * Your strategy is impressive! (Vince +1)
 * You're still a jackass. (Vince +1)

""

Vince +3, Slater +3, Derek +2, Handsome Stranger +2, if you are wearing the premium outfit.

Choice 9
 * Admire your sandcastle! (No effect)

Choice 10
 * Sneak away with Handsome Stranger! (💎20)
 * Sneak away with Beautiful Contestant! (💎20)
 * Sneak away with Jen! (💎20)
 * Sneak away with Derek! (💎20)
 * Wait for the results.

Diamond Choice 5 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Make him chase you. (No effect)
 * Deepen the kiss. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Handsome Stranger)
 * I came here for a lot more than sunshine... (Handsome Stranger +2)
 * Let's just relax on the beach. (Handsome Stranger +2)

Diamond Choice 7 (Handsome Stranger)
 * But Vince is the one who should be worried. (No effect)
 * I'd rather spend the Challenge with you. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Handsome Stranger)
 * I've got your back. Always. (Handsome Stranger +2)
 * Are you getting soft on me? (Handsome Stranger +2)

""

Diamond Choice 5 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Dive in. (No effect)
 * Put on a show. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Don't stop now... (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Let's keep making out. (Beautiful Contestant +2)

Diamond Choice 7 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Everything feels totally off the rails! (No effect)
 * Carson just needs time to find his feet. (No effect)
 * But at least you've got me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Beautiful Contestant) "Wild Among The Waves"
 * Who knew you had such a sweet side? (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * I know we will. (Beautiful Contestant +2)

Diamond Choice 5 (Jen)
 * Watch Jen strip. (No effect)
 * Undress Jen yourself. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Jen)
 * Heat things up. (No effect)
 * Just cuddle on the beach for now. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7 (Jen)
 * I wish be could do this all the time. (No effect)
 * But I don't want to get you in trouble. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Jen)
 * Don't worry. I know. (No effect)
 * It wouldn't hurt to hear it more often. (No effect)

""

Diamond Choice 5 (Derek)
 * Kiss me. (No effect)
 * Touch me. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 6 (Derek)
 * Pull him against you. (No effect)
 * Play hard to get. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 7 (Derek)
 * Keep going. (Derek +2)
 * Relax for a minute. (Derek +2)

Diamond Choice 8 (Derek)
 * My sexiness is impossible to resist! (Derek +2)
 * You jumped at the chance to live in the moment. (Derek +2)

Diamond Choice 9 (Derek) Derek +2
 * Could be your partner instead. (No effect)
 * Felt more confident about this season. (No effect)
 * Had stronger competition! (No effect)

""

"" if you and Vince won the challenge.

"" if Derek and Ivy won the challenge.

Diamond Choice 10
 * We could've won this with our eyes closed. (Yvette -2, Slater +2, Ivy -2)
 * This shows our partnership might just work after all... (Handsome Stranger -2, Vince +2, Ronan +2)
 * But I shouldn't have to share this win with Vince! (Eden/Heath +2, Vince -2, Handsome Stranger +1)

Choice 11
 * But we would've won if it weren't for Vince! (Kiana -2, Vince -2)
 * Your sandcastle looks awesome! (Ivy +2, Derek +2, Vince -2)
 * I guess it pays to have Carson's favor, huh? (Derek -2, Ivy -2, Vince +2)

Diamond Choice 11
 * Ivy's telling the truth. (Slater -2, Ivy +2, Yvette -2, Derek +2)
 * Someone's up to her old tricks... (Yvette +2, Ivy -2, Slater +2, Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * There's no use pointing fingers. (Slater -2, Ronan +2, Ivy +2, Bianca -2)

Choice 12
 * Check out the Date Card! (No effect)

Choice 13
 * I'm glad there's only room for winners on this Date. (😈 +Villain) (Eden/Heath -2, Yvette -2, Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * If these sexpots aren't going, I don't wanna go either! (😘 +Flirt) (Vince -2, Bianca +2, Ivy -2)
 * That seems a little harsh... (❤ +Sweetheart) (Slater -2, Eden/Heath +2, Kiana +2)

Chapter Five: Under The Sea Choices
Choice 1
 * I'm living for the drama! (😈 +Villain)
 * She'll probably charm her way out of it. (😘 +Flirt)
 * Something tells me there's more to the story. (❤ +Sweetheart)

Choice 2
 * It'll be awful saying goodbye to two people each week! (❤ +Sweetheart)
 * This change will do wonders for my game! (😈 +Villian)
 * The more bottoms, the better. (😘 +Flirt)

Choice 3 ''You can only pick one to talk about. How you talk about them is dependent on which personality trait you've chosen in previous choices and you will get a point for that trait. ''
 * Ronan
 * Slater
 * Eden/Heath
 * Yvette
 * Kiana

"" if you got at least 2 😈 +Villain.

"" if you got at least 2 😘 +Flirt.

"" if you got at least 2 ❤ +Sweetheart.

"" if you got one of each answer.

Choice 4
 * I wish it were just the two of us. (No effect)
 * But I'll take this over Piper any day. (No effect)

Choice 5
 * The cute fish! (Handsome Stranger +2, Ivy -2, Derek +2)
 * The screen time. (Eden/Heath +2, Vince -2, Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Those sweet waves. (Vince -2, Slater +2)

Choice 6
 * Get it together, Carson! (Eden/Heath -2, Ivy -2, Beautiful Constestent +2)
 * That means we get more time to relax! (Slater +2, Vince -2, Eden/Heath +2)

Choice 7 ''You will select all of these. This just determines the order.''
 * Beautiful Contestant
 * Handsome Stranger
 * Eden/Heath
 * Slater
 * Derek

Choice 8 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * The cutest thing I've ever heard. (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Super relatable. (Beautiful Contestant +2)
 * Kinda off-brand for you. (Beautiful Contestant -2)

Choices 9 (Handsome Stranger)
 * You wish we were partners? (Handsome Stranger +2)
 * You feel threathened by Vince? (Handsome Stranger -2)
 * You're worried about me? (Handsome Stranger +2)

Choice 10 (Eden)
 * So snobby. (Eden -2)
 * Like a dream! (Eden +2)
 * Too fancy for me (Eden +2)

Choice 10 (Heath)
 * Know your audience (Heath +2)
 * Grow up. (Heath -2)
 * That's genius! (Heath +2)

Choice 11 (Slater)
 * Don't you have other interests? (Slater -2)
 * Snorkeling is fun too! (Slater +2)

Choice 12 (Derek)
 * You're stuck with a crazy ex. (Derek -2)
 * She betrayed both of us last season. (Derek +2)

Choice 13
 * Snorkeling Gear (No effect)

Choice 14 
 * Explore the reef with Handsome Stranger! (💎18)
 * Explore the reef with Beautiful Contestant! (💎18)
 * Explore the reef with Derek! (💎18)
 * Explore the reef with Slater! (💎18)
 * Stay with the group.

Diamond Choice 1 (Handsome Stranger)
 * You're a pretty nice sight yourself... (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * Eyes on the prize, Handsome Stranger! (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 2 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Pufferfish! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Cutthroat pirates! (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * Reality TV contestants. (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * Star-crossed lovers... (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 4 (Handsome Stranger)
 * Gold Coin (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Handsome Stranger)
 * You're my hero! (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * We're gonna be rich! (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * What am I supposed to buy with one doubloon? (Handsome Stranger +1)

Diamond Choice 6 (Handsome Stranger)
 * It was way more fun with a partner. (Handsome Stranger +1)
 * The only thing it's missing is a kiss... (Handsome Stranger +1)

""

Diamond Choice 1 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Pufferfish! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 2 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Cute and deadly. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * But not as cute as you right now. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * I wish we could keep it! (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 3 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Slip an arm around her. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * Splash her! (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 4 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * Antique Necklace (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * It'll be the perfect keepsake. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * But I'd rather see it on you. (Beautiful Contestant +1)

Diamond Choice 6 (Beautiful Contestant)
 * I'll find the biggest pirate jewels you've ever seen. (Beautiful Contestant +1)
 * I can do you one better... a kiss. (Beautiful Contestant +1)

""

Diamond Choice 1 (Derek)
 * There's nothing more beautiful than the open sea! (Derek +1)
 * But I'm kinda terrified I'm gonna drown out here... (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 2 (Derek)
 * Pufferfish! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Derek)
 * Please. I laugh in the face of danger! (Derek +1)
 * In that case... Do you want to scout ahead? (Derek +1)
 * Then let's go together! (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 4 (Derek)
 * Carved Octopus (No effect.)

Diamond Choice 5 (Derek)
 * You're the best treasure hunter I know. (Derek +1)
 * But I don't have anything for you... (Derek +1)

Diamond Choice 6 (Derek)
 * A kiss? (Derek +1)
 * A piggyback ride? (Derek +1)

""

Diamond Choice 1 (Slater)
 * Way hotter in person (Slater +2)
 * More spontaneous in person (Slater +2)

Diamond Choice 2 (Slater)
 * Pufferfish! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 3 (Slater)
 * Though you're pretty cute too. (Slater +1)
 * You can't compete with that lil' guy! (Slater +1)

Diamond Choice 4 (Slater)
 * Antique Ring (No effect)

Diamond Choice 5 (Slater)
 * That's so sweet, Slater... (Slater +1)
 * Isn't it a little soon for that? (Slater +1)

Diamond Choice 6 (Slater) 
 * Kiss Slater! (Slater +1)
 * Push him underwater! (Slater +1)

Choice 15
 * Ivy would ruin it. (Ivy -2, Slater +2, Beautiful Contestant +2, Eden/Heath -2)
 * It'd be boring as hell! (Slater -2, Ivy +2, Vince +2, Derek -2)
 * We'd have a great time together. (Vince -2, Handsome Stranger +2, Derek +2, Ivy -2)

Choice 16
 * I would never do that! (Ivy +2, Beautiful Contestant -2, Derek +2)
 * You only have yourself to blame! (Ivy -2, Slater +2, Eden/Heath +2)
 * But you're making me wish I had! (Beautiful Contestant +2, Vince -2, Ivy -2)

Choice 17
 * Whiskey (No effect)

Choice 18
 * Not trying to poison me, are you? (Vince -2)
 * What's with the attitude adjustment? (Vince +2)
 * But I don't even like whiskey. (Vince -2)

Choice 19
 * It sucks to think Kiana might leave! (Eden/Heath +2)
 * But there's no point dwelling on it. (Eden/Heath -2)

Choice 20
 * We can find a moment before the ceremony! (💎15)
 * You'll figure something out.

Diamond Choice 7
 * Can predict the future (No effect)
 * Remind me how big the universe is. (No effect)
 * Are so romantic. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Eden)
 * Charm? (No effect)
 * Beauty? (No effect)

Diamond Choice 8 (Heath)
 * Super cute! (No effect)
 * So hilarious! (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Eden)
 * Eden can talk to Kiana. (No effect)
 * We can cuddle. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 9 (Heath)
 * Heath can talk to Kiana. (No effect)
 * We can cozy up with each other. (No effect)

Diamond Choice 10 Beautiful Contestant +4, Slater +4, Vince +4, Ronan +4, Ivy +4, Bianca +4, Yvette +4, Derek +4, Handsome Stranger +4, Eden/Heath +4, Kiana +4.
 * To win AME! (No effect)
 * For my friends to be happy! (No effect)

"Starlight, Star Bright"

Diamond Choice 11 (Won Challenge)
 * Bianca and Kiana (Ronan is deemed ineligible, Bianca is deemed ineligible)
 * Bianca and Ronan (Ronan is deemed ineligible, Bianca is deemed ineligible)
 * Yvette and Kiana (Ronan is deemed ineligible, Yvette is deemed ineligible)
 * Yvette and Ronan (Ronan is deemed ineligible, Yvette is deemed ineligible)

""

Choice 21 (Lost Challenge)
 * Bianca (Bianca is deemed ineligible)
 * Yvette (Yvette is deemed ineligible)

Choice 22 (Lost Challenge)
 * Kiana (Ronan is deemed ineligible)
 * Ronan (Ronan is deemed ineligible)