Talk:It Lives Beneath/@comment-3195798-20181206161909

Ok, I'm not buying the whole thing that the Society did in the last chapter. Spoilers ahead.

When Richard tried to kill the MC, Arthur literally saved the kid and he showed genuinely relief when seeing his grandchildren safe in this chapter. He showed in previous chapters that he indeed miss his daughter and was going to tell something to the MC in this chapter before the bodyguard caused a scene. He was denying involvement on the parents' death until Vincent put a hand on him.

Kelley literally has hidden Kyle's death in a previous chapter and suddenly he's pissed about another murder. And he seems out of character in comparison to how he was previously portrayed. I don't buy his explanation about Ned.

Considering what Astrid did in this chapter and how shocked she was about everything (in contrast to Vincent's and Kelley's angry reactions), I rule her out as a villain, but I'm not trusting the other two.