Talk:The Elementalists Choices/@comment-37261185-20190103040010/@comment-27680174-20190103222535

I feel like Atlas may get one eventually, but I'm 90% sure that Aster will end up being a villain.

I can list a couple reasons why:

1. Aster has had a very insignificant role so far. She barely says or does anything of relevance. She hasn't actively helped in the investigation, she doesn't go to Penderghast, she doesn't have an Attunement, so what's her purpose in the story other than freaking me out with her demon-eyes?

2. She went on some sort of rant against the Attuned a few chapters ago were it seems like she has a grudge against them in general.

I think that one of the Pend Pals could have been in her shop recently and she could have stolen their bracelet without them noticing. Or she used some sort of Nymph spell to make a duplicate? I think that The Dread could potentially maniuplate her. He's working on some sort of machine and we have no idea what it does yet. Maybe the purpose will be something Aster agrees with.