Talk:The Junior, Book 1/@comment-34142061-20180515153334/@comment-34381956-20180516201143

I agree that Nathan probably has LI immunity from being the bad guy, but I also think he's as responsible for the glue thing as Beau was. If he knew Beau likes mean spirited pranks, he should have gone with him to get the honey, or at least checked that it was actually honey that he bought. I hate that I picked all the "I'm not sure about this" and "I don't really want to prank her" options and MC still went along with it as if there was any good reason to even "give her split ends from washing out the honey" or whatever. I thought MC and Claire were almost-friends after the Chelsea/Manny thing.

I think it's a little weird that just after Nathan told MC about Beau's history Beau decided to fork another field. Beau is clearly the one PB wants us to think is behind everything (including the car accident, since "something happened at the beginning of summer that he won't talk about"), so I assume he's a red herring. If he is, then Nathan is the logical choice for actual bad guy (since he's setting MC on track for investigating Beau and we're taking Beau's pranking history at Nathan's word) except for the LI immunity thing. It's probably another Alpha who overheard Nathan telling MC everything that morning.