Talk:High School Story: Class Act, Book 1 Choices/@comment-33488829-20190117033954/@comment-1140743-20200812072847

After finally reviewing this scene again, I'm of the opinion that Ajay didn't need to apologize.

Ajay doesn't really accuse the MC of anything, he just says he's unsure what to believe given the new information and that the MC is at least clever enough to pull off what they're being accused of. The real problem is that the MC's argument actually contradicts Trevor, who Ajay has no reason to distrust. So, it's not a situation of the MC defending themself from baseless, wild accusations.

Erin says afterwards that Ajay, as director, isn't in a position to take a side without direct evidence - and he doesn't. Erin and Skye believe the MC purely based on friendship, not evidence.